Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour asking me to take her to hospital appointments

343 replies

BecauseNothing · 02/10/2026 11:43

A neighbour has asked me to drive her to, stay with her and bring her home from 2 upcoming hospital appointments. The first is in 4 weeks time and the second the week after. I have said I can’t because I’m working and she has asked if I can book the time off. I haven’t replied but this seems cheeky to me after I’d said no. AIBU? I need my annual leave for things with my own family. She has people who visit her who I presume are family and friends but apparently has no one to go with her. I work full time at home and have children so with everything that comes with that I’m busy.

OP posts:
CatSquirrelDuck · Yesterday 22:28

Alee36 · Yesterday 22:25

You're not unreasonable for saying no. Or feeling how you feel.

If she is older and therefore vulnerable, this is very sad imo. She has perhaps overestimated the closeness of the relationship, or is of another era, where older people were looked after and prioritised collectively in the community, or she has no other options and is desperate. Asking for help isn't cheeky imo, it's a Doctor's appointment, she's not asking to be chauffeured around for a jolly.

Personally, I wouldn't hesitate to help an older isolated person in my community, but that doesn't mean that you have to.

She's not old and isolated. She doesn't want her own children to have to take personal leave days from work ... but happy to try to get the OP to do it.

newyearnoeu · Yesterday 22:45

Dixie81 · Yesterday 07:39

No matter how responsible you are, life doesn’t always go to plan. Not everyone can afford to live in areas with good public transport and things like health problems or disability can affect anyone. Old age especially tends to dramatically reduce a person’s social network. No matter how many friends you think you’ve built up, you’d be surprised how many will vanish if you ever become needy, We can’t control everything no matter how much we like to believe we can.

My reply wasn’t aimed at the OP. It was about the endless ‘Just get a taxi; Just get hospital transport’ comments, showing real ignorance and/or immaturity. OP is working so of course they cannot help this neighbour out and the neighbour shouldn’t have pushed it any further.

no, not everything goes to plan which is why sensible and responsible people take ownership of the things you can control. Things like where you live ARE usually within the control of most people. Getting older and less able to drive, and more likely to develop health issues is not some sort of surprise development nobody could be expected to have foreseen - it's a completely predictable, if anything almost inescapable, part of aging.

There are very few places in the UK as rural as the poster who referred to the only public transport being a bus that goes twice a week, which was who I was responding to. Living that rurally isn't some sort of accidental circumstance people fall into without realising, it's a very deliberate choice.

You can't get all the benefits of open space and quiet living and then do shocked pikachu sadface that there isn't a bus running 4 times an hour every day on the off chance you might want to use it once a year.

The very cheapest places to live aren't in the middle of the countryside miles from anywhere, they are in deprived areas, where there is public transport (albeit sometimes the sort you wouldn't want to get late at night) so don't play the poverty card.

AmberPeaches · Yesterday 23:42

Aiming4Optimistic · 02/10/2026 18:07

Tbh OP I couldn't leave that be now. I'd have to reply challenging her on why she thinks your time is less valuable than her children's. This would be the end of any amicable neighbourly relationship

Yes, this!! The absolute cheek of her….

nomas · Yesterday 23:56

Alee36 · Yesterday 22:25

You're not unreasonable for saying no. Or feeling how you feel.

If she is older and therefore vulnerable, this is very sad imo. She has perhaps overestimated the closeness of the relationship, or is of another era, where older people were looked after and prioritised collectively in the community, or she has no other options and is desperate. Asking for help isn't cheeky imo, it's a Doctor's appointment, she's not asking to be chauffeured around for a jolly.

Personally, I wouldn't hesitate to help an older isolated person in my community, but that doesn't mean that you have to.

Have you read the thread? The neighbour has children but she’s doesn’t want to ask them because of their jobs. She doesn’t mind asking OP though as OP only works from home. Hmm

nomas · Yesterday 23:57

Mitzuko · Yesterday 22:18

If you don't want to do it don't. No need to judge her for asking or yourself for denying.

We are free to choose.

Why worrying if it's right or not?

No guilt, you can't save the world

I do judge her for picking on a woman neighbour who works from home and asking her to take a day off work rather than asking her own children to book a day off work.

nomas · Yesterday 23:59

Roxy20000 · Yesterday 22:04

I totally agree with this, there is “how dare she ask” here that leaves a bad taste. My mum lived alone and died of lung cancer a few years ago. I was in poor health myself (also living alone) 150 miles away and housebound so I couldn’t help her. She went through chemo alone but neighbours were supportive. It was a different type of community I suppose. Makes me sad.

And it makes me sad that people are still picking on women and expecting them to book off annual leave to help a stranger.

All because the neighbour doesn’t want to bother her own kids and ask them to take a day off.

Shinyandnew1 · Today 00:01

Alee36 · Yesterday 22:25

You're not unreasonable for saying no. Or feeling how you feel.

If she is older and therefore vulnerable, this is very sad imo. She has perhaps overestimated the closeness of the relationship, or is of another era, where older people were looked after and prioritised collectively in the community, or she has no other options and is desperate. Asking for help isn't cheeky imo, it's a Doctor's appointment, she's not asking to be chauffeured around for a jolly.

Personally, I wouldn't hesitate to help an older isolated person in my community, but that doesn't mean that you have to.

So, you’d be happy to help any/all nearby elderly people, would you? You will happily use your annual leave to help them to all their appointments, so that they don’t need to even ask their actual friends or family?

nomas · Today 00:01

BeGutsyGoldMoose · Yesterday 19:40

If she is about to undergo treatment for cancer, she might not want her family to know. She should be entitled to hospital transport if she is unable to drive. I do hope it's nothing serious. My late MIL didn't want us to know and we didn't find out she had cancer until after she passed away.

So it’s right for neighbour to protect her own family by taking up OP’s precious annual leave that she pays thousands for? NO.

Alee36 · Today 00:21

Shinyandnew1 · Today 00:01

So, you’d be happy to help any/all nearby elderly people, would you? You will happily use your annual leave to help them to all their appointments, so that they don’t need to even ask their actual friends or family?

Absolutely. I would. I love the elderly, and feel a strong sense of community and collective responsibility. OP doesn't have to feel the same and nor do you. No one asked OP to help any and all, it was a neighbour who asked her, not a passing stranger.

Perhaps her family don't help her and she's embarrassed to say that, maybe the relationships are strained. Maybe she doesn't want them to know she's ill. Maybe she's a chancer.....or mumsnettter's favourite 'CF', but that wouldn't be my default position, personally, though it does seem to be the Mumsnet concensus.

Wooky073 · Today 00:30

when i needed an op I called on friends to help but in a way that caused them the least inconvenience - once friend dropped me in, another picked me up. I didnt expect anyone to stay with me. I arranged a family member to look after me the first few days post op. Its a bit inconsiderate that she is putting it all on you and asking you to use your leave up on her. Maybe you could offer a lift in or lift home but say thats all you can do.

Oldwmn · Today 01:17

kxeil · 02/10/2026 11:47

She was entitled to ask you and you are entitled to say no.

This is the correct answer.

Oldwmn · Today 01:22

Voneska · Yesterday 15:33

I dont know what country you are in but The UK provides FREE transport for sick patients to hospital, and return trips also. It is a fully equipped, disabled, wheelchair assesable mini bus. Which can be arranged through her GP Surgery.

Are you talking about Patient Transport? I was advised to get them involved by the clinic I had to attend over a year ago. Still no callback. Fortunately, it turned out to be unnecessary.
I wouldn't have dreamt of asking a random neighbour though!

denzel washington GIF
Daygloboo · Today 01:55

summertree1 · 02/10/2026 11:51

You’re not being unreasonable not to take her but don’t be unkind about it. She wouldn’t be reaching out to you if she had someone to take her, it’s quite sad really.

Just send her a polite reply and maybe recommend she checks with the hospital if there is any community support that can help her (in my area there is).

Yes. Especially if she is old..That is sad..If she is old, Age UK could help.

SquirrelsEatingConkers · Today 02:54

Why are you even questioning this? She's a CF. She can get a taxi or arrange hospital transport.

99bottlesofkombucha · Today 04:57

Roxy20000 · Yesterday 22:04

I totally agree with this, there is “how dare she ask” here that leaves a bad taste. My mum lived alone and died of lung cancer a few years ago. I was in poor health myself (also living alone) 150 miles away and housebound so I couldn’t help her. She went through chemo alone but neighbours were supportive. It was a different type of community I suppose. Makes me sad.

I think asking was fine, but following up the ops no with suggesting she use annual leave was taking the piss. Any working mum with children knows how annual leave is 125% measured out for the kids needs. I buy leave to manage.

in the context of she has family but they work, even just asking a neighbour who is a working mum is really taking the piss. If you want favours from your neighbours, don’t treat them like they are disposable. None of these warm it takes a village comments acknowledge that. It takes a village goes both ways.

Tanjamaltija · Today 05:28

Those of us who work from home / do voluntary work are assumed to be able to drop everything at a moment's notice, or arrange for someone to take over our duties. It is not so. Tell this person that your time is limited, because you have responsibilities and deadlines, and you cannot squander it on to-ing and fro-ing.

FluffyBoots · Today 05:50

BecauseNothing · 02/10/2026 17:59

She has replied to say she’ll have to ask her children if they can go with her but she doesn’t know if they’ll be able to because of their work. 🤯

WTF? So her children can't take time off, but she expects you to?

This is all astonishing. There are options. NHS do hospital transport, which she might be eligible for. There's also Uber and buses. I had to go for some hideous investigations a couple of days ago. I didn't presurise family members of friends.

However, it's really not your problem.

FluffyBoots · Today 05:56

Shinyandnew1 · Today 00:01

So, you’d be happy to help any/all nearby elderly people, would you? You will happily use your annual leave to help them to all their appointments, so that they don’t need to even ask their actual friends or family?

@Alee36, your response is astonishing. OP seems like a lovely and supportive lady. Why on earth should she take time off to run her neighbour around? Honest to God, I do sometimes wonder. The neighbour is being really invasive, and appears to be trying to bully her into doing this run for her.

you don't need to do this OP. It won't make you a horrid person.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page