As someone who've also fled DV with nothing but a bag I do feel your pain @Theydontwantme and I know too well the feeling in your stomach from when someone shouts at you. In the gentlest possible way though, I would say that each situation we are experiencing on this thread is different from the next, and that it's not always black and white in terms of when we should leave. Although it is good to hear all sides of the perspective and what you say may help someone who is sitting on the fence as to whether to leave ot not.
In regards to the general discussion amongst us all, around leaving, my thoughts are:
Should some of us have left earlier? When the kids were small enough to literally pick up and grab. Probably yes, but, some of us didn't or couldn't and now have kids old enough to likely protest, potentially even refuse to come with us. There was a thread last summer where a mother had finally left her emotionally abusive and possibly ND husband, for her 13 yo to then refuse to move with her and instead stay with the father. An acquaintance if mine is currently struggling as her 15 yo going to live with his abusive, ND father.
The stress of leaving is also immense and another acquaintance if mine had a health condition determine significantly once she finally left, meaning careering for her two young ND boys was an extreme challenge and she ended up quite unwell indeed.
It may also have taken years for some of us to realise how difficult these men are, we've been in the trenches raising ND kids with no village or support around us to even be able to raise our heads above the water for long enough to realise the extent of how bad the situation is. And even then, planning to leave can take literally years. I don't have anywhere to go (parents in another country and not in work as child not in school) and the situation is not bad enough for a refuge. What then?
Yes, some of the situations on here are clearly into abusive territory but it's bit always black and white as to what we should or can do.
I'm considering my options but right now I need to settle DD into a new school and work on my self a bit as now in some form of burnout due to the last few weeks being quite hellish in terms of school dealings, LA dealings and DD behaviours being challenging. Throw in ailing parents and DH new ASd diagnosis (on top of ADHD dx last year) into the mix and it's all a bit much.