Which kind of vacuum cleaner is best?
There’s no single type of vacuum cleaner that’s best for every home. Cordless stick vacuums are best for convenience and quick everyday cleaning, uprights suit larger carpeted areas, cylinder vacuums offer powerful cleaning and generous capacity, while robot vacuums are best for keeping on top of daily dust and debris with minimal effort.
“While there’s no single ‘best’ type, there is an ideal vacuum - and that’s one that matches your home," Katie Lilywhite, floorcare expert at AO tells me, adding: "Upright models are great for tackling carpets, cylinder vacuums work well on hard floors and are versatile, cordless vacuum cleaners excel for those quick zips around the house, and even robot vacuums can suit for the hassle-free crowd."
The right choice depends on your flooring, the size of your home, whether you have pets and how you prefer to clean. Here’s how the main types compare.
Related: The best vacuum storage bags, tried and tested
Upright vacuum cleaners
An upright vacuum cleaner is best for larger homes with plenty of carpet, particularly if powerful suction and a larger dust capacity are priorities. They're a more 'traditional' choice - ideal for large floor areas and powerful thanks to their mains power.
You won't run out of battery mid-clean, but you will need to unplug and replug as you move from room to room depending on the cord reach. They're not the lightest to lift, however, so may not suit those with mobility issues, but their capacity is usually much larger than a stick vacuum.
You can also pick up cordless uprights - such as the Gtech AirRAM 3 - but models like this are uncommon and tend to share more features with stick vacuums; the only main difference is that they can stand up unassisted.
Want to know more? Read our guide to the best upright vacuum cleaners.
Stick vacuum cleaners
A cordless stick vacuum is best for convenience, stairs and quick everyday cleaning. Stick vacuums tend to be lightweight, easy to manoeuvre and great for everyday use or quick clean-ups. Most are cordless, so you don't need to bother with cables - just remember to keep them charged between cleans.
The downsides? Smaller dust bins need emptying frequently, and some Mumsnetters are adamant that cordless models don't rival the suction power of their corded counterparts. For more, read our full guide on the best cordless vacuum cleaners.
Cylinder vacuum cleaners
A cylinder vacuum is a good choice if you prioritise powerful suction, capacity and cleaning reach over portability. These types of vacuums come in two parts - the main body on wheels and the suction head, joined by a hose. They’re often more powerful than sticks as they're corded, but they can be bulky to lug about. If you’re tackling big messes or larger homes, a cylinder vac is a good bet though. See our top picks in Mumsnet's best cylinder vacuum cleaners guide.
Robot vacuum cleaners
A robot vacuum is best for maintaining floors between deeper cleans, particularly in homes with lots of hard flooring or pets. They're clever little things that whizz around your floors using sensors and smart tech - great for keeping on top of daily dirt without even having to lift a finger. Some link to apps or smart home devices, but bear in mind: no robot vacuum can do stairs. See the tried-and-tested picks in our best robot vacuum cleaners and best robot vacuums for pet hair round-ups.
Handheld vacuum cleaners
A handheld vacuum is best as a secondary cleaner for small spills, cars, stairs and upholstery rather than as your main vacuum. Perfect for quick clean-ups, pet hair on sofas, or crumbs in the car, these vacuums are a handy <ahem> addition - but not a replacement for your main vac. We've focused only on standard vacuums on this page, but you can find out which models made the cut on our best handheld vacuum cleaner guide.
Is a corded or cordless vacuum cleaner better?
Another thing to consider is whether you'd prefer a corded or cordless vacuum cleaner. A cordless vacuum is generally better for convenience: they’re easier to carry between rooms, tackle stairs with and grab for quick clean-ups. The trade-off is limited battery life and usually a smaller dust capacity.
Corded vacuums make more sense if you have a larger home, lots of carpet or regularly do longer, deeper cleans. You won’t need to worry about charging or running out of power, and they often have larger capacities, but they’re generally heavier and less convenient to move around.
In our testing, we assess cordless battery life across different power modes and check whether suction drops as the battery runs down, while corded models are scored on cleaning reach.
Is a bagged or bagless vacuum cleaner better?
Bagged vacuums tend to hold more dirt and are often better for allergy sufferers (less dust flying about when you empty them), but you'll need to factor in the cost of replacement bags. Bagless models are more convenient day-to-day, but can be messier to empty.
How to choose a vacuum cleaner