Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take an extra sibling if not allowed? Super Selective Grammar School visit.

216 replies

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 07:33

DS is in year 5, currently preparing for 11 plus for grammar schools in Sutton. One of the schools has a ticketed visit early next week. both of us and DS1 want to see the school (if he gets offered a place it will be very difficult for us to decide having not all seen it) however we have no one to watch our younger DS (yr 2). It says 3 tickets per family, but I’m wondering if IWBU to bring DS2 as we are not sure how to handle it otherwise

OP posts:
Floppyearedlab · Yesterday 12:28

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 12:08

The thing is it’s not really an emergency, where of course we would ask neighbours or friends. DS (age 7) has friends he could go to for a play date but I feel quite cheeky asking late into evening (we would be back by 8pm) which is past bed time for some of his friends with younger siblings. There are mixed views on the grammar system amongst both friendship groups so it would be viewed as cheeky amongst those I could ask for other reasons.

ive never needed to use a babysitting agency before - do people really leave their kids with at hoc strangers, even for a few hours?

If they have to they do.
However we use other options first. Like friends and trusted neighbours.
In this scenario I would pay my colleague's teenager to sit with my kid. They would just play/watch TV, I'd leave food out for them and then take her home. 8 pm is not like 1 am.

Schnapper · Yesterday 13:16

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 12:08

The thing is it’s not really an emergency, where of course we would ask neighbours or friends. DS (age 7) has friends he could go to for a play date but I feel quite cheeky asking late into evening (we would be back by 8pm) which is past bed time for some of his friends with younger siblings. There are mixed views on the grammar system amongst both friendship groups so it would be viewed as cheeky amongst those I could ask for other reasons.

ive never needed to use a babysitting agency before - do people really leave their kids with at hoc strangers, even for a few hours?

Ask one friend who has a hands on partner. We swapped favours quite a lot for this kind of early evening timeslot. Either guest child comes over and you keep the older ones up a bit in front of a film, or one partner puts own kids to bed and the other goes over and babysits at guest child's house. We used to take it in turns to do bedtime by this age so it was very little imposition to spend a couple of hours on a friend's sofa. And if it's easier for them to have son over and treat it as a long playdate, that's fine too. Whatever is easiest for babysitting parents.

You're going to have to navigate the difference of opinion over grammar schools one way or another. All of you will need to do school visits imminently, and you have a whole summer hols ahead where you can return any favours.

Piglet89 · Yesterday 13:16

Do people really leave their kids with ad hoc strangers, even for a few hours?

Yes, of course they do - otherwise such services wouldn’t even exist!

YourShyLion · Yesterday 13:21

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 07:47

We are really undecided if we want DS to go to this particular school though. I do think we both need to see it.

It's surely your child's choice if he wants to go or not so one parent will be more than ample.

fivepastmidnight · Yesterday 13:25

These type of posts really annoy me this is what we've been told but we want it to not apply towards us and we've left it till last minute.
If every single person had the same attitude that potentially means lots of other people with lots of other children Or do you think you are literally the only one who might have childcare problems.
I'm assuming they haven't only just told you about this open day so you've had time to arrange childcare or decide between you who goes and who stayed with the other child. Presumably if you go you can collect the information ask any questions and explain it all to your husband and vice versa. You may want both of you to go but if you can't arrange childcare then you can't can you.

PestoPastaLife · Yesterday 13:32

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 12:08

The thing is it’s not really an emergency, where of course we would ask neighbours or friends. DS (age 7) has friends he could go to for a play date but I feel quite cheeky asking late into evening (we would be back by 8pm) which is past bed time for some of his friends with younger siblings. There are mixed views on the grammar system amongst both friendship groups so it would be viewed as cheeky amongst those I could ask for other reasons.

ive never needed to use a babysitting agency before - do people really leave their kids with at hoc strangers, even for a few hours?

I used to work for an ad hoc nanny agency and would literally turn up on the doorstep, a 10 minute briefing from the parent and be left with anything from 2 month old twins to a heap of tweenagers and just be expected to get on with it!

In terms of your actual question - they will have other open days/evenings that aren’t aimed at Year 5 parents in the autumn term. Ring them to find out about these dates. For this open evening, just one parent goes with DS. Or take DS2 but be prepared for tutting and not letting him in.

arethereanyleftatall · Yesterday 13:37

NameChanger206 · Yesterday 12:08

The thing is it’s not really an emergency, where of course we would ask neighbours or friends. DS (age 7) has friends he could go to for a play date but I feel quite cheeky asking late into evening (we would be back by 8pm) which is past bed time for some of his friends with younger siblings. There are mixed views on the grammar system amongst both friendship groups so it would be viewed as cheeky amongst those I could ask for other reasons.

ive never needed to use a babysitting agency before - do people really leave their kids with at hoc strangers, even for a few hours?

Of course people use paid for childcare, it’s why it exists. In fact, many people use teenagers quite happily for this - both my dds have more requests for babysitting jobs than they have time for. And one up from that, of course people use proper childcare where the sitters have to go through the usual DBS etc Your question was passive aggressive and sneery since it’s obvious they do. They exist for reasons like this, for the unentitled people who realise that rules apply to them too.

with regards to friends, I would say my friends and I probably on almost a weekly basis would be requesting play dates from each other for one reason or another. We all reciprocated so it was all fine.

PerkyPinkZebra · Yesterday 13:42

Unlikely to be allowed. Arrange childcare/friend to watch younger child and if impossible 1 parent will need to take older child and then discuss with the parent unable to attend.

If yr5 and won't be attending the school until yr7 there will be other opportunities to visit the school.

Trainup · Yesterday 14:12

Just ask a friend to come and babysit. Explain why and that you’d be happy to pay them or return the favour etc.

Macaroni46 · Yesterday 14:16

ThanksItHasPockets · Yesterday 11:12

It may be ‘noticed’ but it will have no bearing on the admissions process. It’s remarkable how deep these misconceptions run, even amongst parents with children in these schools.

Actually it can have an impact on the selection process. If there are two places available, the child whose parents bent the rules will be passed over.

noshade · Yesterday 14:18

Macaroni46 · Yesterday 14:16

Actually it can have an impact on the selection process. If there are two places available, the child whose parents bent the rules will be passed over.

Oh stop it 😂

minipie · Yesterday 14:19

Macaroni46 · Yesterday 14:16

Actually it can have an impact on the selection process. If there are two places available, the child whose parents bent the rules will be passed over.

Pretty sure grammars have strict rules on how they offer places and can’t take things like this into account.

Private, yes possibly the annoying parents with the extra child might get noted, but still unlikely.

LassitersLegend · Yesterday 14:23

I can see that you have three options, take him with you, one parent goes and the other stays with the younger child, or if possible book your youngest into after school club.

Nicelynicelyjohnson · Yesterday 14:24

WeatherOrNothing · Yesterday 11:06

Youre not clued up to how these things work op. My kids are in Super selective London schools and little things like this are noticed. It’s ticketed so your name will be marked off a list and you will be handed name tags.

Attended an open day recently where it stated that no kids were expected to be present(meaning the prospective child)and it was two places per family. So clearly reading in between the lines it meant just parents and definitely no siblings.

One lady brought her child and must have thought 2 meant any two people. Child was quite disruptive and kept running back and forth for the breakfast spread. The panel of staff giving the talk were disrupted a few times…and noticed.

So you have some options. Why isn’t your Y2 in school? Surely he can have a play date at his friends?

Why would it matter if it was noticed?

I mean, noticed and told you couldn't bring them in as one thing but are you suggesting they would hold it against the child long term?

NiftyKoala · Yesterday 14:28

You need to get a sitter or one of you stays home.

Citadelica · Yesterday 14:33

If it were me I'd just go with my DC and feedback to DH how the school was.

In fact that is what I did when visiting my DCs' Non-Selective Comprehesive School.

ThanksItHasPockets · Yesterday 15:02

Macaroni46 · Yesterday 14:16

Actually it can have an impact on the selection process. If there are two places available, the child whose parents bent the rules will be passed over.

I wouldn’t ordinarily engage with this kind of pure fiction but for the benefit of anyone else reading, this is untrue.

Macaroni46 · Yesterday 15:41

ThanksItHasPockets · Yesterday 15:02

I wouldn’t ordinarily engage with this kind of pure fiction but for the benefit of anyone else reading, this is untrue.

I’ve worked on admissions teams in selective schools. I’m not making it up!

Thanksforyourlackofthought · Yesterday 15:45

If you had 3 tickets for a concert, would you assume 4 could get in?

twoshedsjackson · Yesterday 16:08

At this early stage in your relationship with the school, I feel it would be unwise to self-identify as That Parent.......after all, the school is, as you say, highly selective, so taking their pick.
A cautionary tale from many decades ago. A girl in my class, as clever if not cleverer than me, was going for the most sought-after grammar school locally, (back in the day when little Londoners still sat the 11+). She was quite a mousy little thing, probably because her DM was, er, strong minded. It was one of the "baby bulge" years, and the headmaster advised my parents that the competition would be particularly tough numbers wise, recommending a slightly less prestigious grammar school, which worked out well for me.
My classmate's DM forged ahead regardless, and then insisted on sitting in on her daughter's interview with a member of staff, which was apparently part of the school's admission policy. Having thus thoroughly drawn attention to herself, she was livid when other girls gained places while her daughter didn't, to the extent of berating some other parents. I don't know where she ended up going.

Nicelynicelyjohnson · Yesterday 16:10

twoshedsjackson · Yesterday 16:08

At this early stage in your relationship with the school, I feel it would be unwise to self-identify as That Parent.......after all, the school is, as you say, highly selective, so taking their pick.
A cautionary tale from many decades ago. A girl in my class, as clever if not cleverer than me, was going for the most sought-after grammar school locally, (back in the day when little Londoners still sat the 11+). She was quite a mousy little thing, probably because her DM was, er, strong minded. It was one of the "baby bulge" years, and the headmaster advised my parents that the competition would be particularly tough numbers wise, recommending a slightly less prestigious grammar school, which worked out well for me.
My classmate's DM forged ahead regardless, and then insisted on sitting in on her daughter's interview with a member of staff, which was apparently part of the school's admission policy. Having thus thoroughly drawn attention to herself, she was livid when other girls gained places while her daughter didn't, to the extent of berating some other parents. I don't know where she ended up going.

It doesn't work like this any more (if it ever did). State schools have very particular rules to follow (even grammars) and could not possibly use "brought an extra child to an open evening" as a reason to exclude.

twoshedsjackson · Yesterday 16:15

I can also support @Macaroni46 's assertion. At the last school where I taught, we had an activity morning for prospective pupils, and they were observed as they participated in a Games session, an IT session, an Art session and a Music session.
As you can imagine, these are parts of a normal school day where youngsters show up in their true colours, and if you are choosing between two children, their reaction to slightly more freedom can be telling....

Nicelynicelyjohnson · Yesterday 16:17

twoshedsjackson · Yesterday 16:15

I can also support @Macaroni46 's assertion. At the last school where I taught, we had an activity morning for prospective pupils, and they were observed as they participated in a Games session, an IT session, an Art session and a Music session.
As you can imagine, these are parts of a normal school day where youngsters show up in their true colours, and if you are choosing between two children, their reaction to slightly more freedom can be telling....

Was this a state grammar?

twoshedsjackson · Yesterday 16:23

Nicelynicelyjohnson · Yesterday 16:17

Was this a state grammar?

In this case, no, it was an independent, but however many rules there are for a state grammar, all the people doing the selection have to do is state, truthfully, that they have filled all available places.

stichguru · Yesterday 16:26

3 tickets
3 people
obviously DON'T