JKR being uncharacteristically quiet

[Jdugsgsgwyd]

Anyone else noticed since the news that JKR is being sued by Imane Khelif she's been very quiet, unless I'm mistaken she's hasn't tweeted at all in about a week.

and hasn't responded at all to the legal action being taken against her. This is very unlike her, I'm thinking she's been advised by her lawyers to keep quiet. Anyone else think she might have put her foot in it this time?

Pretty sure she's more intelligent than those who think a vagina is observed at birth! 😬🙈

This is further evidenced by the fact we know from her family history that she was raised as a girl, which is a highly highly unlikely state of affairs if she doesn't at least physically appear to be female. Therefore unless you're proposing there has been some grand multilayered conspiracy to conceal a child's penis from birth in order to win a hypothetical future boxing match, we can be pretty confident Imane does indeed have a vagina.

Would you like to explain why IK was hoisted on a man's shoulders and carried around joyfully — something which is done with men but would never be done with a woman?

Like most supporters of twaw you seem to lack very basic logic (sorry to seem rude but Im just describing reality, sorry)
Men in womens boxing smash womens skulls in (see fallon fox) women boxing each other is not the issue.

Its surprisingly unsatisfying arguing with stupid. We could have a thread about that.

I don’t want to play the gender critical “nothing is transphobic” game

No, you'll just keep playing the "everything is transphobic" game.

Some men get soooo riled when women have opinions.

Its funny, but also sad at the same time.

Would you like to explain why IK was hoisted on a man's shoulders and carried around joyfully — something which is done with men but would never be done with a woman?

Says who? Who wrote that rule? Is that something you've just made up?

I'll spare you the humiliation of sharing links but spending literally 2 seconds on google will reveal many images of victorious female boxers being lifted on their coach's shoulders.

I think you're grasping at straws. And again, there's some misogyny creeping in there- "she can't be a woman because women would never do this thing" - says who? I thought being gender critical was supposed to be about challenging stereotypes?

It’s not convenient, it’s a fact. If someone looks at your genitals when you’re born, and says “penis - it’s a boy” or “vagina - it’s a girl” in the vast vast majority of instances, they will be right.

But not necessarily if that individual has a DSD and their sex is incorrectly assigned.

I do NOT believe that ‘assigned male at birth’ actual XY chromosomed men can become women.

Isn't it just. More so when you put time into explaining stuff and they just don't engage with what you've written at all as they can't dispute it!!

Anywho 🤷🏼‍♀️

Yes ok, I was using the term colloquially. It’s possible she has a blind vagina. She certainly wouldn’t have likely had a penis given her female sex assignment. Just more evidence that human sex is complicated and not in fact binary or “basic” at all eh? and also sex is assigned 👍🏻

You think you're more clever than JKR, do you? Okey-dokey.

How to say in many words that you have absolutely no understanding of DSDs.

Do you also think it's impossible to identify a cave by standing at the entrance?

Christ, how embarrassing for you. Three edits and you still can’t get it right.

I hate to break it to you, but statistically there are many many many people in the world who are cleverer than JK Rowling.

Christ, how embarrassing for you

I'm not discussing whether she has a DSD, I'm discussing whether she has a vagina as that was the question asked. Even if she has a DSD we can still be pretty confident she has a vagina for all the reasons outlined above.

Some posters apparently don't believe women can read

I can't wait to read the next Strike book. I will buy the hard back for sure.

On the other hand I'm tapping out of here now because I'm bored of arguing with those who don't have the most basic school level knowledge of either logic or female anatomy.

No, we can't.

Quite!
The fucking Paris Olympics and their shite opening ceremony… “we have reached gender parity in this Olympics! Yay us!”

Then fails to mention that some of the female athletes are actually male. Hmmmmm

Yes, always round in the same old circle;

Women shut up! how dare you not BE KIND!!!

Calm logic and facts

Some scientifically illiterate bullshit

Calm logic and facts

Name calling and threats

Calm logic and facts

silence....

Just had a quick read about the T/E tests which are looking at the ratio of testosterone to epitesterone which should be in equal amounts for natural testosterone. Doping changes the ratio.
If an athlete naturally has male testosterone levels wouldn't they pass the T/E test?

I literally explained the reality of the genitalia for a child with 5ARD above, it did not include a vagina.

Google the Prader scale, look at the pictures for yourself if you need to visualise it rather than read a description.

Ffs debating this is like you're invisible at times!

I'm sorry, but your side are really really not offering calm logic and facts.

Not everyone is on Twitter. So you should probably explain what you mean here.