Please can you be honest. Making cake toppers for dd birthday, should I give up now (pics attached)

[Cherrymuffiny]

Trying to make cake toppers for my dd Snow White birthday cake. If it was just at my home I wouldn’t care how bad they are but we’re going to a restaurant with a load of friends and I am a bit self conscious about this cake and everyone else seeing it and secretly laughing at it.

i feel like these are horrendous and thinking of just giving up and going Tesco ha! Pls tell me the truth should I give up while I’m ahead?!

yes im afraid

decent attempt though

They look great! I’m sure your daughter will be thrilled with them.

but not very nice family if “secretly laughing” about to

when is party? could you get a cake made?

I think they look great

They're very good in the sense that many people could make them as well as you have but I must admit my first thought was Dopey's seem some traumatic shit. 😅

I'd chuck them on the cake and it will be a nice family memory in years to come.😅

Oh. I think they are great. It's so lovely too spending the time and making the effort to do them. They are really cartoony and they are perfect for a child's birthday cake. 🎂

They look great!
I am quite jealous...
Well done you!

I think they are pretty good! They certainly have character! You’ll get better as you work through all 7 plus Snow White! Stick with it

I think they're great and anyone sneering at them - they are the problem.

Most importantly your child will love them - my children remember my far worse attempts at their cake requests fondly.

It's family - not a professional bake off.

I think they look great! It’s a homemade cake that reflects DD’s current interest - it doesn’t need to be perfect. Keep going :)

The one on the left looks a bit scary but I think they’re fab! I’m the type that would just tell everyone as soon as the cake was coming out that I made it. I’d be really proud of that!

They look good! Really cute. Well done.
I could never manage to make those in a million years.

I love them and your daughter will really appreciate the effort you've gone to.
If your friends laugh and you unkindly you need new friends not new cake toppers....

Ooh I think they look fab! They're dwarves in a fairytail story as well so surely they're not meant to look "aesthetically perfect"?! If I was a friend or family member I'd be well impressed that you made them yourself. Your child will love it!

I’d be pretty pleased with myself if I’d made those!

They look kinda evil but I really like that haha

they’re great OP, I always make my kids a birthday cake. Im hopeless at baking and worse at decorating but they always love them and sure your DD will be so happy. Good
job!

They look great. I'd be proud of myself if I had managed that!

way better than I could do but I'd just buy them in the first place!

I think they are really good, it's obvious they are part of the seven dwarves. (Presumably you're going to do a prettier/graceful Snow White!)
I'd definitely use them and can only think the less than favourable comments here must have come from experienced cake makers and decorators.

I think they're brilliant. Who cares if they're a bit quirky. That's part of the charm. Well done you, far better than could have done

I think they're brilliant. I've served cakes with a lot worse - the mermaid theme was a memorable one!

If you were selling these as a professional baker, then no. But it's a family party and I'm sure your DC will be thrilled with them.

My mum always made my birthday cakes and I still have fond memories of them, hoping my children will feel the same, despite them not being Instagram perfect.

I think Milo O'Shea on the right is a particularly good likeness. I like them.

I think these are weirdly great. It's a family party - spend the money somewhere else more memorable.

~sighs at pressure to live an Instagram perfect life and spend like the Kardashians~

They look great. I'd never be able to do that!

I like them
I bet your DD will love them
Good luck with the rest ☺️