Oh my God, seriously, do you lot ever stop talking???
Bit late as the debate seems to be done but GF, I do relaxed routine. From the day they were both born my two have had a bedtime, bath bottle bed. Moses basket in the room for the 1st couple of months. I was strict with feeds but had to adapt a bit cos if I tried 4hrs with ds1 I found myself spending the last 45mins putting his dummy in trying to keep him going. Changed it to 3 hrs and problem solved. Did a dream feed and he was fine. He fitted into our life.
Ds2 was slightly different, still did 3 hours but wouldn't take the dream feed. Didn't need it. Used a sling with him cos it was easier and he's not clingy.
GF does have good theories but as you've all said, you need to adapt them slightly for each child but I'm a strong believer in routine. It's never too early to stArt and its meant that I've been able to stay organised and have a life. The kids know where they are and don't argue.
Please can I join fbook??
Feeling proper shitty today, works crap, traffics crap, other drivers are all twats and I'm sick of mil sending me stupid name suggestions. Grrrr!!!