Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that alcohol should also be banned for anyone born after 2008?

248 replies

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 02:21

Alcohol causes just as much, if not more harm to society as tobacco does. IMO it should be banned as well. Any possibly junk food as well?

OP posts:
ValueofNothing · Yesterday 20:30

I'm just imagining a group of 50 years olds in 2058 being told they're not allowed to have a glass of Rioja with their tapas because the government says so, while the world burns down around them.

FindingMeno · Yesterday 20:31

CamillaMcCauley · Yesterday 03:25

In itself, the consumption of alcohol doesn’t pose any harm to anyone except the consumer. You and your baby can sit at a table next to someone enjoying a glass of wine and not be affected. The same can’t be said of cigarettes.

If you've ever lived with an alcoholic you will know this is not true.

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · Yesterday 20:31

Fuuuuuuuuk, I bet you're the life and soul at a party 🙄

ValueofNothing · Yesterday 20:34

"Everything bad must be banned" is the logic of a 5 year old.

TonTonMacoute · Yesterday 20:36

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 02:21

Alcohol causes just as much, if not more harm to society as tobacco does. IMO it should be banned as well. Any possibly junk food as well?

Oh do fuck off.

This is pathetic reductionist high school politics, grow up.

Flamingojune · Yesterday 20:44

FindingMeno · Yesterday 20:31

If you've ever lived with an alcoholic you will know this is not true.

Not everyone who drinks is an alcoholic. Everyone who smokes is a smoker

MrsVBS · Yesterday 20:55

Blimey what a boring world if every single thing is banned, the vast majority of people can enjoy a drink without getting blotto or have a McDonalds once a year, nothing worse than someone holier than thou being a killjoy.

Jnngg · Yesterday 21:12

ValueofNothing · Yesterday 20:34

"Everything bad must be banned" is the logic of a 5 year old.

She's the OP of the teacher fake boobs post

Dappy777 · Yesterday 21:46

Personally, I would much rather live in a society in which alcohol was banned but ecstasy, MDMA and the milder forms of cannabis were legal.

Alcohol is a dangerous and highly addictive drug. It makes people loud, aggressive and obnoxious. One of the few really positive changes I have lived through is the decline in alcohol consumption. Public drunkenness used to be a national humiliation. It made me SO ashamed of this country.

ValueofNothing · Yesterday 22:23

Jnngg · Yesterday 21:12

She's the OP of the teacher fake boobs post

That explains it.

Girlonnaughtystep · Yesterday 22:25

Ha ha!
Told my GP surgery I’m having problems with alcohol
Nurse; are you dear
there is no evidence from your liver tests.

Tried getting help through AA but couldn’t tell me how to access their Sunday morning session in my town on two occasions last year. But it’s ok…

Does anyone really care?

SometimesThingsHappen · Yesterday 22:26

Why only people born after 2008? Were you born in 2007 by any chance? 😂

The young uns are making better choices with alcohol anyway, so they will be fine. Its us older folk who have been habituated to it for a lifetime you need to worry about.

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 22:48

SometimesThingsHappen · Yesterday 22:26

Why only people born after 2008? Were you born in 2007 by any chance? 😂

The young uns are making better choices with alcohol anyway, so they will be fine. Its us older folk who have been habituated to it for a lifetime you need to worry about.

Tobacco is being banned for those born after 2008.

OP posts:
IAmBeaIDrinkTea · Yesterday 23:06

CupcakeDreams · Yesterday 03:55

I feel like having a drink just from reading the title of this thread. Wish I could hide it from view......

But, since I can't, pinot grigio, anyone? Love a crisp wine in just the right glass. 👌

I'm sat here with a nice glass of sauvignon blanc saying "blah bollocks" to the OP 😁
<clinks glasses>
Cheers!

TempestTost · Today 00:00

I don't think smoking should be banned so it's a non-starter for me.

That being said, alcohol historically has been a food as much or more than it has been a drug. It's a way to preserve the harvest and can keep quite a lot of calories in a small space, in a fairly stable state.

That's maybe not as necessary for many people as it once was, but it doesn't mean it's useless. There are still cider apples all over the country and if you make cider, which is lovely and useful, it doesn't take long to become alcoholic.

Lilyisthebest · Today 01:39

CamillaMcCauley · Yesterday 03:25

In itself, the consumption of alcohol doesn’t pose any harm to anyone except the consumer. You and your baby can sit at a table next to someone enjoying a glass of wine and not be affected. The same can’t be said of cigarettes.

Not when she and her baby end up dead or injured because of some drunk driver

Topseyt123 · Today 01:39

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 17:24

IMO anything that is bad should be banned.

Everything can be bad for you in excessive quantities. So by your logic then we should just ban everything.

You're talking bollocks.

Lilyisthebest · Today 01:41

Maybe we could limit it?

Overitallnow · Today 09:01

Just sod off

BauhausOfEliott · Today 10:48

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 17:24

IMO anything that is bad should be banned.

Then your threads would all disappear.

ParadiseIsNoBunker · Today 10:50

OP, have a day off.

ExquisiteSocialSkills · Today 11:00

ValueofNothing · Yesterday 20:30

I'm just imagining a group of 50 years olds in 2058 being told they're not allowed to have a glass of Rioja with their tapas because the government says so, while the world burns down around them.

It might help reduce the incidence of pompous middle class windbagging if ‘good’ red wine was banned.

LizzieW1969 · Today 16:29

MrsVBS · Yesterday 20:55

Blimey what a boring world if every single thing is banned, the vast majority of people can enjoy a drink without getting blotto or have a McDonalds once a year, nothing worse than someone holier than thou being a killjoy.

^This 💯. These are things to be enjoyed in moderation.

Besides, banning doesn’t work. As can be seen with all the illegal drugs around.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread