Is this model too thin or about right?

[TheQuirkyMaker]

To me she looks healthy but thoughts?

She's absolutely fine.

She looks fine to Me

Fine

I think she looks a healthy weight.

ffs not this again.

she looks fabulous.

you didn't mention your thoughts OP much considering you started a thread. If you think she's 'ok' why did you start a thread, knowing this topic always ends in a bunfight about fat vs thin?

Why are you asking?

Its been photoshopped as the hips dont seem proportionate with the rest of her, so they've thinned down her arms and legs for some reason by the looks of it but kept the curve of hips to show off the dress shape.

She looks normal. Other than being model beautiful, obvs.

Why?

I think she looks proportionate. The hip is exaggerated because she's leaning against a wall and popping it out.

Photoshop isn't itself banned, but there are ASA regulations implemented which mean that no photoshopping or editing are allowed to exaggerate what the clothing can achieve. Editing someone's weight or body proportions to accentuate their figure comes under this.

slight smoothing and good lighting, yes. Slimming someone or nipping in a waist isn't. It's heavily frowned upon.

Her thighs and arms look too thin to
me, the rest of her it’s hard to tell in the dress but she’s probably got a very low bmi. I wouldn’t trust it not to be photoshopped anyway.

Too think for what? You are missing the end of your sentence.

I wondered if the dress was a bit shapeless so the way she is positioned or perhaps photoshopped is to make it look shapely. Perhaps as another poster says she is just at an extreme angle

Is this model too fat or about right?

She's beautiful but what's going on with her leg?

Left one.

Why?

She looks to be on the slimmest end of "healthy" BMI around 18.5.

OT, but is her dress available to buy?

I'd say that's between her and her doctor and not anyone else's business.

Out of interest, would you screenshot a plus size model and ask if she was too fat?

She's fine, typical teenage shape.

She looks lovely and not too thin. She's a tall, slim young woman.

Her legs look normal too. That's just how slim legs look when you have one straight and one slightly bent.

I would say if you are wanting to judge if she is "too thin" you would need to see her dressed more revealing . She looks fine in what she is wearing but other clothing could very well reveal the protruding ribs and clavicles usually seen in dangerously underweight people.

Well of course you know the answer to that one. You can thin shame all day long but you mustnt mention someone being overweight.

She looks a healthy weight to me.

I'd say she looks entirely normal. She has the same shape legs as me (5ft 10, bmi of 20) which is nice to see for me because I grew up thinking my legs were too long and thin until I was about 30.