Hello fellow travellers, good luck to us all.
I'm going to tell you my story if it helps anyone. From a high of 12.8 at 5ft5 I am now around 10st 10. or so. I don't weigh myself anymore as I use my jeans and tops to gauge when I'm slipping into the fat zone!
It took about a year to sort myself out as I comfort ate following family traumas and bereavements. A not uncommon story.
I started off with intermittent fasting. I broke the rules many times, but I forced myself to stick to it and I lost weight gradually. I really cut down on carbohydrates and upped the protein, grains, seeds, nuts and veg/berries. Once I got used to it I honestly didn't think about it much. It stopped me snacking at night which I'm sure many are guilty of. It's not that I just stopped, I felt I was breaking the rules, and I like rules!
So over time and holidays and Christmas and whatnot I yo yo'd a bit. But I now have a good (but punishing) solution which may be frowned upon. When I feel my clothes are getting tight again, I eat very little except Greek yog/berries/seeds, eggs or salmon and veg for a week and I get back on track.
I'm just finished my week of hard cutting back and as I said, I don't weigh myself, but the dress that was so tight across the stomach is now fitting well again. So back to 16/8 and more or less normal eating now apart from sugar and white bread/potatoes and pasta.
It works for me, but I really have to keep an eye on things. That said I do misbehave a lot, but know I have to pay for it immediately after or I'll just go back to the unhealthy ways.