The quote was from Humza, in the clip linked in the OP - a man who seems very likely to be the next Scottish Minister. He is an idiot. There is no valid distinction.
Fake transwomen = transwomen = men
The rapist examples make this blindingly obvious. At least to anyone with an ounce of common sense (so not Humza then).
@ArabellaScott I think we need to be really clear on this. A male criminal who only ever comitted tax fraud, who is mild mannered and pleasant, can still cause alarm, fear, and distress to women who are locked up with him.
This too of course. But we still seem to be at a point where even rapists are considered to be people who can be legitimately placed in women's prisons as long as they are "genuinely" pretending to be women, rather than pretending to be pretending to be women...
Forbes and Regan, who are on the side of women and anti-GRR, have both had a lot of negative press, which Humza (who seems to be the current leadership's favourite) has not. Anyone might think there's a smear campaign going on.