I haven’t seen anyone on this thread say that prostituted women shouldn’t be listened to because they’ve been abused. That would be pretty inhumane victim blaming.
Firstly, I've met a huge amount of current and former sex workers and the vast vast majority object to being called 'prostituted women'. I hope you'd listen to any other marginalised person when they told you not to call them a certain term, so please afford sex workers the same courtesy.
Secondly, the comments about sex workers all apparently having being abused were not only misleading and inaccurate, but only ever seem to be made towards those who are expressing an opinion that the commenter disagrees with. I've been called some horrible things on here but the implication that sex workers don't know their own mind because they 'must' have been abused is the worst.
I agree that it's inhumane and dehumanising. I don't have personal experience of abuse so I'm not going to speak for people who have, but I will say if you want to know about this then you need to seek out current sex workers who have suffered it and listen to them. Unfortunately it's not likely they'll want to speak to you if you continue talking about sex workers like this.
When you say this "Is it reasonable to infer that historical abuse is the reason for a woman making bad choices and that it might muddy the waters about how much agency she has to consent? Yes." you are making a judgement on someone else's ability to consent, and that's not ok. When the previous poster falsely claimed that all sex workers have been abused the implication was that they can't consent and can't make good decisions. I'll say it again, I'm not trying to deny the effects of abuse, but the previous poster was saying that it applies to everyone, which is not true.
Is it unreasonable to argue that allowing men to buy your disassociated body for their sexual gratification isn’t an objectively bad decision or an act of self harm?
I would say it isn’t.
I'm not saying it can't be an act of self harm, but it's unfair to imply that it always is, which is what the previous poster was trying to do.
As long as we live in a society where men feel entitled to sex and to be able to buy access to women’s bodies, all women will continue to suffer misogyny under the patriarchy.
If you don't like the fact that sex work exists that's fair enough! But it does, and if you want to help sex workers you need to stop assuming your opinion is correct and start listening properly.
I'm not going to get into an argument with you, mainly because I doubt anything could change your mind, but please remember that your opinion is not necessarily factual, and please listen to sex workers when they say your language and behaviour is making life worse for them.
Pretending that all sex workers are somehow damaged or abused is just not true. There is a wide range of experiences and needs in sex workers, and acting like we've all had the same lives, while using dehumanising language and insisting you know best just doesn't help anyone.