Trans Women are Real Women and Should Have Access to Women's Spaces

[user08101988]

Started because a thread on Girlguiding was getting too off topic.

The evidence is stacking up against me, it seems. Tenor, hairy, scientist, and I have the finger ratio Aimee refers to as being male too. Damn good thing I have the fruit of my loins sitting next to me, otherwise I'd have no way of knowing what I am!

I am Hamlet Prince of Denmark. Could we get together?

No, just lips and brains on any one of billions of male humans. No “uniquely male brain” You seem a little stuck on this stereotype stuff.

A romance! 😍

It’s the same every time.

none of the trans are the actual other sex will ever engage with me.

why do I have less rights than them?

who is it ok for me to “out” myself as disabled and a rape victim but it’s not ok for them?

why does a man’s “internal cognition” matter more than my consent (or lack thereof)?

Hilarious!
My brain can tell me that I like engineering and wearing trousers and hate makeup. But it can't magically change my chromosomes from XX to XY. You can call yourself a man, a woman, a dog, a tree. You can call yourself what ever you like but you cannot change absolute scientific fact as to which sex you are.

No, that’s not ‘what women are’ that’s what women are capable of achieving.

Having the vote or owning my house is not what defines a woman as a women. Millions of women across the world don’t have these basic rights and yet they are still women.
Similarly millions of men across the world do have these rights and yet are not women!!

You'll have to be quick, they finish at 16.30. Unless you want to pay them overtime.

Tell my rapist the brain was the most important part of my body.

I've become a bit hairier too I don't have the proof of the fruit of my loins. :)

I do have a couple of letters from NHS Fife confirming that my uterine biopsy results came back 'normal'. Will that do?

No. Should not.

my pronouns are fuck and off.

What if you don’t have a job or own a house, what sex are you then? I could guess it’s one of the 100 specials genders, but that would be mean.

C’mon Taztoy, keep up. Because they’re MEN, all of em, despite what ra-ra skirt they happen to be wearing. You dont count against that, obvs

I'll allow it.

I'm glad you agree that there is no such thing as a male brain 👍🏻.
i am quite concerned about a number of comments to the contrary on this thread.

Good point. So Steven Wright, who killed 5 women at a minimum, should be in the female estate?

It depends on how quickly you can make up your mind. Maybe it if you have a good chat with your dad, it'll help you to come to a decision?

The fucking sneaky victim blaming pisses me right off.

im alert. Im ready to hit back (my paraphrase coz it is so fucking offensive I’m not going back to look)

therefore all those of us who fought as fucking hard as we bloody well could and STILL got overpowered? We just aren’t as GOOD. We didn’t try hard enough.

fuck that.

and I’m calling it out.

Great 👍 now, about your earlier disingenuous comment that the Supreme Court haven’t adjudicated on whether “trans women” are women in terms of women’s spaces?

I thank you.

Those stirrups were not in vain.

Nobody is policing your language.
You accused women of weaponising pronouns, ergo you did the policing.
Please refrain.

Flat-Earthers and Anti-Vaxxers (amongst other 'passionate' ideologues) also bombard their detractors with junk science. You're certainly not special in that regard. You try so desperately to mould reality to your ridiculous narrative.

Personally speaking, I think you're all cut from the same cloth and barking mad. 🤪

Which thread on girlguiding? The one started in response to the law stating that transwomen are NOT women? I don’t want to share my space with a bloke who has decided his name is now Wendy and wears a dress, especially if he still has a penis.

The best pronouns that I ever heard came from a Third Year pupil in a Scottish secondary. His pal announced that his pronouns were "ze/zim", to which he announced "Aye! And mine are 'yer/maw'!"

Haha nice try

I said that the Supreme Court have not adjudicated on whether trans women are women.
which is absolutely correct as per paragraph 2 of the judgement and yet widely misunderstood and weaponised across mumsnet.

https://supremecourt.uk/uploads/uksc_2024_0042_judgment_aea6c48cee.pdf