Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My mum has asked me to help with my sisters college costs.

214 replies

Shootingstar1115 · 12/05/2019 16:41

Hi all, my sister is 16 and going to college in september and there will be added costs like equipment she needs etc and the bus pass etc which will probably cost around a grand.

There is no reason my parents couldn’t afford this if they were careful. They knew she wanted to go to college so why not save up? They both work. My mum only works part time but my stepdad earns a decent wage. They seem to spend above their means. Will pay out for 2-3 holidays a year, days out, night so out but as soon as something comes along like a car repair or a school trip, college!! They haven’t got it for these things. They also live in a council house and there rent is soo cheap (compared to private rent in the area anyway) so I’m not sure where they go wrong.

So I moved out when I was in my late teens. I was financially independent before moving out because they were just terrible with money.

Myself and OH are sort of average when it comes to earnings. We aren’t rich (far bloody from it 😭) but we aren’t poor either and don’t receive any Financial help and own our own home so everything is down to us.

But she’s asking me to help out with the college costs. I’m all for helping people out but it seems unfair that they have been on 2 holidays this year (we haven’t had a holiday in 5 years). Surely I’m not being unreasonable to think this is not my responsibility??? My sister is 16, she could get a part time job surely? I had to at that age!!

My mother has never helped us out financially. My mum receives a huge amount of money off my grandparents who have quite a bit stashed away (they aren’t rich but have saved saved saved all their lives). I just can’t help thinking this is not my place.

We aren’t talking borrowing 30 quid, she wanted £300 odd. We simply haven’t got that kind of money to give out!!

OP posts:
Tistheseason17 · 14/05/2019 22:30

As per PPs.
Just say, "Sorry, would love to help but we cannot afford to."

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 14/05/2019 23:19

By the title of your post I really thought this was going to be that you were well off and your parents were poor, it's obviously the opposite. In reality you would be funding your parents' lifestyle if you contribute. I'm amazed they would ask.

SavvyBlancBlonde · 15/05/2019 00:01

So your sister is the eldest of your other siblings? Will she also ask for the others?

Bailey6 · 15/05/2019 09:05

You would get normal provision until they are 18 as they have to stay in education now. The only thing that can stop at 16 if going into an apprenticeship is Child Maintenance. If child stays at school child maintenance continues until 18 and 21 if they go onto higher education. (Further education / part time course / apprenticeships it can stop, Bishalisha. As far as I am aware.

Definite NO to parents. Again, I would just brush it off with the comment about no holidays and that you are saving for your own DC. I wouldn’t approach grandparents (she may have approached them). I would also say they need to think bout putting money aside for your siblings! Extra & PT jobs are also good for your sister & your mother!
Please let us know what goes on :-) pretty consistent on here!

BMW6 · 15/05/2019 09:46

I wonder if OP is going to come back.......

Durgasarrow · 15/05/2019 09:51

This has NOTHING to do with you. It is between your sister and your mother. You need to take care of your children's education. She needs to take care of her children's education. If they don't have the money, then sister will need to earn some money herself. Plenty of young people have contributed to their own education. And it is HER education, not yours.

MindfulBear · 15/05/2019 09:59

What mrs pratchett said
Your poor sis. Cheeky Feckers.

I'd also talk to DSis and GP About taking control of the situation.

How can they take so many holidays and then not be able to cover everyday costs? The mind boggles. At 16 most U.K. kids are still reliant on their parents and will go into some sort of post gcse education. This should not have been a surprise to them.

Sounds like they are lazy and entitled. So sorry for you and your DSis.
Hope GPs see through them and support DSis directly without making life difficult for her.

Anniegetyourgun · 15/05/2019 10:26

What they all said - but do not get into the discussion about what else you are intending to use your money for. Do not even mention that you are saving for anything at all, least of all a holiday! I also feel it is not your place to encourage the grandparents to get involved. Mum already knows well enough how to cadge off them, she doesn't need a helping hand to get more.

I do feel sorry for your sister, just as I would have for you at the same age. But I don't think handing over cash that is supposed to be for her education is actually going to benefit her very much, if at all. That's if you had it to spare; your own children must come first.

FizzyGreenWater · 15/05/2019 13:03

No, obviously!

You could probably make reference to the holidays etc though without it sounding like an attack - but you'll have made your point. Something like:

'We can't afford it - there is just no way, I'm sorry. Gosh mum I thought you realised how strapped we are - I mean you say that you and Dad are struggling and even you've still at least managed to get away on a couple of breaks this year - there's no way we'd even manage that - we haven't had a holiday for five years!'

Friendly, sympathetic, bit jokey... but you will have made the point.

Nicklebox · 15/05/2019 14:33

There are more younger siblings, so if you do it for this sister does that mean you have to contribute to them as well further down the line? I would say no now it's hard enough bringing your own family up.

YouBloodySod · 15/05/2019 18:50

But I’m sure you said in your opening post, that you provided for yourself from a very young age.
I think you’ve done more than enough already and credit due to you.
Just tell your mum ‘sorry, no can do’
I’ve already done my bit mum, time for you to step up. 🤷‍♀️

Redact · 15/05/2019 19:12

YANBU just say no sorry we can't afford it!

Omzlas · 16/05/2019 12:31

"Sorry, we're not in a position to help financially"

Gth1234 · 16/05/2019 12:33

Discuss it with your sister, not your mother. If you want to help, do so. If you want to make it a loan, give her a loan. Try not to feel under pressure.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page