Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a baby with a man i dont love

162 replies

ComeAtMe · 01/02/2026 19:32

I have 1 kid with my husband. I don't love my husband anymore. It used to be pretty awful, he was horrible to me, but now we have settled into housemate life. He is a good dad but he is sexist and uncaring. I do it all and I used to that now.

I know i want to leave and I will. But is it horrible of me to have a baby before I do?

I know everyone will say how selfish to the baby to bring a child into an unloving marriage, but the baby will be v loved, looked after and surely all kids would rather be alive than not?

Pls explain why its a terrible idea. I am perfectly capable of looking after a new child and loving them, with or without my husband.

OP posts:
90sTrifle · 03/02/2026 22:48

I understand your want for a second child, but given the situation you are in, knowingly bringing a child into a ‘soon-to-be’ broken home is absolutely selfish of you.

I take it you were not brought up in a ‘broken-home’, had you been I don’t think you would be asking this question.

OneQuirkyPanda · 03/02/2026 22:49

Don’t do it, my best friend did the exact same thing, it took her almost a year to fall pregnant, then after the baby was born she didn’t want to divorce while she was on maternity leave due to the stress and financial vulnerability. So she subjected her eldest to another three years of living in a toxic home.

After their second child was born the relationship deteriorated significantly, having two kids with a useless, selfish, sexist husband is a lot harder than just one. As much as you think your love and great parenting can make up for the fact that you and your husband don’t like each other and he’s an awful example of a father and husband, the truth is it can’t.

What you’re doing is selfish, not only to the child you’re planning to bring into this toxic situation, but especially to the child you already have, who will suffer from having to continue living with parents who don’t love and like each other, a father who is sexist and lazy and then being older and more able to understand and be affected by the breakdown of their family.

OneNewLeader · 03/02/2026 22:50

He’s a good dad apart from being awful, horrible, sexist, uncaring and uninvolved. I think to knowingly bring another child into this environment is at best selfish and at worst cruel. I doubt all the love from one parent can actively cancel out the lack of it from another.

HolidayPlanningAgain · 03/02/2026 22:57

How will feel when you are not with your children 50% of the time? Will that still fit your dream of being a single mum of 3?

Fancycrab · 03/02/2026 23:52

HolidayPlanningAgain · 03/02/2026 22:57

How will feel when you are not with your children 50% of the time? Will that still fit your dream of being a single mum of 3?

If you had 3 kids being with them 50% of the time would be perfect!

Fancycrab · 03/02/2026 23:57

KimberleyClark · 03/02/2026 22:25

Women can still get sperm from abroad from countries which allow anonymous sperm donation.

That would involve travelling to that country, paying for all the costs that would incur and spending the entirety of your IVF treatment there (usually months, years even) or travelling over every time you need to get a new round. Be realistic. I know loads of people who’ve used donor sperm, every single one has said they would have chosen non-anonymous even if they didn’t have to. Most mothers want to give their children that option

Bellaunion · 04/02/2026 07:26

Fancycrab · 03/02/2026 21:06

Why did you have kids? Have you cultivated their brains from toddler-hood to be Oxbridge grads at 12 in the hope they might one day cure cancer or perhaps solve world hunger? In which case, ok. You truly are a selfless parent. But I don’t think that’s the case is it? You had kids because you’re a woman with a biological urge to reproduce. Just like the OP is. You just happen to (quite arrogantly) assume your circumstances were better. Being a good parent is highly subjective. I’m sure you and your hubby think you’re great parents and feel really smug about having children in what YOU believe is an ideal family, but your kids and other people may not think you’re good parents. People have different values and ideas about what makes a good upbringing for a child. My parents thought they were good parents, to outsiders they looked like ideal parents - a man and a woman, married, no DV, no addiction etc, loving, firm boundaries. But those firm boundaries meant my dad was very strict, I was smacked often, criticised all the time by him, all because he was “loving and had high expectations” of me. He and everyone else he knows still think he was a great parent. I, on the other hand have lifelong problems with low self-esteem because of him. Hands down I’d rather have been raised solely by my mum, who was kind, understanding and loved me without conditions. I’m sure I would have turned out far better. A child needs love and support (emotional & financial). That is all. It doesn’t matter whether they get that from a mum and a dad, just a mum, just a dad, two mums, two dads, a grandparent. It. Does. Not. Matter. All that matters is they get it.

Your post makes absolutely no sense. There needs to be more thought into having a baby then just the urge to reproduce. People need to think what sort of environment they are bringing a baby in, finances, support network and who will be bringing a baby up and involved with it. Just to have a baby because you want one and to ignore everything else is the height of selfishness.

And I'm not quite sure why you're trying to shame me about my situation. I purposely made sure I was with a loving and caring partner, who made a good father. If that makes me smug, then so be it. Yes theres nothing wrong with being in a single parent family but having two loving parents is always going to be better. That's the situation I wanted for my children and I make absolutely no apologies if that makes me narrow minded or smug. Surely most parents want the best for their children?

And you've went on about your own childhood yet still seem to be advocating for the OP to have a baby with a man who she already says is sexist and uncaring so surely you know that having a father with these qualities can impact on the child as you say so yourself. The OP isn't talking about a sperm donor, this is the route she wants to take and the father will have rights and access to the child.

Bellaunion · 04/02/2026 07:36

OneNewLeader · 03/02/2026 22:50

He’s a good dad apart from being awful, horrible, sexist, uncaring and uninvolved. I think to knowingly bring another child into this environment is at best selfish and at worst cruel. I doubt all the love from one parent can actively cancel out the lack of it from another.

Absolutely, I'm glad some people see sense. I can't believe they are people advocating for this. As if having a parent with these attributes wouldn't have an impact.

Even worse we are bizarrely seeing a poster who has said that their dad left with them such low life long self esteem go onto to say that the poster should have kids with an unloving, sexist dad and then let the dad have them 50% of the time.

Sartre · 04/02/2026 07:43

I understand why you’d want this, having children by different fathers brings its own challenges and isn’t for everyone. On top of that, you feel too old to even meet someone new and know them well enough to have a child so it does make sense.

I don’t think it’s the worst decision in the world, because you feel able to financially and emotionally support two children if/when you end your marriage. It also has to be your husband’s choice though, unless you were planning on doing it without his knowledge which I do not recommend.

MIAMNER · 04/02/2026 07:50

The problem is if something goes wrong (the baby has additional needs, you have a difficult pregnancy that impacts your health long term etc) then you won’t have the support.

Extraenergyneeded · 04/02/2026 08:08

You have to consider that the child could have profound disabilities, what then?
It could be caused by birth accident .Cerebral palsy can affect a child physically and mentally.

Sunshineandgrapefruit · 04/02/2026 15:23

He is not a good Dad if he is sexist and uncaring. So why would you want a child with him? You know this though which is why you posted. Leave and find someone who is a good Dad and a good husband ( and by definition therefore not sexist)

New posts on this thread. Refresh page