I was mourning missing out on the pink coat this morning but I've just spotted it on someone else and it didn't look that great. It was rather crumpled (material isn't all that thick) and the colour was a bit harsh on her so maybe I've made a lucky escape 🤷 this is what I'm telling myself anyhow and I'll probably still be checking all the Zaras in Antwerp and Paris manically.
That green coat is a bit of a risk, it would depend on the fabric content. Like Elle pointed out, mohair and alpaca can look drab in a photo and great in RL but if it's synthetic to look like mohair/alpaca (or cheap/low % alpaca) it will look fine for a bit but then look quite shabby before the coat is anywhere near being worn out. It looks quite wide and short, it's a silhouette that I usually avoid as it looks a bit Russia in the 90s/pregnancy coat on me. You could probably carry it off better, Red, but I'd check your own coats of you already have silhouettes like that and that you actually like them.
Interesting about the red coat not feeling quite modern. I've been on the lookout for awhile and my main complaint is that the colour is off, but mostly that they're rather prim. I'd love something like the Raey coat with a bit of texture in red but I've only really spotted the Max Mara teddy coat which I'd written off as I thought it was mad to be spending that much on a synthetic coat. Recently discovered it's silk and alpaca and I tried it on in blue, I'm trying heavily to ignore it due to ££££ but I'm talking myself into how I'd still wear it as an old bitty as it would fab with grey hair... Help me save me from myself 😬
Should arrive in Antwerp in a bit, hopefully the culottes are still in stock at Massimo Dutti...