Trans Women are Real Women and Should Have Access to Women's Spaces

[user08101988]

Started because a thread on Girlguiding was getting too off topic.

Every cell in the body of a biological female will be XX.
Every cell in the body of a biological male will be XY.

It would appear that some people* who like to argue the ‘biology’ case, are unaware of this basic fact.

*probably along with the majority of people in general.

Trans identified men, should not have access to women's spaces.

I bloody love being a crone.

@Wishesandhorses

Actually many beliefs in souls returning to human form at intervals for lifetimes discuss that souls don't have a gender, and that the point of a soul having a 'human' incarnation is to learn in the journey of that soul through multiple lives, during which the soul will enter bodies of both sexes for the wide range of experience needed, and usually talks about the soul or higher self having chosen the body and life it goes into. The soul itself doesn't have a sex.

So transgenderism would actually be going against the very point of existence? If existence is about learning from a wide range of experience, then insisting on refusing the current sex we're in is refusing the current crop of experience we're supposed to collect. Huh. Interesting 🤔

Sorry lol

I have a Lady Grinning Soul

And it's grinning right at you, OP

One that can sing anywhere with the tenor/baritone/bass range.

My soul identifies as a hermit swamp witch.

If you are so enamoured with this study, do you accept its conclusions:

"The observed shift away from a male-typical brain anatomy towards a female-typical one in people who identify as transgender women suggests a possible underlying neuroanatomical correlate for a female gender identity. "
if so, do you recognise this suggests evidence of a biological underpinning to being a transgender woman?

Harry Potter isn't a potter.

@Wishesandhorses I have seen my soul, its female

Nonsense, I smoke and can do a passable tenor on occasions!

Goodness, you clearly understand this stuff so well! Would you like to explain it in plain English for those of us unfortunate enough to have only developed female brains on account of us being women and not having our brains enhanced by a temporary illusion that we are men?

Genuine question. What does "male affected brain" mean, and how are you measuring this?

... This is one of those times when I took someone seriously while they were just taking the piss, isn't it?

Okay, that was a good one then! Souls!

😁

' They could have a soul that was always female until now'

See, I find this quite cute.

It's meaningless, but honest. At least it spells out what 'gender identity' is based on. An ineffable, indescribable item of faith.

A 'female soul' is not a thing that we can base the law on.

I'm getting unfortunate images, I'm afraid.

I'll chat it through with the fairies at the bottom of my garden and get back to you.

It’s the study the OP posted in support of his claim that TWAW.

Where did I put my bingo card dabber pen thingy??
AMAB ✔️
Sex assigned at birth✔️
Echo chamber✔️
Anti trans✔️

Ooh women can open bank accounts
And have jobs!!!
Who knew 🙄
Give me 5 minutes to find my eyes cos they've rolled right down the back of the sofa

Womens' spaces for women- every time, every day of every week and year

I have one quite often, but only when DP is pissing me off.

Brain Sex and the Soul of a Female.

New band T shirts coming soon!

I don't smoke and am always a tenor. Makes me popular with female voice choirs!

Long-long-long time ago when all of this started, I always thought that there was only one test - say a transwoman is admitted to A&E (don't wish it on anyone, it is only for talking sakes), and this is a life-and-death progression situation. And a female dose is 100 ml and a male dose is 200 ml, again, for talking sakes. And the doctor says 'please tell me what dose to administer, but the administration of the wrong dose will lead to a lethal outcome for you'. I bet you anything that a transwoman will go for the 200 ml, without any doubt. So, basically, if it is costume-play, it is one thing, but if it were life-or-death, the fog would lift very quickly and the realisation, I am a man, give me 200 ml, I don't want to die would ensue.

What does this mean?

And how do you know?