I'm hoping they'll work well together, Elle, otherwise I might try revisiting an Aran again. Love the biscuity skirt, what brand is it? I have to say the lingerie departments seem to have the nicest materials these days, so maybe it could possibly work if it's weighty enough. Some brands do seem to be branching out as can be worn in or outside of the house, there's a Swedish brand Deitas that I was looking at in my camisole search, looked nice online, pricey though. One of the camisoles was named after me (Bo) so was somewhat tempted.
Ok dresses, Atlein, I can't see the added bulk you're seeing but at that price, it has to feel fantastically right from the get-go, so if not able to alter or exchange the size I'd say move on, lovely as it is.
The Reiss, not sure what the exact colour is, it doesn't read as emerald on my screen. You sound a bit meh about it, and the cling factor could be remedied with some smoothing undergarments but it does sort of read like a dress that should have been made in a heavier weight fabric to hang nicely. My concern would be about how it looks/moves when you sit down and clammy children's hands grab onto a swathe of it when trying to get your attention.
Third, I agree the proportions are off, a bit like you're wearing something from the petite range by accident.
Fourth is lovely, but I'd want to coordinate that with the other bridesmaids. If they're all in sleeveless party wear this might not blend in as seamlessly despite being in the same colour family?
Fifth, I already commented on previously, it looks better in this picture but I'm still not too sure about the black.
All in all, I like the Atlein best
Hairy (and anyone else heading to NYC), as promised my address list of places I'd intended to visit. Restaurants are mostly pizza and sushi, pizza speaks for itself but supposedly best sushi outside of Japan is now in NYC. Someone will have to let me know if it's really the case:
NYC Google Doc
And promise not to go crazy and save your money for NYC, here's my (mostly) tan 70s boots Shoptagr list that are all wrong for some reason or the other:
Shoptagr Boots AW17/18
Not a very exhaustive list but as you've noticed yourself there's not much out there.