Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to tell stranger where DD goes to nursery

220 replies

LG93 · 17/06/2020 14:47

I was queuing to return some shoes in the supermarket yesterday, there was a woman in front of me presumably returning everything she's ever owned by the length of time she was there. While the man on the till went out the back to sort the paperwork DD (18months) who was in her buggy started waving at the lady in front and shouting Hiya at her. She turned around and was chatting to me, we had a civil conversation. I suffer with anxiety so not really one for chatting to strangers but have tried to make more of an effort in lockdown having seen how pleased people are to see dd if they're alone/missing family.

She asked how I was finding working with her at home (not that I'd said I worked at home, a lucky guess) and I said it was a challenge but at least nurseries had reopened. She asked which one she went to and I vaguely said one in next village over, which is true however it has 4 nurseries/preschools so not too identifying. She kept pushing as to which one, so I politely said 'Sorry, I don't really feel comfortable sharing that information with strangers'

Her tone changed and she asked me what I thought she would do with that information. I explained it wasn't personal but it's not information we shared. She huffed that it's 'all over your social media no doubt' (it's not, I very rarely post any photos of her at all on social media and certainly don't identify her nursery etc) and she just wondered if it was the same as her granddaughter but to 'suit myself' and turned around. The man came back shortly after and she gave me a bit of a scowl as she left but didn't say anything else.

Wibu? I'm sure she meant no harm by her question but I obviously have no way of identifying who may or may not be so simply don't share that information with people who don't need it, but her reaction made me wonder if I'm being overly anxious?!

OP posts:
midnightstar66 · 18/06/2020 07:23

Gosh, where kids go to school / nursery is the main topic of casual conversation when I meet any adult in my (London) neighbourhood.

Same here -not London, small city that's a bit like a large village in that someone always knows someone who works or attends there so it's an ice breaker/way to find common ground

midnightstar66 · 18/06/2020 07:36

*It’s just an example of what could happen. The Algarve was full of children too but the guy selected that particular child for reasons only known to him.
*
I think it's pretty widely believed that this child was not 'selected' but an opportunist situation as the suspect was not only paedophile but a career house breaker and just happened upon unaccompanied sleeping children (or had observed this was happening each night)

Isthisfinallyit · 18/06/2020 07:44

You know what? Just look at the "what if your wrong" scenarios:

  1. If you're wrong about her being creepy and shd is actually trustworthy thrn worst case scenario a stranger now doesn't like you.
  2. If you're wrong and tell her what she wants to know and she is a paedophile she could seriously hurt your child.

Now lets put them together: pissed off stranger or hurt child? I'd know which scenario I'd go for.

ohoneohtwo · 18/06/2020 07:52

2. If you're wrong and tell her what she wants to know and she is a paedophile she could seriously hurt your child.

How?

She was asking what nursery the child went to, not to take her home for the week Hmm

Please enlighten us as to how the child could be seriously hurt?

Aweebawbee · 18/06/2020 08:04

Oh dear, I could've been that nosey woman in the queue. As an ex-teacher and mother of DCs who have been through the education system, I'm always curious to hear people's experience of schools and nurseries in the area, maybe catch up on a bit of playground gossip. And yes, I would be quite taken aback if someone implied that I was up to no good for asking what I would have thought was a fairly innocuous question. How exactly are we supposed to connect to the community these days?

TerrapinStation · 18/06/2020 08:08

@Isthisfinallyit

You know what? Just look at the "what if your wrong" scenarios:
  1. If you're wrong about her being creepy and shd is actually trustworthy thrn worst case scenario a stranger now doesn't like you.
  2. If you're wrong and tell her what she wants to know and she is a paedophile she could seriously hurt your child.

Now lets put them together: pissed off stranger or hurt child? I'd know which scenario I'd go for.

How would she end getting hurt?

Do you think the lady was then going to start on a list of questions about what days the child goes to the nursery, what hours she attends, could she be put on the list of authorised collectors, what's the password?

You're being totally ridiculous about an everyday conversation

Thurmanmurman · 18/06/2020 08:14

I'm going to go against the majority here and say I think your reaction was very odd indeed. She was making general chit chat and I think you're reaction was weird and precious. Sorry.

Thurmanmurman · 18/06/2020 08:14

*your

EmbarrassedUser · 18/06/2020 08:23

Grin First baby by any chance?? I doubt she wanted to kidnap your kid @LG93 Sounded like she was being polite.

saraclara · 18/06/2020 10:27

To be fair to @LG93 she at least a) questioned her own behaviour b) recognises that her anxiety might be making her unreasonable and c) has taken on board what many of us have said about her reaction being, as she suspected, a bit OTT.

It's the other posters who seem to think that one innocuous bit of information on a subject brought up by the OP, not the stranger, is going to lead to her child being abducted (not to mention the ones feeling the need to hide their child's school uniform in public) that I worry about.

Ronnie68 · 18/06/2020 17:45

I don't think ywbu at all. It's certainly not information I'd share about my children. Hopefully she'll be put right by her Dd if she mentions conversation to her! Wth does what you put on your social media have to do with her!
I wouldn't lose any sleep over her

cstaff · 18/06/2020 18:04

Bloody hell, this thread is nuts. So did you call the FBI, CIA, MI5 or the cops and report this poor woman for the crime of making conversation with you and your dd in a shop queue. Grin

Thisismytimetoshine · 18/06/2020 18:10

If you're wrong and tell her what she wants to know and she is a paedophile she could seriously hurt your child.
This is a seriously disturbing level of paranoia, combined with a serious lack of logic.

Thisismytimetoshine · 18/06/2020 18:14

the woman got huffy and rude. Thats NOT being "friendly"
Because op made it plain she thought the woman wanted the information for nefarious purposes (although it beats me what harm she could have done with it), not because she was denied the information.

minny80 · 18/06/2020 18:42

YANBU at all, it's her problem if she took it personally Flowers

Her1mum · 18/06/2020 18:43

YANBU. She should have understood straight away that you didn't want to be more specific and politely backed off. She was the rude one by not picking up on your reluctance to tell her.

riceuten · 18/06/2020 19:36

I don't think you were unreasonable or reasonable. I'm not sure why she asked - but I'm not sure why you refused, nor of what use she'd make of it if she did. Given that you're an anxious person, I understand your reticence, and generally, if I sense someone is like that, or doesn't want to engage, I back off.

I did have this a few years back - I was waiting for an appointment and we'd been kept waiting for quite a while and chatting about holiday experiences and, purely out of politeness I asked where they were planning on going in the summer. The temperature dropped 20 degrees and you would have thought I'd asked for her PIN number.

Boxerbinky · 18/06/2020 19:38

I personally wouldn’t have been bothered saying. But your reasons for not sharing it with her are your own so I don’t really understand why people think yabu. She shouldn’t have kept pressing, as others have said she should have realised you were deliberately vague and if she had better social skills could have continued with other chit chat. You mentioning the nursery opening doesn’t mean you have to tell her which one!

Fishfingersandwichplease · 18/06/2020 19:45

I would have just said - like pp have already said she was hardly going to rock up and steal your child! Just making friendly conversation esp if her grandchild is at nursery too. I would always ask someone which school their kids go to (work in a shop)but not because l am a child snatcher ffs!!

NewName89 · 18/06/2020 20:06

YABU she was making conversation and you had a very confrontational response which she (probably rightly) found offensive...

Tsubasa1 · 18/06/2020 20:17

I think both you are BU and not. However that lady might think twice about making small talk again which makes me sad.

Bibijayne · 18/06/2020 20:30

I don't think either were being unreasonable. You are not comfortable in social situations. You did not feel comfortable giving that information and tried to distract by being vague, and she pushed.

But I don't think she was being nefarious. She was making pleasant conversation and which nursery a child/ grandchild is at is a fairly standard question. She was seeking connection. But she kept pushing for an answer when you clearly weren't comfortable and got an answer she did not like.

It happens. No one is actually in the wrong here. Two adults with differing personalities made small talk, it was awkward.

ABlackRussian · 18/06/2020 20:37

You're really odd.

ABlackRussian · 18/06/2020 20:40

And then to post the whole 'drama' to an internet full of strangers Hmm

Sort yourself out. No one really gives two hoots about anyone else's brats. She was just being polite.

Chickoletta · 18/06/2020 20:42

Genuine question - what did you think this grandmother was going to do with the information to harm your child?

Swipe left for the next trending thread