Hi puggle - I attempted a vbac last time but wasn't successful unfortunately. Had an emergency section with my first after going in with reduced movement. Spent most of pregnancy two agonising over whether to go for a vbac or elcs.
Decided eventually to give it a go, with an elcs booked in for eight days overdue for if it didn't happen naturally, as advised by the hospital. Most doctors and midwives I spoke to were very balanced and didn't push me one way or another, though that didn't help my indecision!
Went into labour four days overdue, early labour and contractions for eighty hours what no real progression, went into hospital on the third day of contractions and stayed in overnight hoping to move to delivery, but after no real progression through the night I eventually ended up having the booked section the next morning anyway.
I was disappointed but after no sleep for four days just relieved to get baby out! The problem was because I didn't labour the first time, it was pretty much a first labour, and they were very reluctant to anything to help me along to reduce risk to the scar.
I'm glad I tried, but the section was fine and I recovered well. The only thing I regret was spending so much time agonising over whether to have to have the section or not as it seemed to be all I thought about in the latter part of my pregnancy. I didn't really want a c section recovery with a two year old, and also if I'm honest felt a bit of pressure to try and have the experience of a vaginal birth. But it was all fine in the end and i was luckily back on my feet fairly quickly and driving, doing the nursery run etc by the time my dh went back to work after paternity leave.
This time I am having an elcs with no discussion and not a second thought, and am much more relaxed, and resigned to the fact it's not meant to be for me!
So my only advice really as a failed vbac-er is to try not to let the decision take over your pregnancy or worry too much about it, as long as they get here the method doesn't really matter!
Good luck deciding. I am looking forward this time to know what is going to happen and when all being well!