Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Do women in the U.K. know or care about the threat to women’s and girls rights now they’ve voted labour?

1000 replies

Heylo · 05/07/2024 07:14

i know the tories record on public services are abysmal and bar some genuine believers like Kemi Badenoch the tories would likely go the trans route if they thought it would buy them votes. But, currently it’s the tories who offered to protect women and girls from the trans madness. My question is - which women voted in trans loving, women - hating Labour?

we can look forward to -

  1. continued gender ideology being pumped out in schools
  2. conversion ban - you better hope your child doesn’t start questioning their gender out loud because TRA ridden schools will be referring them to gender clinics and socially transitioning them now they have a mandate
  3. same sex attracted lesbians (myself included) it’s completely game over. Keep your head down and your mouth shut. Trans identified males and their female allies have already closed down every women only night. Same sex attracted women are now labelled bigots. We are no longer welcome in London’s LGBT soup community
  4. prisons - what happens to vulnerable women? They are already disbelieved and dismissed. Now they have to endure the staring and various forms of sexual harrassment that goes with being incarcerated with men

i can only hope our political landscape mirrors America and in the same way Trump will be voted back in this year, we will have The Tories being led by Kemi back in in 4 years time.

omg I can’t believe we have to kiss goodbye to women’s rights - for the next four years

back to my original question. Apart from TRA idealouges, why have women voted these clowns in? Is it that they prioritise the Tories terrible record on public services over this? Do some women not see it as a huge issue? would love to hear from some posters who voted Labour.

Thanks & stay safe out there, as women we have woken up to a a dark chapter in history today

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2024 16:18

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:02

You're only proving my point that you're more likely to have your privacy invaded by a GC woman demanding to ask you questions about your genitals than a man or a trans woman.

That is a weird fantasy you have about strangers asking about your genitals.

I said asking what sex you are. That is - or used to be -- a 100% normal, everyday question. Sure, the knowledge of your own sex comes from your knowlege of your own body including its genitals, but that really wasn't at the top of anyone's mind until TRAs starting making a big deal about sex being this big secret no one should be talkng about or thinking about.

Personally I find the idea that people should use different toilets based on what type of personality you have far far weirder than basing it on body sex!

Ironically, I was a fairly androgenous kid and there were plenty of times I was called "son" or indeed asked if I was in the right toilets. I said "no I'm a girl" and that was it. No one was on high alert back then because when it comes to sex and gender the idea that it was ok to lie what you want had not been popularised by TRAs.

Such a shame TRAs have only started worrying about women being challenged now, when they can leverage it for their own agenda, rather than worrying about this happening before they started pushing men into women's spaces when they would have been in a position to ralise that maybe they should just not start doing that in the first place.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/07/2024 16:18

eatfigs · 05/07/2024 16:12

"same-genital spaces" 😂

Of all the ridiculous things I've read today this has to be near the top of the list!

It's a very teenage male obsession / fantasy isn't it? Genital checks / genital spaces.
Never mentioned by women anywhere in the world until a certain type of man started demanding to access women undressing / otherwise vulnerable.

Helleofabore · 05/07/2024 16:19

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:08

No I'm simply suggesting women don't take it upon themselves to "pull up" someone who isn't bothering or interacting with them in any way and is simply trying to take a piss because you suspect they aren't a woman.

When I was a child, I was constantly asked if I was in the wrong toilets because I looked like a boy. Women and girls have always asked these questions because it is integral to our needs. In toilets, it is important for safety and privacy and dignity. In sports, it is vital for fair competition and safety.

Are you honestly trying to say that women and girls were never asked these questions before male access to single sex spaces and sports became an issue?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:19

Unless you're in the medical field or a sex worker, being so obsessed with complete strangers' genitals is not normal or necessary.

The only people with a genital obsession on this thread are the people banging on about how women shouldn't want single sex spaces.

Sloejelly · 05/07/2024 16:20

Cadela · 05/07/2024 16:17

Actually there’s quite a few butch lesbians on tiktok that say they’ve never experienced homophobia, but do experience rampant transphobia because they’re using women’s facilities and others think they are mtf!

If they are being mistaken for men who identify as women then that is not transphobia. That is being mistaken for men. Transphobia would be if they were mistaken for transmen and asked to leave.

RTHJ14 · 05/07/2024 16:20

Tinylittleunicorn · 05/07/2024 07:24

I'm concerned about the rights of women to have access to single sex spaces.

But I think poverty, access to education and employment, access to healthcare, social care, childcare, violence and rape perpetrated by "cis" men, access to justice etc - are also issues very important to women on which they have been very badly failed by the Conservatives and are likely to do better under Labour.

Edited

Absolutely my thinking too..

ChishiyaBat · 05/07/2024 16:20

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:16

Read through the thread I linked and there's pages of examples for you there. I'm not going to screenshot all 10 pages for you.

I have read the full thread, sorry I missed your link!

Whyisthatonthefloor · 05/07/2024 16:20

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/07/2024 15:59

Women wouldn't be on high alert in changing rooms and bathrooms and feel the need to pull up masculine looking females if this social contract of males staying out of such places weren't being broken down by them and other women due to male gender feelz. I very much doubt this happens a lot either.

it does happen regularly to gender non conforming women.

I’ve known butch friends harassed, threatened and security called because they don’t ‘look like women’ in female toilets.

There was also the lovely day a friend stripped down to her tank top to prove she was a woman with her own belongings and not in fact a man who had stolen a women’s debit card and driving licence ( the shop workers were threatening to call the police).

She had committed the offence of having a shaved head and a baggy jumper- they were very surprised to discover her DD bust 🤦‍♀️.

That’s not to mention the looks and mutters we put up with regularly in changing rooms or bathrooms.

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:21

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2024 16:18

That is a weird fantasy you have about strangers asking about your genitals.

I said asking what sex you are. That is - or used to be -- a 100% normal, everyday question. Sure, the knowledge of your own sex comes from your knowlege of your own body including its genitals, but that really wasn't at the top of anyone's mind until TRAs starting making a big deal about sex being this big secret no one should be talkng about or thinking about.

Personally I find the idea that people should use different toilets based on what type of personality you have far far weirder than basing it on body sex!

Ironically, I was a fairly androgenous kid and there were plenty of times I was called "son" or indeed asked if I was in the right toilets. I said "no I'm a girl" and that was it. No one was on high alert back then because when it comes to sex and gender the idea that it was ok to lie what you want had not been popularised by TRAs.

Such a shame TRAs have only started worrying about women being challenged now, when they can leverage it for their own agenda, rather than worrying about this happening before they started pushing men into women's spaces when they would have been in a position to ralise that maybe they should just not start doing that in the first place.

Again you're just ignoring the invasion of privacy and upset of walking up to a stranger trying to take a piss or deal with their period or a miscarriage or all the other things you point out women deal with in toilets and being asked what sex they are! When they aren't bothering you in any way and no doubt you're asking someone you don't believe looks feminine enough.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:21

It's a very teenage male obsession / fantasy isn't it? Genital checks / genital spaces.
Never mentioned by women anywhere in the world until a certain type of man started demanding to access women undressing / otherwise vulnerable.

YY. And people are free to draw whatever conclusions about the people using this rhetoric that they think are appropriate.

Humtum · 05/07/2024 16:21

greenpolarbear · 05/07/2024 16:14

I didn't vote Labour but I'm also not transphobic. It's one of the relatively few Labour policies I agree with.

In a couple of generations' time, people are going to be as horrified at the attitudes some people had to trans people as we are at the attitudes past generations had to gay people, and black people.

Unless you're in the medical field or a sex worker, being so obsessed with complete strangers' genitals is not normal or necessary.

Edited

This!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:22

If they are being mistaken for men who identify as women then that is not transphobia. That is being mistaken for men. Transphobia would be if they were mistaken for transmen and asked to leave.

Quite.

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:23

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:19

Unless you're in the medical field or a sex worker, being so obsessed with complete strangers' genitals is not normal or necessary.

The only people with a genital obsession on this thread are the people banging on about how women shouldn't want single sex spaces.

I'm not saying they shouldn't be there I'm asking you on a practical level how you enforce them.
I'm sure there's more instances of biological women being challenged as being men than actual male cleaners being challenged to prove they actually work there

Humtum · 05/07/2024 16:23

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:19

Unless you're in the medical field or a sex worker, being so obsessed with complete strangers' genitals is not normal or necessary.

The only people with a genital obsession on this thread are the people banging on about how women shouldn't want single sex spaces.

Incorrect.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:23

I have no interest in enforcing them. I want the social contract to be that people don't encourage men to use our spaces.

HeadNorth · 05/07/2024 16:24

Sloejelly · 05/07/2024 16:09

Joanna Cherry is SNP. She lost because she is SNP and people are sick and tired of the SNP.

That is my very point- outside of this board, it is an issue that has no traction with most people - certainly not enough to sway their votes.

Helleofabore · 05/07/2024 16:24

Humtum · 05/07/2024 16:10

On that - for a thread that is about protecting women and safety I've been
1 - called a male
2- called chat gpt
3- instructed how I should communicate on here "don't state what you can't define" (even though said item is a concept....)

Efforts to persistently undermine and invalidate different views.

Forever championing trans policy and EDI representation as part of healthy progressive debate. It's not here though.

I haven't seen you do much more than post weak evidence and tell people they are being 'unkind'. You personally have also attempted to undermine and invalidate other's views.

Most people on this board would support healthy debate. It can be argued that you have not engaged in this way on this thread. Obviously, you think you have.

ChishiyaBat · 05/07/2024 16:24

Cadela · 05/07/2024 16:17

Actually there’s quite a few butch lesbians on tiktok that say they’ve never experienced homophobia, but do experience rampant transphobia because they’re using women’s facilities and others think they are mtf!

I don't use tiktok so I would never get to see this, I was often mistaken for a boy when I was young, but back then it wasn't transphobic it was just a mistake, yes sure it offeneded me sometimes, but I didn't really care and I still don't. If men weren't in womens spaces now, it wouldn't be an issue, it would simply be a mistake, a mistake that plenty of women have experienced.

eatfigs · 05/07/2024 16:24

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/07/2024 16:18

It's a very teenage male obsession / fantasy isn't it? Genital checks / genital spaces.
Never mentioned by women anywhere in the world until a certain type of man started demanding to access women undressing / otherwise vulnerable.

Certainly is, also very telling that the "genital checks" people don't consider the option of male individuals choosing (or being incentivised) to do the right thing and refrain from accessing female spaces.

Melisha · 05/07/2024 16:25

Helleofabore · 05/07/2024 16:24

I haven't seen you do much more than post weak evidence and tell people they are being 'unkind'. You personally have also attempted to undermine and invalidate other's views.

Most people on this board would support healthy debate. It can be argued that you have not engaged in this way on this thread. Obviously, you think you have.

This is not true. Any time I have tried to engage I get accused of being a man or a TRA. I am neither.

Whyisthatonthefloor · 05/07/2024 16:25

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2024 16:18

That is a weird fantasy you have about strangers asking about your genitals.

I said asking what sex you are. That is - or used to be -- a 100% normal, everyday question. Sure, the knowledge of your own sex comes from your knowlege of your own body including its genitals, but that really wasn't at the top of anyone's mind until TRAs starting making a big deal about sex being this big secret no one should be talkng about or thinking about.

Personally I find the idea that people should use different toilets based on what type of personality you have far far weirder than basing it on body sex!

Ironically, I was a fairly androgenous kid and there were plenty of times I was called "son" or indeed asked if I was in the right toilets. I said "no I'm a girl" and that was it. No one was on high alert back then because when it comes to sex and gender the idea that it was ok to lie what you want had not been popularised by TRAs.

Such a shame TRAs have only started worrying about women being challenged now, when they can leverage it for their own agenda, rather than worrying about this happening before they started pushing men into women's spaces when they would have been in a position to ralise that maybe they should just not start doing that in the first place.

Ironically, I was a fairly androgenous kid and there were plenty of times I was called "son" or indeed asked if I was in the right toilets. I said "no I'm a girl" and that was it. No one was on high alert back then because when it comes to sex and gender the idea that it was ok to lie what you want had not been popularised by TRAs.

GNC women have been being hassled and threatened in female spaces for decades because of homophobia.

The thinking goes

‘manly women=dyke=pervert=looking at me=a threat to me’

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2024 16:26

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/07/2024 16:06

Right so in your opinion women who pull up masculine looking women, which never happens, are more of a problem than males entering women’s spaces and sports. How fucked up.

The first wouldn’t be happening without the second.

It's hilarious/tragic isn't it.

It's like saying the biggest crime in a mugging is committed not by the mugger mugging the victim, but by the victim treating strangers warily as a result.

Humtum · 05/07/2024 16:26

LilyBartsHatShop · 05/07/2024 16:10

@Humtum I'm not entirely sure what your more waffly sentences mean, so I doubt there's much backfire effect going on in my poor, dear, befuddled brain.
I read the comic you linked to. It's very well presented, I like the fonts and some of the pictures are nice. Also the way it uses Facebook-style scrolling to progress the argument / narrative / comic, it's well done.
I get American greats muddled and can never distinguish in my head Washington from Franklin or Lincoln. If it's true about enslaved people's teeth being used to make enslavers' dentures that is horrific - it's getting in the vicinity of those Nazi paperweights and lamps that were made from parts of murdered Jewish people's bodies. My only recommendation would be to recentre the humanity of people who were enslaved (and also the barbarity of people who were actively enslaving others, not just passively benefiting) in your language i.e. "enslaved person" rather than "slave."

I'm a bit sceptical of fMRI stuff, there is an unfortunate tendency for researchers to find what they're looking for - lots of reproducibility crisis happening there. Also the cod evo-psych section, really cannot stand that stuff (the caveman bit - seriously?).

I'm also wary of those who have a need to deconstruct what I "cherish most deeply" (to quote the comic). It's all clever-clever ivory tower, heartlessness posing as social justice. All that is wrong with twenty-first century activism, in my opinion.
I wanted to respond with a comic strip that I love - a Leunig comic which begins with a person on their knees worshipping before a cardboard box. Then a group of people come along and say, "Why are you worshipping a BOX?! Can't you see it's just a BOX??" And they tear the box to pieces, to prove their point. The final image is of the person on their knees worshipping before a cardboard box that has been taped together from the discarded scraps. Honestly my typing all this out is such a shame compared to the beauty of the cartoon itself.
All of which is a long winded way of saying, are you sure that link was for me?

Interested to know about the challenges to activism (one for another day) thanks for your mention of the comic strip - shall have a google!

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 16:27

eatfigs · 05/07/2024 16:24

Certainly is, also very telling that the "genital checks" people don't consider the option of male individuals choosing (or being incentivised) to do the right thing and refrain from accessing female spaces.

Considering there are posters like @Helleofabore endorsing the idea of sex verification in sports (which involved examinations hence me asking if she actually had read up on the process) that's why I'm asking how you want people to prove their sex

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/07/2024 16:28

I want all policies to state that women's spaces are for women, not men, regardless of identity. Woman - an adult female human being.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.