Hi - I was replying to a comment that was specifically about memory:
"I find the people who airily declare "Babies won't remember anything they've seen anyway, so we should let them watch everything" very strange. I can only assume, if they genuinely believe this to be true, that their offspring are raised in (say) a featureless grey room with white noise playing. I mean, if they really think babies are just memoryless blobs, why did they bother singing the awful Wheels On The Bus until they were sick of it, in the first place?"
So about the fragility of memory in babies and very young children and the phenomenon of "childhood amnesia" and, although they both impact on adult memory, that was not my main point.
Could you say more about this? If you have got any references I would be really interested:
"These early experiences are transformative to the brain because of neuroplasticity, and so the effect of an experience like CBR cannot be understood totally just by whether they remember as an adult."
There are so many things to be concerned about wrt this Caba Baba Rave monstrosity but I have yet to be convinced that the most dangerous aspect is the fact that it was experienced by children under the age of two, rather than up to the age of five which seems possible from the advert on Happity. However, it is reassuring that most people have a visceral reaction of shock and disgust to babies being present, as it is obviously not a good idea at all.
Others have expressed it better than me already but I think that focussing in close on the presence of babies risks missing the massive dangers of the bigger picture ("queering" of society) and, lets say, the "medium focus" of the impact an event like this might have on the parents, their future parenting and safeguarding their children.
I'm not saying, "Forget about the impact on the babies" but the press coverage I have seen tends to amplify this aspect. Although maybe that is the best way to deal with this in terms of alerting the public and garnering opposition? To connect with that visceral reaction rather than possibly dilute the message by over-intellectualising things and bringing in the wider context?
Bit of a change of tack. Another thing that I have wondered about is what else, if anything, is going on in those areas of town that mums could go to with their babies and young children? Is there nothing? If there are alternatives, why are they less appealing than this bizarre event? £25 and £5 each for extra kids for 45 mins is not cheap. Is there a vacuum that these drag events have moved in to fill?
If there is a demand for troupes of uninhibited adults dressed up outrageously and performing whacky stunts to music then Morris Dancers are missing a golden opportunity because they could clean up! 😂