Please or to access all these features

30 days only

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I prefer one of my children over the other

151 replies

ihaveafavourite · 27/08/2026 15:56

And I don’t feel great about it. I feel pretty awful but I really am struggling with what to do about it.

My DS is nearly 6 and is very full on. He’s loud, argumentative, stroppy, even when he’s affectionate it’s too much so he’ll sit on your lap endlessly elbowing you and pulling hair and poking his fingers into your face.

I have spent a lot of time with him this summer as he’s been on holiday of course and I just have not enjoyed it at all. Some of it’s fairly standard five y/o I am sure: I’ll ask a question and he’ll answer ‘yes’ but in a really stupid put on voice, like YUUUUURS at the top of his voice. Winds other children up terribly - I think some play dates have been rescinded because of this.

of course I love him but I can’t pretend life isn’t easier with just his sibling, a 3 yo DD. And I feel horrible about it.

OP posts:
EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 08:14

Do you have any family that can care for dd op? Or a nursery place that she can go to for the morning etc and take your son out on his own? Spend some time cuddling him, and attending to him. This is attention seeking and it is happening because he isn't getting enough 1-1 time with a parent.

It sounds like you might not want to spend time with him, or to make it happen. If that is the case it is really a good idea to speak to a counsellor (It is free if you ask GP) and discuss the underlying issues. Maybe he reminds you of his father, or you associate him with difficult periods in your life or resentment that hasn't been acknowledged. I wouldn't ignore the feelings you have, as it could get worse, you have already described your relationship as deteriorating - and he is only five years old.

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:16

No. Her nursery is term time only and DS is obviously at school then. Any arrangements I make will only be fleeting, so I do have to manage them both together for now.

OP posts:
Snufkin88 · 28/08/2026 08:19

@ihaveafavourite here is an article I read the other day on the subject, it’s not all that well written but quite relevant to your situation

https://www.thejournal.ie/readme/favourite-child-7123663-Aug2026/

Squidgemoon · 28/08/2026 08:21

Just a small suggestion OP but sign him up for martial arts. My DS has done karate for 6 years now and it’s so good for him. There’s quite a few kids in his class with ADHD and it’s a good combination of energy release and discipline for them.

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:22

Thanks @Snufkin88 . It’s interesting we favour daughters and younger children, as that’s obviously difficult when you have boy and girl with older boy and younger girl.

He already does swimming, football, rugby and Squirrels @Squidgemoon and we’d struggle to fit anything else in if I’m honest, but thank you.

OP posts:
EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 08:22

Fleeting is better than nothing.

Your son is just a small child. Most children are annoying at different points, but you seem to actively dislike being with him almost all of the time. I am just aware this could easily result in your son becoming the 'difficult' child (scapegoat) in the family, your dd is a golden child because she is so 'good' and you will be sowing the seeds for a very dysfunctional family that will damage both children in the long term.

He is not annoying he is curious and talkative
He is not too much, he is high energy and full of life

He will eventually pick up on your dislike and displeasure and think there is something intrinsically wrong with who he is/ how he is, which will damage his self esteem and confidence. These are his foundation years, and your messaging and your reaction to him will be internalised.

The way you are framing and describing his very normal behaviour is worrying.

Phineyj · 28/08/2026 08:24

OrdinaryGirl · 28/08/2026 08:01

Mum of three boys here 👋🏼
This sounds really hard and I can hear in your post how you’re struggling with it all. I have a few thoughts.
First is that the final week of the school summer holidays is not a good time for parents to try and make reliable, clear-eyed assessments on how we feel about our kids. 😏
After five weeks of no routine, being eaten out of house and home, often no break from being with them, AND in most situations having to manage working as well, lots of folk are at a low ebb.
Lacking in patience, feeling exhausted and depleted and frustrated and maybe also apprehensive about the ‘holidays’ ending and being expected to be raring to go in September. Your state of wellbeing is the lens through which you look at everything in your life. And unless you are a millionaire with nanny-level childcare on tap and lots of funds to spend on massages and trips out with friends, the last week of August is probably going to feel less than amazing. Some of what you’re feeling will very likely improve when schools go back and you aren’t having to deal with your son all the time.

Second thing is that everything is a phase. I’ve been on Mumsnet 13 years and this has been one of the most helpful MN mantras I’ve seen. All three of my DSs got a lot easier to deal with at age 6. They seemed to get with the programme more at school and that helped at home too.

Fully agree with the physical exercise point someone made upthread. Particularly between the ages of 1 and 8, if we didn’t run them out like spaniels at every opportunity, it would feel really chaotic and they would be much harder to deal with. NONE of my friends with daughters experienced this with their girls (though obviously this is not necessarily indicative) It was annoying to have to constantly get out of the house and off on a yomp or to a bloody play park in all weathers BUT it did make our lives easier for that period.

Another thing is to be careful with your perceptions and notice the narrative that may be being constructed in your mind. What I mean is that if we get an idea in our head about the way things are (in this case it might be ‘My son is so hard to deal with, I don’t like him’), the way our brains work is that they often start to look for evidence confirming that view. Your attention is like a torch-beam. There might be lots of stuff in a dark room, but it’s the stuff you shine the light on that you actually see.

You can start to bring some balance back by physically writing down every day one thing your son did that was gentler, or sweet, or where he tried hard. I know it sounds weird but maybe take a pic of you cuddling with him and put it up somewhere you can see it. A picture of the loving mum you want to be, in terms of the feelings in your head, not just the care you’re providing him.

Finally I would say to extend some grace to yourself about these feelings. Being a parent is HARD. So much of what we do goes unnoticed and everyone needs some kindness and support. You’re not a machine. Get some stuff in the diary wherever you can - starting today - that will give you joy, that will lift your spirits. Even if it’s as small as buying a magazine or having coffee with a mate. It all helps.

Sending you an encouraging shoulder-squeeze this morning OP. Hang in there ☕️ 🍰

Edited to add: finding a mum with a similarly energetic boy can be a lifeline. They get to tear around together and you get to chat with her about how exhausting it is and feel less alone - double win.

Edited

I find this post really wise.

I've got a hyperactive girl though! And I'm afraid she was at her most challenging around 7-8. She was diagnosed with ADHD and ASD at 7 though which gave me more insight into why we were struggling so much more as parents than our friends.

The book I recommended has got some good strategies for thinking more positively about your challenging child.

EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 08:24

You might also be severely burnt out, and this will be impacting how you parent. I hope you can get some support op.

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:25

Yes, well we can’t even have fleeting.

I genuinely don’t need long lectures about DS. I do realise there is no ill intent but he has presented a number of challenges this summer and just as some of his friends have started to back away I suppose I’ve started to feel similar, combined with the horrible sense of being responsible for him and his behaviour. Hopefully it is just a phase. Anyway …

OP posts:
Mydogisagentleman · 28/08/2026 08:27

My DH was his mother's absolute favourite. He could do no wrong (not that he ever did).
Her favouritism was definitely obvious to his siblings.
Please try not to make it obvious to your son. I know that my SIL struggled.

EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 08:29

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:25

Yes, well we can’t even have fleeting.

I genuinely don’t need long lectures about DS. I do realise there is no ill intent but he has presented a number of challenges this summer and just as some of his friends have started to back away I suppose I’ve started to feel similar, combined with the horrible sense of being responsible for him and his behaviour. Hopefully it is just a phase. Anyway …

What do you want pp to say if there are no solutions and you don't want to find any? You are not even willing to look at the damage you might be doing to him?

Did you come on here and expect people to say it is normal and fine and just carry on?? No, it is not normal or fine, and if you don't want to address any of this in yourself and try and understand why you are reacting to him like this, and are simply looking for your son to change/disappear then I think you have a very tough road ahead.

I feel very sorry for him. He is just a small child and you are his only carer in life.

Phineyj · 28/08/2026 08:30

@EnglishRose26 my parents (especially my mum) framed us as "the independent one" and "the one who needs support" when my DSis and I were quite little and it still causes issues in our 50s. Plus I HAD to be independent because they'd kind of already decided...

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:30

@EnglishRose26 i am engaging to and thanking people with useful, thoughtful and helpful points. That’s not you, though. So don’t worry.

@Mydogisagentleman i am trying but it is very hard because I also cannot ignore some behaviour. Some low level stuff yes, but it is rarely low level with DS!

OP posts:
Phineyj · 28/08/2026 08:35

You could do something like a Saturday morning dance class for DD (even my rather tomboyish DD went through the tutu-love phase at that age) and that could be "DS time" where he has your attention? Obviously pick the class location carefully. One of the ones we did was in a leisure centre where parents waited in a large area with a cafe, soft play etc and another was just off a library that had Lego and plentiful superhero "early readers" for instance.

OrdinaryGirl · 28/08/2026 08:35

Just a thought… you haven’t mentioned your DSs’ dad, and I don’t know if he is involved or even alive, but I wonder if this may be a factor.
I know of situations where a single mum has really struggled because of how much like her ex her son is. Whether it’s in problematic behaviour / challenging temperament, or interests or even just looks.
Cosncious I could be over-stepping but if you went to therapy it’s likely this would be something the therapist would explore with you.

Edited to add: just seen your comment saying you don’t need long lectures and I’m realising my post was probably the longest but very much not intended as a lecture - sorry was just trying to help 😔

Snufkin88 · 28/08/2026 08:37

EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 08:29

What do you want pp to say if there are no solutions and you don't want to find any? You are not even willing to look at the damage you might be doing to him?

Did you come on here and expect people to say it is normal and fine and just carry on?? No, it is not normal or fine, and if you don't want to address any of this in yourself and try and understand why you are reacting to him like this, and are simply looking for your son to change/disappear then I think you have a very tough road ahead.

I feel very sorry for him. He is just a small child and you are his only carer in life.

Honestly @EnglishRose26 children go through phases of being annoying and hard to deal with . That’s normal. Op has not described any behaviour that is suggesting he is being mistreated or damaged.

QuietBlueFrog · 28/08/2026 08:41

The feelings you are describing are very strong OP and a bit more than the “I love you but don’t rally like you atm” state many parents experience. You sound frazzled and like you could really benefit from talking this through with someone neutral. I’m not going to ask you where dad is because I imagine there is a backstory here you don’t want to go into, but is there a possibility your DS is bearing the brunt of this? In the meantime I really recommend The Book You Wish Your Parents Had Read by Phillipa Perry. You might find it helps put words to the feelings you are experiencing.

Tryagain26 · 28/08/2026 08:43

Children go through different stages. Next year you might find that you prefer your son.
As long as you love them equally and you don't let them know you favour one of them don't worry. It's natural to find certain stages particularly annoying..

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:45

Phineyj · 28/08/2026 08:35

You could do something like a Saturday morning dance class for DD (even my rather tomboyish DD went through the tutu-love phase at that age) and that could be "DS time" where he has your attention? Obviously pick the class location carefully. One of the ones we did was in a leisure centre where parents waited in a large area with a cafe, soft play etc and another was just off a library that had Lego and plentiful superhero "early readers" for instance.

She already does but by the time we’ve got there and have to pick her up again it’s maybe 40 minutes I get with ds (and bear in mind I have to take him there and back) it’s not really meaningful quality time, is it? I’m not trying to be snarky but I do think this can be a problem with MN: there’s a tendency to fixate on one small piece of the overall puzzle so I’ll make an offhand comment about him being better one on one and I get a few posters focusing on that and trying to engineer ways it can happen. I do try quite hard to make it happen, but it isn’t possible often and plus he then reverts as soon as DD is with us anyway and I can’t really send her away indefinitely!

@OrdinaryGirl DS is VERY like his dad but that’s OK; his dad was a good man. I do gather he was a PITA as a young child so I’m hopeful we may see the other side yet.

i do overreact I know but he’s been such hard work this summer and it does affect me and my friendships as well as dd and hers, and it’s hard not to worry about this.

OP posts:
ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:49

@QuietBlueFrog i did actually get halfway through that but had to give it up in disgust - it was so guilt tripping and impractical. I really don’t think ds is bearing the brunt of anything; I do honestly try hard to be positive and encouraging and have firm boundaries but also praise but sometimes I do get worn down and I lose patience.

I tried to explain to ds the other day that my patience was like a full bag of sweets and every time he didn’t do as I asked or roared or threw something or wound his sister / his friends up (didn’t list all these but you get the gist!) it was like someone took a sweet away and then by the end of the day I have no sweets / patience left and end up annoyed.

I did actually see some mum friends last night with similar aged children and they were describing similar stuff so perhaps it is the age.

OP posts:
sparrowhawkhere · 28/08/2026 08:49

Wear him out. Find something you enjoy together to bond over. Let little things go but if it’s something annoying that adds to your feelings then work on that, like poking you in the face or using a silly voice. Praise for when he responds. I’ve got a child who is much harder work than the other, there are some annoying habits I have to eradicate (if I can) because their whole personality can be quite overwhelming at times and it helps me feel less grumpy.

BunnyLake · 28/08/2026 08:52

My older son was much harder work than my younger one but once he grew out of it he was an angel. He’s an adult now and the kindest loveliest son. So is my younger one, it just took a bit longer for one of them.

Phineyj · 28/08/2026 08:53

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:45

She already does but by the time we’ve got there and have to pick her up again it’s maybe 40 minutes I get with ds (and bear in mind I have to take him there and back) it’s not really meaningful quality time, is it? I’m not trying to be snarky but I do think this can be a problem with MN: there’s a tendency to fixate on one small piece of the overall puzzle so I’ll make an offhand comment about him being better one on one and I get a few posters focusing on that and trying to engineer ways it can happen. I do try quite hard to make it happen, but it isn’t possible often and plus he then reverts as soon as DD is with us anyway and I can’t really send her away indefinitely!

@OrdinaryGirl DS is VERY like his dad but that’s OK; his dad was a good man. I do gather he was a PITA as a young child so I’m hopeful we may see the other side yet.

i do overreact I know but he’s been such hard work this summer and it does affect me and my friendships as well as dd and hers, and it’s hard not to worry about this.

I meant you stay at the venue and do something with him there.

ConfusedSoShutUp · 28/08/2026 08:54

EnglishRose26 · 28/08/2026 07:43

Op, you don't enjoy being with him at all, and you much prefer his younger sibling is pretty serious.

I would ignore the flippant/dismissive comments on here.

You seem to be aware this could be very damaging for him, and that is why you are posting. It is very brave of you to admit this, but I would book some counselling and talk this through. Make extra effort with him, rather than pull back. Celebrate when he is uses a quieter voice. Build his confidence. HIs behaviour sounds like attention seeking to me, and I wonder if he is picking up on your preference, it may be subtle but it will be obvious.

The holidays are always tiring, but try to enjoy his energy, and find ways to work with it rather than resent who he is.

Why can't you ensure he has one to one? I think this would see an immediate improvement, as he needs time just with you and his father.

Good luck

Edited

This.
A long time ago I posted similar. Reverse DD/DS age order. A couple of years older.

First. I did get myself some therapy. And I needed it...my mum was not great (understatement). I had been the golden child. My sister the scapegoat. I was sooo horrified about repeating her fuck ups that my (then) preference for younger DS caused huge anxiety. And the anxiety made me crave control. And a 4yo was "easier" than a 7yo to "control"

Therapy helped.me unpick my childhood trauma and why it made me crave control/hypervigilance/anxiety. How this translated into negative thoughts. And translated to anxieties/controlling behaviour. And to take steps to change it.

Now. I do not have a preference (actually, slight lie, DS is about to head off to uni and is being a totally lazy-arsed teenager crossed with a hyper-focussed-list-making-uniproject-manager. DH and I are looking forward to Sep 17th!).

You are incredibly brave and insightful to realise what may be happening.

Take some you time to explore it.

And PP are right...it does change. As they age. As you age. PP are not being flippant about it deliberately..as they don't understand how you feel underneath.

BUT you are anxious about this. Which if you do not explore why, could mean you keep repeating your thoughts/behaviour and making the preference an ingrained one (either in your head or theirs). That would be bad.

ihaveafavourite · 28/08/2026 08:55

arrrrggggghhhhh!!!

(sorry but!)

I cannot DO any more for him, exercise wise. Honestly I can’t.

On Monday he went to a sports club (“all the reception boys go!”) They don’t but I’m trying to encourage friendships so brilliant 👍🏻 that’s 9-330 with running in the woods, games, sports, loads. He then played Race Tracks in the garden.

Tuesday - went to a national trust (they have a summer of play thing on so I wasn’t walking around a stately home with him.)

Wednesday - massive country park and he ran and he ran and he ran and he climbed and he jumped and he went nuts in the little soft play when there was a turn in the weather and then he charged around some bubbles (those giant ones, you know?) and tried to cuddle a duck and I had to tell him off as it looked like he was chasing ducks and I know ds well enough to know that he wasn’t being cruel but you know can’t really chase ducks, brits don’t like it!)

Yesterday - the heavens opened but I’d actually booked them for a craft activity in the morning (MN jury I am sorry this isn’t exercise but still good for the old fine motor.) He did quite a nice painting actually. And we had to walk through a (rainy!) park to get there. I took them to McDonald’s for lunch then home for the afternoon. This may be why I’m struggling …

Today is a trampoline park for two hours. Then grandad is coming to save my sanity. Thanks FIL!!!

So I DO try, I honestly do. They are both booked into a range of activities and I love them but my god I was ready to return him as faulty goods yesterday!

OP posts: