Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you know about this other attempted beheading?

160 replies

Whiski · Today 09:56

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr7pg7nk53go

First I ever heard of it was yesterday.

People act like it’s only non white people that do this.

A police mugshot of Alina Burns, wearing a black hooded jacket and a grey T-shirt. She has blue eyes and her blonde hair is closely shaven. She is standing against a light grey background, looking ahead with a blank expression.

Father of jailed neo-Nazi teenager says 'everyone failed her'

Alina Burns, 19, was jailed in May for attempting to behead a barber.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr7pg7nk53go

OP posts:
CarbootJunction · Today 15:41

The point is, we can barely cope with our own nutcases; we really don't need to open our borders to more of them.

Sskka · Today 15:41

CarraghInish · Today 15:35

I’m still a bit suspicious that many of the comments on one of those sides are not written by real people. VERY quick to respond, lots of buzzwords, short answers, inflammatory digs at other posters to try and stir things up. Or maybe I am just stupid to believe that real people would be less one dimensional?

Which side? You could be talking about either tbh.

LuckyHazelFox · Today 15:44

Sskka · Today 15:41

Which side? You could be talking about either tbh.

Think it's clear which sides she's talking about. How dare people have quick thinking and typing skills. They can't be real, have to be bots. Some really do live in bubbles.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 15:46

Persephonia1966 · Today 15:30

Because people keep changing their stories on what the anger is about. Or, alternatively everyone is consistent but has their own separate reason for "the anger". And it's ever shifting according to opportunity.
Eg today "the people" are angry that current immigration is bringing in more people to commit violent crime on top of the British people we can't do anything about. Yesterday "the people" were angry at Novak's killer even though he was born in the UK. When the 3 little girls were attacked "The People" were first very angry that the attacker had come over in a boat and it was about illegal immigration. Then when it turned out he was born in Wales "The People" were angry that hisnparents were allowed to come here.
"The People" were angry that the Belfast attack was being underplayed by the media but when it was pointed out that similar crimes received the same or less publicity it turned out the real reason "The People" are angry is because immigration is bringing in more violent people to add to the people we have.

The people were angry at overall migration numbers and how that affects demographics/housing/enployment but when migration numbers went down it turned out not to be overall migration numbers that were .asking people angry but the types of people. Sometimes the wrong type of people includes Eastern European. Sometimes they are the right type of person and the wrong type is Muslims. Etc.

Do you live in an area of high immigration. I do. The landscape of my home town has changed out of all recognition. There is overcrowding. There is poverty. The crime rates have soared, you are not safe if you live anywhere near the migrant housing facilities. I think what you’ve left out of the long list of changing reasons for people’s anger, is probably the real one. That they have concerns about immigration, based on lived experience. They see the things politicians tell them are not happening, actually happening in front of them. They have experience for themselves the contempt with which a lot of migrants hold us and are resentful.

The asylum system is broken and unfit for purpose. That’s what this incident and others before it highlights very clearly - this man was a failed asylum seeker, given leave to remain. Had he not, this incident wouldn’t have happened. And what do we get from government each time this happens - ‘violence isn’t the answer’ and ‘this is the work of far right thugs’. That argument isn’t going to work for much longer. You can’t stand there wringing your hands, blaming the very people the system has let down for its’ failure.

Persephonia1966 · Today 15:48

ThreadGuardDog · Today 15:46

Do you live in an area of high immigration. I do. The landscape of my home town has changed out of all recognition. There is overcrowding. There is poverty. The crime rates have soared, you are not safe if you live anywhere near the migrant housing facilities. I think what you’ve left out of the long list of changing reasons for people’s anger, is probably the real one. That they have concerns about immigration, based on lived experience. They see the things politicians tell them are not happening, actually happening in front of them. They have experience for themselves the contempt with which a lot of migrants hold us and are resentful.

The asylum system is broken and unfit for purpose. That’s what this incident and others before it highlights very clearly - this man was a failed asylum seeker, given leave to remain. Had he not, this incident wouldn’t have happened. And what do we get from government each time this happens - ‘violence isn’t the answer’ and ‘this is the work of far right thugs’. That argument isn’t going to work for much longer. You can’t stand there wringing your hands, blaming the very people the system has let down for its’ failure.

Ok so now your angry at me.
If immigration is why people are angry why were people also angry at the Southport murder? Given he was born here.

DuncinToffee · Today 15:49

ThreadGuardDog · Today 15:46

Do you live in an area of high immigration. I do. The landscape of my home town has changed out of all recognition. There is overcrowding. There is poverty. The crime rates have soared, you are not safe if you live anywhere near the migrant housing facilities. I think what you’ve left out of the long list of changing reasons for people’s anger, is probably the real one. That they have concerns about immigration, based on lived experience. They see the things politicians tell them are not happening, actually happening in front of them. They have experience for themselves the contempt with which a lot of migrants hold us and are resentful.

The asylum system is broken and unfit for purpose. That’s what this incident and others before it highlights very clearly - this man was a failed asylum seeker, given leave to remain. Had he not, this incident wouldn’t have happened. And what do we get from government each time this happens - ‘violence isn’t the answer’ and ‘this is the work of far right thugs’. That argument isn’t going to work for much longer. You can’t stand there wringing your hands, blaming the very people the system has let down for its’ failure.

Is it asylum seekers you think are the issue? Or immigrants from certain countries?

I am an EU immigrant, have I changed the landscape of my town?

People usually say 'oh I don't mean people like you'

dottiehens · Today 15:52

Dahliasrule · Today 15:12

The point is there is only an outcry and rioting causing damage, fear and possible threats to life in this latest incident. This is because the climate has been primed for this by people like Nigel Farage nd Tommy Robinson who highlight such unforgivable and shocking attacks such as that by the Sudanese refugee. They are conspicuously quiet as mentioned by another poster when it is a white, far right perpetrator because it does not suit their narrative. Whilst both acts are to be deplored, it is equally deplorable to stir up hate that causes others to fear for their lives. Those are not the values I want for our British society. Show disgust, anger at the perpetrators and compassion for the victims. If action is needed, make it peaceful and productive.

For me is clear. People are given a hand in the UK and more and more we see them are just thugs, murderers and not even trying to adapt to this country. There is not selection or criteria. It is open for all. It is seriously a security risk for decent citizens. Including decent migrants and their children. As like the victims in Stockport. Stop trying to defend thugs and criminals. It is offensive to collude decent migrants with those pieces of shit killing in our streets.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 15:59

Persephonia1966 · Today 15:48

Ok so now your angry at me.
If immigration is why people are angry why were people also angry at the Southport murder? Given he was born here.

Because of misinformation being spread online. Pure and simple. Same as in the Digwa case. Do you really not understand the connection ? People in high immigration areas are watching the landscape of their towns and cities being forever changed as a result. They experience high crime rates and many other issues that government simply deny is happening and they are sick of being gaslighted. There is no misinformation in this case. The attacker was a failed asylum seeker, given leave to remain by a system not fit for purpose. A innocent man was attacked and received life changing injuries as a result. And all the authorities can say in the face of the anger and frustration vented on the community is ‘violence is never the answer’. The perpetrators are inevitably branded right wing thugs and racists, and their concerns dismissed. No attempt is being made to even address their issues or concerns, so what do you expect ?

CagedBirdInACage · Today 16:00

Persephonia1966 · Today 15:30

Because people keep changing their stories on what the anger is about. Or, alternatively everyone is consistent but has their own separate reason for "the anger". And it's ever shifting according to opportunity.
Eg today "the people" are angry that current immigration is bringing in more people to commit violent crime on top of the British people we can't do anything about. Yesterday "the people" were angry at Novak's killer even though he was born in the UK. When the 3 little girls were attacked "The People" were first very angry that the attacker had come over in a boat and it was about illegal immigration. Then when it turned out he was born in Wales "The People" were angry that hisnparents were allowed to come here.
"The People" were angry that the Belfast attack was being underplayed by the media but when it was pointed out that similar crimes received the same or less publicity it turned out the real reason "The People" are angry is because immigration is bringing in more violent people to add to the people we have.

The people were angry at overall migration numbers and how that affects demographics/housing/enployment but when migration numbers went down it turned out not to be overall migration numbers that were .asking people angry but the types of people. Sometimes the wrong type of people includes Eastern European. Sometimes they are the right type of person and the wrong type is Muslims. Etc.

I agree with this if they want people to listen/don't want to be branded as racist/stupid/whatever then get your act together and launch a proper campaign with clear grievances and clear aims. All I hear lately is rabble, rabble, rabble with no clear message.

Prove that you aren't stupid racists and put together a coherent campaign instead of whining on the Internet and burning people out of their homes.

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:02

CagedBirdInACage · Today 16:00

I agree with this if they want people to listen/don't want to be branded as racist/stupid/whatever then get your act together and launch a proper campaign with clear grievances and clear aims. All I hear lately is rabble, rabble, rabble with no clear message.

Prove that you aren't stupid racists and put together a coherent campaign instead of whining on the Internet and burning people out of their homes.

The more citizens are called far right racists the more they will double down. Maybe the rioters aren't the only ones who should be looking at their own behaviour.

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:04

Launch a proper campaign? - the types that will be countered by hard left thugs and lefty agitators who can't handle their way or the highway mentality not working.

Backedoffhackedoff · Today 16:04

Walkyrie · Today 15:09

So let’s change the qualification. We shouldn’t be adding people to the list if we can’t already house the people on it.

So the disabled Welsh woman with 4 kids stays homeless whilst people with less need than her are housed?

DuncinToffee · Today 16:05

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:02

The more citizens are called far right racists the more they will double down. Maybe the rioters aren't the only ones who should be looking at their own behaviour.

When they target migrant houses to set on fire, what should we call them?

Dollymylove · Today 16:13

"Terrorist related" it says. Yet they say Belfast wasn't terrorism.
I wonder how they came to that conclusion 🤔

OrangeCrushes · Today 16:17

LuckyHazelFox · Today 14:29

It's only attempted beheadings you're interested in? Perhaps you and OP can work collaboratively on trying to prove there's nothing to see here. Same as there wasn't with Henry Nowak. Until the next savage act, reflecting a different set of cultural values takes place.

Did you only read the first line of my post? I asked about beheadings in line one as this is the thread topic, then I asked if you have general stats in line two.

I see that your position must be vibes-based as you don't seem to have any supporting evidence.

NB edited for clarity

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:18

DuncinToffee · Today 16:05

When they target migrant houses to set on fire, what should we call them?

You're only taking into account the rioters. Call them what you like. If they are stupid enough to play into your hands more fools them. Im talking about the every day man and woman who doesn't let their anger and frustration out on violence. So for the poster talking about one-dimensional thinking, she's right, just not in the way she suspects she is.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 16:19

DuncinToffee · Today 15:49

Is it asylum seekers you think are the issue? Or immigrants from certain countries?

I am an EU immigrant, have I changed the landscape of my town?

People usually say 'oh I don't mean people like you'

Well you haven’t given me much leeway to reply have you ? You can deny there’s a problem if you want and cry racism if that’s what you believe. It doesn’t change anything. The asylum system is not fit for purpose and is actively putting UK citizens at risk. I don’t care where migrants are from, but it’s undeniable that many do not share our values or respect for life. The fact is that there are many issues connected with it and people like me, who have valid concerns at what’s happening in our local areas have those concerns routinely dismissed as either far right or racist views.

I don’t have any problem with migrants coming here to work, and who respect our laws. I do have a problem with those who have no intention of that, and who actively harm others. And I have concerns about the sustainability and fitness for purpose of the migration/asylum system, and even bigger concerns about the illegal element, as well as being deeply concerned about the trend of those in power dismissing concerns like mine as far right and racist so they don’t have to deal with them. Kicking the can down the road doesn’t solve anything.

likelysuspect · Today 16:19

DoraSpenlow · Today 14:56

I cannot quote any 'peer reviewed evidence', I can only speak of experience within my family. My niece, her partner and their 5 year old have been living with his parents in a two bedroom bungalow for 5 years. During that time several housing association houses have been allocated to families who definitely do not come from the local area. I know for a fact that at least two of these families do not speak English because I know the people who live next door. Another relative who worked for the housing association has resigned in protest about recent allocations.

People are housed on the basis of being homeless in those situations. Your neice is overcrowded but has somewhere to live

When asylum seekers are granted refugee status the NASS accommodation is withdrawn almost instantly, families have around 7 days to get out of the property because they are no longer supported by the HO and now have the right to public funding/benefits/housing whereas they dont while seeking asylum.

So they are going to be homeless in 7 days and therefore will have a higher need than someone who is overcrowded.

Successive governments have not built enough social housing.

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:20

OrangeCrushes · Today 16:17

Did you only read the first line of my post? I asked about beheadings in line one as this is the thread topic, then I asked if you have general stats in line two.

I see that your position must be vibes-based as you don't seem to have any supporting evidence.

NB edited for clarity

Edited

Vibes-based. Is that a new wanky term I've not heard about?

Anotherdayanotherexcuse · Today 16:23

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:04

Launch a proper campaign? - the types that will be countered by hard left thugs and lefty agitators who can't handle their way or the highway mentality not working.

So not having a proper campaign but violence by hard right wing thugs and fascist agitators who can't handle their way or the highway which is what's happening now is ok because that's the implication.

You can partly blame Brexit, and also blame the right wing in Europe for this shit show.

CagedBirdInACage · Today 16:24

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:02

The more citizens are called far right racists the more they will double down. Maybe the rioters aren't the only ones who should be looking at their own behaviour.

Yeah because that's what clever people do, they don't say oh millions of people are taking our message up wrong maybe we should look at how we are communicating it? Instead they 'double down' and keep regurgitating the same shit over and over again, that will surely help the cause.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 16:24

likelysuspect · Today 16:19

People are housed on the basis of being homeless in those situations. Your neice is overcrowded but has somewhere to live

When asylum seekers are granted refugee status the NASS accommodation is withdrawn almost instantly, families have around 7 days to get out of the property because they are no longer supported by the HO and now have the right to public funding/benefits/housing whereas they dont while seeking asylum.

So they are going to be homeless in 7 days and therefore will have a higher need than someone who is overcrowded.

Successive governments have not built enough social housing.

All very reasonable. But it doesn’t change the perception for people who have been on LA housing lists for very long periods of time and who are living in overcrowded conditions. They perceive that refugees are jumping the queue while they have waited their turn, only to be pushed further down the list. It may not be accurate, but it’s understandable.

ThreadGuardDog · Today 16:25

CagedBirdInACage · Today 16:24

Yeah because that's what clever people do, they don't say oh millions of people are taking our message up wrong maybe we should look at how we are communicating it? Instead they 'double down' and keep regurgitating the same shit over and over again, that will surely help the cause.

And what ‘same shit’ would that be ?

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:25

Anotherdayanotherexcuse · Today 16:23

So not having a proper campaign but violence by hard right wing thugs and fascist agitators who can't handle their way or the highway which is what's happening now is ok because that's the implication.

You can partly blame Brexit, and also blame the right wing in Europe for this shit show.

Great user name.

CagedBirdInACage · Today 16:27

LuckyHazelFox · Today 16:04

Launch a proper campaign? - the types that will be countered by hard left thugs and lefty agitators who can't handle their way or the highway mentality not working.

Afraid to launch a campaign because it might be countered. Sounds like they just aren't cut out for politics. It's OK not everyone is.