I Would Do Anything

[3NAB]

Starting now - BBC1

gosh am bit torn tonight. Always thought jodie was outright star. But rachel and samantha were so so watchable. When I thought about paying money and all...

Sarah too nice and enunciated. Talented but agree re Mary poppins.
hope niamh and jessie deliver truly cracking and talented girls. Maybe not nancy but def career in this industry

i didnt think rachel was very good. i dont relaly like her.
jodie and sarah are really good but i spose there is more to take into consideration. i am just going by the sound they make!

glad ashley is gone though

Ashley still there about to sing now
will be feckin travesty if she stays tonight
doing Big Spender
ugh

oh yes,
oh god!

Asley hasn't gone. But hope she goes tonight. May favourites are Sam (but then I'm form the IOM) and Jodie.

oh , its sam i don't like in that case...

actually hey big spender suits her!

thought jessie good very good
Ashley oh different league from other girls
like geri halliwell versus celine dion

that's right!
she is like gerri halliwell, that is why she is so off putting.

think niamh might be in bottom two again. Poor lass but although I dont enjoy Sarah I think she is more commercial (wrongly imo) so public will triumph grr
but Ashley must go
god pray she in bottom two or arghh

Jessie was my favourite at the beginning - she just seemed so fresh and gutsy - I know everyone raved about her performance tonight but somehow I just don;t like her as an actress - stunning voice though

Loved Niamh tonight and Rachel again. Sam's somehow a bit brassy and showgirly.

Sam is a bit brash, I wish they would give her something a bit more subtle to do.

I think Niamh and Ashley will be the bottom two with Ashley to go. I don't quite get the Jessie thing, that wonky mouth thing drives me nuts!!

Right, I've watched the whole series bar the first episode, but I still don't understand what's going on with the Oliver bit. We seem to see the same set of boys doing all the activities and singing each week, and yet supposedly one of them gets picked each time. Can anyone explain to me how it's supposed to work please?

Niamh's fringe doesn't do her any favours.

I am loving this series, much to the digust of dp

Thought Jessie was fab tonight, have liked her all along

I felt very sorry for Ashley having to perform straight after Jessie

Thought she sounded 'tinny' and amateurish

If I'd closed my eyes I would have thought Jessie WAS Judy Garland!

Yes Jessie's great if you have your eyes closed, but I keep getting distracted watching for that awful thing she does with her mouth.

Sam from the IOW was sexy & held the stage imo.

I prefer it when Rachel does tortured and troubled, which makes her perfect for Nancy.

Ashley is not Nancy, she'd better suited to another role. Think it will be her and one of the blondes in the final two.

I'm amused by ALW and the awful things he does with his mouth (and face, generally)

And eugh to the way he felt the need to touch each and every one of them when working with them during the week.

I tought Jessie was excellent, and Sam was fab! really good dancer! And if she is brassy, or brash, well I'm sure Nancy was!!!! I think she is amazing for 17!

Rachel is a bit blah blah blah, hate Ashley, Jodie seems nice, but is a bit too 'ooh, Blackpool', Sarah is too nice!. Niamh, again sweet girl, but think she should give it 5 years for her voice to develop. Sam and Jessie are really unusual to have such powerful voices at 17/18.

obv tought was though - it's the Irish rubbing off!

GAHHHH!!! Can't type tonight. THOUGHT

I can see Jessie as Nancy, Sam as Nancy, maybe Rachel...

Niamh is great but just too young and almost vulnerable looking

Sarah... just NOT rough enough

Ashley... waaaaaaaaaaay behind now

Jodie??? Don't really 'like' her, IYSWIM

I havent posted on this one before, BUT I cant stand Ashley . Something about her, I cant stand!! anyone like her?

No, I really really don't like Ashley! Cold and hard as nails imo.