Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Do women in the U.K. know or care about the threat to women’s and girls rights now they’ve voted labour?

1000 replies

Heylo · 05/07/2024 07:14

i know the tories record on public services are abysmal and bar some genuine believers like Kemi Badenoch the tories would likely go the trans route if they thought it would buy them votes. But, currently it’s the tories who offered to protect women and girls from the trans madness. My question is - which women voted in trans loving, women - hating Labour?

we can look forward to -

  1. continued gender ideology being pumped out in schools
  2. conversion ban - you better hope your child doesn’t start questioning their gender out loud because TRA ridden schools will be referring them to gender clinics and socially transitioning them now they have a mandate
  3. same sex attracted lesbians (myself included) it’s completely game over. Keep your head down and your mouth shut. Trans identified males and their female allies have already closed down every women only night. Same sex attracted women are now labelled bigots. We are no longer welcome in London’s LGBT soup community
  4. prisons - what happens to vulnerable women? They are already disbelieved and dismissed. Now they have to endure the staring and various forms of sexual harrassment that goes with being incarcerated with men

i can only hope our political landscape mirrors America and in the same way Trump will be voted back in this year, we will have The Tories being led by Kemi back in in 4 years time.

omg I can’t believe we have to kiss goodbye to women’s rights - for the next four years

back to my original question. Apart from TRA idealouges, why have women voted these clowns in? Is it that they prioritise the Tories terrible record on public services over this? Do some women not see it as a huge issue? would love to hear from some posters who voted Labour.

Thanks & stay safe out there, as women we have woken up to a a dark chapter in history today

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
CatusFlatus · 05/07/2024 09:03

Captainmycaptains · 05/07/2024 09:02

I’m not sure that getting hysterical and being a doommonger over this is going to achieve anything.

Nice use of a misogynistic term there.

Sloejelly · 05/07/2024 09:03

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/07/2024 08:57

But “cis” men do this sort of thing all the time?? There are no safe spaces, there are no single sex spaces. Men can and do invade spaces which are not for them. Men don’t need to transition to
prey on women.

Argh this argument! You don't fucking remove basic safeguarding measures because 'men are going to do it anyway'. You don't make it easier.

I presume everyone who makes this argument never locks their front door when they go out. Afterall thieves don’t need to use the door to break into a house.

Helleofabore · 05/07/2024 09:04

LunaandLily · 05/07/2024 08:54

But “cis” men do this sort of thing all the time?? There are no safe spaces, there are no single sex spaces. Men can and do invade spaces which are not for them. Men don’t need to transition to
prey on women.

Quite right. Yet no government should be making it even easier by allowing male people into female single sex spaces via policy and guidance.

Under the influence of political lobby groups such as Stonewall, the current situation has been allowed. Telling female people that ‘it is going to happen anyway’ is certainly not going to close the loopholes that have been created intentionally or unintentionally. Telling female people it is going happen anyway, has a chilling effect on campaigning to make women and children safer.

Mrsdyna · 05/07/2024 09:04

traytablestowed · 05/07/2024 09:02

@Mrsdyna thanks, I am Grin it's so great to finally have the Tory's out!!! I'm looking forward to a brighter future for this country, including all the women in it who have been so badly let down for the last 14 years.

Aww, bless 😂

Coffeedreaming · 05/07/2024 09:04

Bollindger · 05/07/2024 09:03

I think as females right now we need to start invading the Gents.
Every time. Even if we just wash our hands.
The only way Men will back us is if they have a problem....

Except there’s no threat to them so it’s much less of a big deal in the gents.

Yes men deserve privacy too but the big issue here is safety

Chickenuggetsticks · 05/07/2024 09:05

CatusFlatus · 05/07/2024 08:58

It's not about so called 'transwomen' it's about men.

Men as a sex class (transwomen are men, humans cannot change sex) are a threat to women - fact.

Replacing sex with the concept of 'gender identity' removes the distinction between women and men. Women's spaces, legal protections, healthcare, prisons, sports, changing rooms, everything, cease to exist because they're now mixed sex.

I really don't understand why some people find it so difficult to grasp this.

If you're OK with that, not just for yourself but for every other woman including severely learning disabled women, women with dementia, incarcerated women, rape survivors and more, then I'm truly amazed.

Tbh I'd rather the government, sports governing bodies and so on were just honest and abolished sex categories, that would at least make it clear to people what is happening.

At the moment it's not regarded as a big issue by many because it's still relatively hidden. Also, because women are by definition second class citizens in a patriarchal world, their rights, needs and wants are secondary to men's even amongst other women (remember transwomen are men, it's the only qualification).

Precisely, for me I always think about some poor woman who has dementia being forced to accept intimate care from someone she correctly identifies as male but keeps being told is a woman. It’s gaslighting.

If you let one man in how do you prevent others from also entering?

CandiedPrincess · 05/07/2024 09:05

Actually many schools use teaching resources from activist organisations and do teach gender ideology as a fact...rather than as a contested theory. Also, many schools have activist teachers running LGBTQ+ lunchtime clubs.

Five kids. Five different schools. Haven't come across any of this. Not "many" schools, I think you mean "some" and even then it's probably a tiny majority. Stop scaremongering.

traytablestowed · 05/07/2024 09:06

@Mrsdyna sorry you didn't get the result you wanted hun.

Whatever1964 · 05/07/2024 09:06

Sloejelly · 05/07/2024 08:50

They are only 0.5% of the adult population. PP are talking about children in schools.

That's not making the point you think it is.

Andthereitis · 05/07/2024 09:06

Every lid dem and green is a danger too.

They are seriously deranged.

Mrsdyna · 05/07/2024 09:07

traytablestowed · 05/07/2024 09:06

@Mrsdyna sorry you didn't get the result you wanted hun.

That's ok, neither will you.

Signalbox · 05/07/2024 09:07

Bearpawk · 05/07/2024 08:43

@Signalbox so that's one trans person not 3.

We don't 'all know' people who Id as yhe opposite sex - I live in the most LGBTQ friendly city in the uk and I don't actually know any trans people personally. Or any nb people. Just lots of gay men and women. And I have a very wide circle and I'm very sociable.

Are you saying that people who claim to be non-binary are not trans? I know Stonewall kicked out the cross-dressers last week but I didn’t know they’d turned their backs on the they/thems too.

borntobequiet · 05/07/2024 09:07

Trans women are no more of a threat to me than any other woman. Trans women are disproportionately vulnerable

Actual evidence suggests that this isn’t true. Transwomen conform to male pattern violent offending.

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/pdf/

Helleofabore · 05/07/2024 09:08

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/07/2024 08:57

It isn't a trans people issue. It's a MEN issue.

Yes!

And just for clarity for those who consider men are women too, MALE people are the issue. Including male people who claim
not to be men.

Eatstootsandleaves · 05/07/2024 09:09

DaisyCat33 · 05/07/2024 07:21

You're a lesbian and you don't support trans rights? There's a T in LGBT you know

No I don't see this as a huge issue. I don't see trans people as some sort of dangerous or risky group that are out to get me 🙄

No, there was LGB for decades, where we fought for equal rights and won. Stonewall had fulfilled its remit, but it had staff to pay and spare capacity — so the TQ+ saw an opportunity and quietly approached Ruth Hunt with a proposal.

Because of Hunt's bad decision to add the TQ+, the LGB community was forced into a marriage which they didn't consent to. It's a toxic relationship in which people who are sex-based (LGB is all about same SEX attraction) are expected to support people who are GENDER-feelings-based (who believe if a man says he's a woman and a lesbian, he's a woman and a lesbian — even though he's very clearly a man). This is a classic abusive relationship. And lots of gay men, in particular, absolutely hate the word Queer after years of queer-bashing. So to be tethered to the TQ+ is a nightmare.

The LGB need to divorce the TQ+ who are leeching off them and destroying the concept of same-sex attraction and same-sex-sexuality. And then they need to take out a restraining order to prevent the TQ+ ever coming near them again.

Fargo79 · 05/07/2024 09:09

Honestly, people can fuck off with the accusations that "women have let each other down", or the insinuation that women who voted for Labour are too stupid to understand the issues (which is drenched in misogyny, btw).

It's not been an easy vote to cast. I am deeply, deeply worried about the threat to women's rights. But right now, in the present moment, my family is in desperate need of better healthcare provision, better SEND provision and a better educational system. We can't wait any longer. It may be the difference between one of my children being able to live an independent life or needing care forever. It could be the difference between one of my children's parents having their mobility or not within the next few years. I don't know if Labour can make the difference, but I am absolutely certain that things would only have declined further under the Tories. I don't think for a second that KS actually believes TWAW. I am hopeful that some common sense will prevail and that there is continued pressure on the incoming government.

I will not be made to feel guilty for casting my vote in the interests of my family and thousands upon thousands of others in similar circumstances. This was an awful hand to be dealt and we've done what we think is the "least worst".

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 05/07/2024 09:09

Sloejelly · 05/07/2024 09:03

I presume everyone who makes this argument never locks their front door when they go out. Afterall thieves don’t need to use the door to break into a house.

Exactly. Why bother with new ways of finding deterrents, ring doorbells and the like.

PoliticalCanvasser · 05/07/2024 09:10

BlowDryRat · 05/07/2024 07:22

I think the result is the best we could have hoped for: a change in government but no groundswell of popular support for Labour. They do not have the mandate in terms of the popular vote to push through unpopular policies like anti-women GRC reforms.

They have an almost 200 seat majority, they can literally do whatever the fuck they like. And the Libs won't be stopping them.

This is why I despaired at all the gloating (although I can't say I was sorry when Truss got the boot) because we must have a decent, coherent opposition. To everyone wildly celebrating a Labour win-enjoy it. But please think about what happens when they do something you don't like. Who will be there to dissent?

Petitee · 05/07/2024 09:10

TheAlchemistElixa · 05/07/2024 08:58

Well don’t be.

I shouldn't be scared about children being taught inappropriate stuff? Or little girls sharing a changing room with men who claim to identify as women? Starmer wants to bring in self ID and allow men to be in female only spaces. Starmer doesn't care about protecting women and girls.

WomensRightsRenegade · 05/07/2024 09:11

DaisyCat33 · 05/07/2024 07:21

You're a lesbian and you don't support trans rights? There's a T in LGBT you know

No I don't see this as a huge issue. I don't see trans people as some sort of dangerous or risky group that are out to get me 🙄

The T is antithetical to the LGB. Gender ideology has caused incalculable damage to the L in particular, with same-SEX attracted women being called sexual racists.

Shame on you and your white MRA horror show

DoIWantTo · 05/07/2024 09:12

I have a DC who is a lesbian and vocal about biological sex, I’m scared for her. However I did not vote Tory nor Labour. Sickens me that so many did.

edited because I went to say I voted neither T nor L but wasn’t sure if it was grammatically correct, changed the sentence and forgot to remove the whole thing 🤦🏻‍♀️

Grammarnut · 05/07/2024 09:12

StepUpSlowly · 05/07/2024 08:57

As a fellow lesbian I respect your experience but don’t share it at all (nor your point of view). Everything you are experiencing now has nothing to do with the future political party in charge, anyway. I (alongside my countless lesbian friends) have never felt not welcome or unsafe due to trans women in our spaces, but personally I have also always been welcoming and treated people with respect (and yes, I don’t date/sleep with transwomen (I am not saying I never would as love can surpise you but never have and have little interest to so it’s unlikely) and I don’t hide it either and I am still very much welcome in my spaces.

As a woman I would say that most of my threats very much come from men who feel like men and fully embrace their testosterone levels and as such feel powerful enough to control me, my body and my rights.

Trans people pose very little threat in comparison to all the men in charge or those who walk the streets at night. Guess who have enough power to truly strip me from my rights as a gay woman of color? Men. How many trans women do you know in position of power? All those policies you are afraid of are currently voted in and mainly enforced by men (not trans women but men).

Trans people are 1% or so of the population. In that 1% how many of them are proven rapists? What’s the ratio vs men who completely identify as men?

As a lesbian have you never felt harassed by other women (not trans women) in lesbian or queer spaces? Because I have. In fact in lesbian spaces I have never ever been harassed by a trans woman despite them being present and almost always have felt harassed by other women/fellow lesbians. The trans women I have met have been completely understanding if I am not interested, but I have had plenty of lesbians who weren’t so keen on taking a no. I have also definitely been assaulted by other women.

In fact I wouldn’t even be surprised if the number of sexual assault at the hand of women is equivalent or even higher than those of transwomen. As in, both very low, with very little data on the subject, but yes. Women aren’t necessarily the best as taking no for an answer either.

So, yes your choice to sleep with whoever you want should always be respected but I personally don’t think trans women are a threat to my freedom (at least not any bigger threat than any other demographic. In fact religious women are likely a bigger threat to me in terms of policies they might want implemented in that regard if given the choice and they probably make up for a much bigger portion of the population than trans women.)

So I think a lot of women care about their rights and that’s why they vote the way they vote. Because trans folks while maybe worrying for some (not for me) are really not the biggest threat to women, their rights and their well-being right now.

I'm not a Lesbian. I am not happy with transwomen being in my spaces, however. They are men, what are they doing in my lavatories, my changing rooms, my sports, my prizes, my refuges, my prisons? There is a lot of evidence that TiMs and their allies commit violence against women, GC women who dare to say that TiMs are men, both verbally (you need only look at the threats to JKRowling) and physically. There was a Let Women Speak rally in Brighton a couple of weeks ago. The women who wished to speak for their rights were drowned out by men shouting about their right to invade women's spaces. Wake up, do.

Pipsquiggle · 05/07/2024 09:13

I feel 'trans' is now in the same ball park as 'small boats' - hysteria around something that affects less than 1% of the country.

I know 1 trans person as work. She has given diversity training which was incredibly helpful and enlightening.

The most dangerous group to women are cis men.
Personally I feel inequality, poverty, NHS, education, violence against women & girls usurp this fringe issue.

WomensRightsRenegade · 05/07/2024 09:13

Fargo79 · 05/07/2024 09:09

Honestly, people can fuck off with the accusations that "women have let each other down", or the insinuation that women who voted for Labour are too stupid to understand the issues (which is drenched in misogyny, btw).

It's not been an easy vote to cast. I am deeply, deeply worried about the threat to women's rights. But right now, in the present moment, my family is in desperate need of better healthcare provision, better SEND provision and a better educational system. We can't wait any longer. It may be the difference between one of my children being able to live an independent life or needing care forever. It could be the difference between one of my children's parents having their mobility or not within the next few years. I don't know if Labour can make the difference, but I am absolutely certain that things would only have declined further under the Tories. I don't think for a second that KS actually believes TWAW. I am hopeful that some common sense will prevail and that there is continued pressure on the incoming government.

I will not be made to feel guilty for casting my vote in the interests of my family and thousands upon thousands of others in similar circumstances. This was an awful hand to be dealt and we've done what we think is the "least worst".

There is literally no money for any of the things you seek. None. None of that is going to change. And remember it was Labour who brought in both uni fees and ATOS assessments for the disabled.

The only changes Labour can make are the free ones. Pushing hugely divisive and destructive ‘culture war’ shit from race essentialism to gender ideology.

achipandachair · 05/07/2024 09:13

I voted Labour not because I don't know or care about any of this, but because the conservatives have trashed our society and the public infrastructure and the country is in a desperate state after 14 years of conservative nonsense.

As someone else has pointed out, true TRAs see Starmer's labour party as transphobic which I think is an indication of gender critical points of view being less unsayable than they used to be. There are legal frameworks around this which, of course, matter, but I think how this all plays out in real life has got a lot to do with the situation in mainstream society and I am happy to say that attitudes are not as nuts as they were a few years ago - thanks to sustained and determined activism - in which mumsnet played a huge part.

My kids go to a secondary school which has quietly dropped Stonewall logos from its website. Its safeguarding policies are - and I suspect always have been, stonewall association notwithstanding (though its stonewall days predate my kids' attendance at this school so I don't know) single sex for PE and anything requiring residential stays. I asked about this and the response I got was very common sense. In many places, no matter what it is trendy to virtue signal about, real life people never really caught up with what what they were "supposed" to be doing in favour of the TRA agenda (because parts of it were blatantly nuts) and I think now never will, thank goodness.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.