Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with IL’s gift?

212 replies

DoesThisLookRight · 12/08/2019 13:17

IL’s live 200 miles away from us but a few roads down from dh’s dsis. As such, they are very close to the other set of grandkids but not so close to our kids. They speak on the phone most weekends and Skype a couple of times a month though. We drive up at least 3 times a year for a weekend. They haven’t been down to us once since we moved 18 months ago. They are healthy, can and do drive long distances and we have plenty of room so no real reason they haven’t come down except that they just don’t want to. They even driven past our house on their way to a holiday and didn’t come in for a cup of tea despite me inviting them.

Ds’s birthday in a few days. I opened an Amazon package today addressed to me and find a battered, secondhand copy of Ganster Granny. No note or explanation. After a bit of digging it turns out that this is their birthday present for ds. I received a message from MIL after asking if she knew what it was saying ‘hope ds (name spelt wrong) likes it. I remembered he said it was his favourite book. I hope he has a great day. Best not to call on the day as we’re going to a book reading. Speak soon, love MIL.’

IL’s are pretty wealthy. For my niece and nephews birthday (they’re 2 days apart so got a joint present) IL’s paid for a weekend at CenterParcs. My ds gets a secondhand book that he’s actually told them that he’s already read and already has. No card, nothing. I’m tempted not to give it to him it’s so crap.

I’ve tried so bloody hard for them. I have crippling social anxiety but they insisted that Dh and I have a big wedding so they could show off to their friends. I went along with that and so much other shit just to try and get them to like me and they give ds a book worth 20p from a charity shop.

I know I’m being a brat but it’s just the latest thing after years of being left out and they can’t even be bothered to wrap up a present.

OP posts:
ReasonedCamper · 13/08/2019 10:20

Sorry but It is controlling not to give him the book.

He said it was his favourite book, they sourced it for him. Sometimes that is more important than bling.

Give him the book just as a present: ooh, look what grandparents sent you!

I understand why you are upset about the other negligences and lack of engagement but that doesn’t give you the right to withhold a book given to your child.

Let him make his own judgement.

Cassilis · 13/08/2019 10:24

It’s pretty clear to me OP is trying to protect her son not control him.

namechangedforthis1980 · 13/08/2019 10:27

I've heard of this sort of thing so many times, including in our own family

My BIL and family live much closer to the in laws than we do. It's noticeable how much more effort they make with them - with presents, spending time with them, gifts of money. Really upsets DH, his parents are pretty old so travelling to us isn't an option but we'd always be happy to make effort to travel to them but they don't seem to be interested in that. If we go and visit all they do is talk about their other grandchildren. Probably the most noticeable thing was a few years ago, MIL had had an op before Christmas and said that she would be giving the GC money for Christmas as she couldn't go shopping - obv no problem at all. Roll on Christmas and we're all sat together, our boys are handed money and the other children have presents to open! Felt abit like they couldn't be bothered with our children Sad. DS2 really noticed as it was a present he would have loved ( too young to appreciate money really).

I had it even more extreme growing up, with us being the GC that got presents like the OP's child, when our cousins got much more extreme stuff.

I just ignore it all now, if my IL's insist on just talking about their other GC then I listen for a bit then change the subject. We're actually very close to DH's B and his family so don't ever want to say anything as id be gutted if that relationship broke down.

Stoichiometry · 13/08/2019 10:29

That is really bad behaviour from your ILs DoesThisLookRight.

I definitely would not be giving that gift to my son or making any effort with them at all in the future.

I hope your DH calls them out - simply stating the facts back to them will be pretty powerful without any extra PA/comparing.

Justhavingacry your dad sounds fantastic!

Fuckedoff1 · 13/08/2019 10:33

What is your relationship with your SIL like? Has she ever mentioned the way they're treating her kids so differently to yours?

simplekindoflife · 13/08/2019 10:45

I'd have to confront them over this. It's pretty awful. How rude to say not to call either - I doubt they'll be in a book reading all morning, afternoon and evening with no break?!

Nasty people.

As your dc get older, they will start noticing soon. Best nip this in the bud now. I'd get DH to do it though and not mention you at all.

bellabasset · 13/08/2019 11:22

As your dh is home for your ds' birthday I would give him the parcel and say you found it offensive they've given ds a tatty second hand book. Then leave him to decide whether to give it to ds and talk to his dps. Don't let dh buy a pretend present from them.

GPs could have sent a card with money for you to give to ds or buy a present from them

ReasonedCamper · 13/08/2019 13:31

How does it protect him to not just hand him the book and say 'oh look, DGPs sent you a copy of the book you said you liked'?

Today, rather than his birthday?

FireBloodAndIce · 13/08/2019 13:40

He said it was his favourite book, they sourced it for him. Sometimes that is more important than bling.

What buying him a book that he's previously told them he already has. All that says is they don't care and listen!

Nanny0gg · 13/08/2019 13:56

He said it was his favourite book, they sourced it for him. Sometimes that is more important than bling.

He's already got the bloody book!
And I bet it's in better condition too!

(And buying from Amazon is not what I'd call 'sourcing')

Cassilis · 13/08/2019 14:29

I love that buying on Amazon, which likely took all of 2 minutes, is ’sourcing’ the book Grin

If it’s his favourite book it’s obvious he already has a copy! And to get him a tatty second hand instead of splurging all of £4 on a new copy is the icing on the shitcake. They obviously didn’t want to spend any money or thought in the present.

Cassilis · 13/08/2019 14:31

Either lots of MILs or tight differentiating grannies on this thread!

By the way the cheap grannies is not a criticism. My mum bungs her grandkids a tenner on their birthday but the key thing is she treats all 10 kids the same. And they all love her.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread