Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

The Split Barcelona

221 replies

oatmy · 29/12/2024 21:35

Anybody watching? I have questions!

  • Why are they so cool about Liv getting married, she can't be older than 20?
  • Surely her brother would have come back for the wedding?
  • When Rose said she was missing 'the girls' I thought she meant children, but it sounds like they haven't had any yet?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
gingercat02 · 31/12/2024 12:57

Definitely not as good as the original series' but still love the people.
Lots of moments to suspend belief (Liv's siblings and cousins not at the wedding in particular)
Lovely scenery and characters, v disappointed in Nicola's wardrobe, which is usually epic.

usernother · 31/12/2024 13:47

Spanish wife was very understanding about Spanish husbands bit on the side being at the house. She was a bit angry at him but I'd have thumped her. I'd also have appeared the next day with eyes so puffy from crying they'd look like piss holes in the snow.

Ralphiemia · 31/12/2024 14:55

fairytailcat · 30/12/2024 09:05

Why were the streets of Barcelona so empty

And the beach?

I’m sure the street scenes were filmed in Sitges. Such fond memories of holidaying there with my friends.

Sheetsinthewind · 31/12/2024 15:16

Ralphiemia · 31/12/2024 14:55

I’m sure the street scenes were filmed in Sitges. Such fond memories of holidaying there with my friends.

It looked like they only had permission/budget to film in one street though.
I watched it all but it was rubbish really - so many holes in the very thin plot. Would they all have welcomed Gael back like that in real life?
Gorgeous scenery though.

PeachyKeane · 31/12/2024 15:28

Nicola's wardrobe was so frumpy I was really disappointed 😞

tribpot · 31/12/2024 20:21

Just finished it and like most posters I think I enjoyed it for nostalgia and seeing the characters again but it seemed to reverse the two key characteristics of the main series - grittily realistic divorce in high net worth individuals and wildly unrealistic costumes. Now we get tragic costumes and wildly unrealistic divorce among high net worth individuals. So what the hell, Valentina thought 'I know, I'll fuck up my only son's wedding day because it handily falls one week before the 5 million euro clause in my pre-nup kicks in, despite having known about the mistress for months'? Did the cast have to bring their own clothes for the shoot??

Also .. it wasn't in Barcelona?! (The city at least, rather than the province). Under the circs they could have saved a packet on location costs and filmed it in Cornwall - put that money towards some fabulous dresses.

The bit where Nathan tells Hannah to 'go and find her person' really annoyed me. Hannah already has her people - her sisters.

Finally the thing that really confused me was I thought this two-parter was to act as a backdoor pilot for the new series, the one stuck in development hell. So I had expected to be introduced to at least one new character who would take the story forward to Manchester, but apart from Archie I can't see who it would be. Maybe Gael will be Mancunian next 😂

DoreenCorkhill · 31/12/2024 20:39

I loved the original series 1 & 2 but this was utter rubbish .
Nicola Walker /Hannah's navy pleated skirt dress was the highlight for me .
Utter daftness
Cliche after cliche really soft script and lazy writing .
All those dancing/family jokes/smiley fading light montages
Shame -I'll remember it as it was .

catkatcatkat · 31/12/2024 22:08

How is it possible to legally move a wedding from a church to a beach at no notice? Couldn’t do it in the UK, doubt it’s possible in Spain either.

SadOrWickedFairy · 31/12/2024 22:22

fairytailcat · 30/12/2024 09:05

Why were the streets of Barcelona so empty

And the beach?

That wasn't Barcelona.

The 'town bit' that they went to on the Hen Night was Sitges which is about 40km outside of Barcelona.

There were no scenes in Barcelona.

Evertheoptimist68 · 31/12/2024 22:28

Where to start?
don’t the in-laws live in Argentina? Well, Argentina or Spain it’s by the by really, why do they have an English lawyer ( Archie) and if he’s a big divorce lawyer why don’t the defoes know him well. And how can someone both dull and indecisive have every man in love with her. And why don’t any of the men in it have extended families of their own at family gatherings - Nathan, Ronnie anyone? And boy aren’t the sisters irritating

Inndiaanna · 31/12/2024 22:40

Well I quite enjoyed it.

Davros · 31/12/2024 22:48

Drivel. Thoroughly enjoyed it.

Liv is a drip in her drippy nightie.
Gael is revolting.
Toby Stevens looks dog rough, why would Hannah be so worried about him seeing her in the nuddy? Although I quite liked their beach talk.
Lesbian storyline shoehorned.
Beach wedding was nonsense.
Holes, holes, holes!

Soonenough · 01/01/2025 02:09

So disappointed on Hannah wardrobe . Previously had sharp simple but expensive style. The inside out shirt looked like Primark . And she kept appearing in frumpy too long floral dresses . Meanwhile the rest were in cheap looking sundresses . As if . And as for Liv scrappy looking wedding thing . Yuck . Don't even begin to talk about the scruffy hair. Such a let down .
Meanwhile Daddy Nate is being so disloyal to his wife and children . In MN land he would be a real sleazy guy leaving them home and proclaiming his live for Hannah. Also why wasn't the house sorted at the time of divorce. Surely she could afford to buy him out . And Gael is a big attention seeking drama queen . Valentina was the best character of them all.

WGACA · 01/01/2025 10:00

Normalrulesdontapply · 31/12/2024 11:19

A very easy watch for a cold rainy day. I thought it was like a strange ‘The Split’ version of Mama Mia 🤣

Agree!

WGACA · 01/01/2025 10:01

MabelMora · 31/12/2024 12:31

I don't know why Hannah was so worried about Archie seeing her in the buff when she'd shagged Christie senseless not that long ago and he was a God amongst men.

This!

Ariadneefron · 01/01/2025 11:27

It was dreadful.

In all honesty, I have had mixed feelings about the series at the best of times. The cast was great but the writing and direction was always soapy, there was never any real tension, the supporting characters were always under developed, everyone was given to making long therapy speak speeches, the love triangle was unlikely and everyone was so wealthy without risk or effort that my thoughts would stray to class war. It was basically just millionaire house porn.

Also a lot of the characters were real wet blankets. Did any of you ever give a shit about the other two sisters? Not just in this episode but ever? Or the children? Or Christy, beyond a vague will he won't he? Did any of you feel the gaping absence of his character in this episode? No, because he didn't actually have a character. Did anyone watching feel any emotions at all when the drippy sisters drippy husband had a terrible accident and then got swiftly replaced by a drippy vicar?

The children were so uninteresting in the previous series that I couldn't even remember how many children had implausibly failed to turn up to their sister's wedding. To be honest, it took me a while to recall that Rose was not Nicola Walkers eldest daughter, but her sister.

However it plodded along for three series in an undemanding fashion. I played 'Guess how much the kitchen cost' and the cast is of a calibre that even tosh like this is, to some extent, watchable, though it always felt like a missed opportunity and I found myself wondering why they never renewed Silk. To say this jumped the shark with this Christmas special would be to entirely overstate the level of action. It subsided like a soggy Creme Catalan into an unappetising sugary syrup.

The faults were innumerable, from the MIA siblings to the doe eyed ex who is strangely callous towards his wife and two little children in London. There was the implausible meet cute of two lawyers who absolutely must have already known each other professionally. Not only because the London legal world is a small pond but because Hannah would have known the identity of the London law firm who drew up her daughter's pre nup. A contract dealing with property of that size would hardly have been a last minute negotiation, so she would have spent months going back and forth. There was the arrival of the Mistress, then the weird handling of the mistress, the FIL's and then the MIL's and then all the guests the next day meekly accepting the mistress showing up at the son's wedding. And then staying for breakfast after making a scene and nobody says nuffin.

There was the groom who runs away from his fiancée, sits on a rock all night and is then welcomed back by his fiancée and her entire family in spite of the fact he's been a total dick. Not to mention the English lawyer who draws up a Spanish divorce with a vast property, a family business and a multi million pound fortune to dispose of, in a single morning in the middle of a cancelled wedding with a manhunt for a missing person going on.

I mean, what the hell was all that?

EggandStress · 01/01/2025 11:42

fairytailcat · 30/12/2024 09:03

Too many holes in the plot

Where was Cora?
Why didnt Tilly and Vinnie come bavk for the (most expensive) wedding ever? They can't be older than 18/16?

Why is Gael Spanish now? He was always Argentinian?

I also thought he was Argentinian, but assumed I'd misremembered.

suburburban · 01/01/2025 11:57

Yes I did too

LouisCatorze · 01/01/2025 11:57

I found it very disappointing although visually stunning. Couldn't work out why they called it The Split Barcelona when it should have been The Split Catalonia surely?

I too was willing for Christie to come back. Surely that was the whole 'will they won't they?' storyline central to the previous seasons? With that off the table, it somehow lost one of the main reasons to tune in to watch it?

MissMarplesNiece · 01/01/2025 11:57

@Ariadneefron From your comments it sounds so bad that I've just got to watch it. I'll sit down with a g&t, prepared to either cringe or laugh at it. Or, maybe I'll enjoy it. There were lots of faults with the series too (as you've pointed out) but I quite liked watching them.

suburburban · 01/01/2025 11:59

I liked the guy who died riding the bike, he was decent

Ariadneefron · 01/01/2025 12:13

@MissMarplesNiece

I watched the series and I didn't totally hate it, I carried on watching. But I thought it was always a bit pudding-yand second rate, like a lot of BBC dramas. It seemed like such a waste of talent.

kerstina · 01/01/2025 12:15

MissMarplesNiece · 01/01/2025 11:57

@Ariadneefron From your comments it sounds so bad that I've just got to watch it. I'll sit down with a g&t, prepared to either cringe or laugh at it. Or, maybe I'll enjoy it. There were lots of faults with the series too (as you've pointed out) but I quite liked watching them.

Be sure to let us know your thoughts on it !

PeachyKeane · 01/01/2025 12:20

Ariadneefron · 01/01/2025 11:27

It was dreadful.

In all honesty, I have had mixed feelings about the series at the best of times. The cast was great but the writing and direction was always soapy, there was never any real tension, the supporting characters were always under developed, everyone was given to making long therapy speak speeches, the love triangle was unlikely and everyone was so wealthy without risk or effort that my thoughts would stray to class war. It was basically just millionaire house porn.

Also a lot of the characters were real wet blankets. Did any of you ever give a shit about the other two sisters? Not just in this episode but ever? Or the children? Or Christy, beyond a vague will he won't he? Did any of you feel the gaping absence of his character in this episode? No, because he didn't actually have a character. Did anyone watching feel any emotions at all when the drippy sisters drippy husband had a terrible accident and then got swiftly replaced by a drippy vicar?

The children were so uninteresting in the previous series that I couldn't even remember how many children had implausibly failed to turn up to their sister's wedding. To be honest, it took me a while to recall that Rose was not Nicola Walkers eldest daughter, but her sister.

However it plodded along for three series in an undemanding fashion. I played 'Guess how much the kitchen cost' and the cast is of a calibre that even tosh like this is, to some extent, watchable, though it always felt like a missed opportunity and I found myself wondering why they never renewed Silk. To say this jumped the shark with this Christmas special would be to entirely overstate the level of action. It subsided like a soggy Creme Catalan into an unappetising sugary syrup.

The faults were innumerable, from the MIA siblings to the doe eyed ex who is strangely callous towards his wife and two little children in London. There was the implausible meet cute of two lawyers who absolutely must have already known each other professionally. Not only because the London legal world is a small pond but because Hannah would have known the identity of the London law firm who drew up her daughter's pre nup. A contract dealing with property of that size would hardly have been a last minute negotiation, so she would have spent months going back and forth. There was the arrival of the Mistress, then the weird handling of the mistress, the FIL's and then the MIL's and then all the guests the next day meekly accepting the mistress showing up at the son's wedding. And then staying for breakfast after making a scene and nobody says nuffin.

There was the groom who runs away from his fiancée, sits on a rock all night and is then welcomed back by his fiancée and her entire family in spite of the fact he's been a total dick. Not to mention the English lawyer who draws up a Spanish divorce with a vast property, a family business and a multi million pound fortune to dispose of, in a single morning in the middle of a cancelled wedding with a manhunt for a missing person going on.

I mean, what the hell was all that?

When you put it like that 😅😁....

I have to completely agree.

lolly792 · 01/01/2025 12:30

Ariadneefron · 01/01/2025 11:27

It was dreadful.

In all honesty, I have had mixed feelings about the series at the best of times. The cast was great but the writing and direction was always soapy, there was never any real tension, the supporting characters were always under developed, everyone was given to making long therapy speak speeches, the love triangle was unlikely and everyone was so wealthy without risk or effort that my thoughts would stray to class war. It was basically just millionaire house porn.

Also a lot of the characters were real wet blankets. Did any of you ever give a shit about the other two sisters? Not just in this episode but ever? Or the children? Or Christy, beyond a vague will he won't he? Did any of you feel the gaping absence of his character in this episode? No, because he didn't actually have a character. Did anyone watching feel any emotions at all when the drippy sisters drippy husband had a terrible accident and then got swiftly replaced by a drippy vicar?

The children were so uninteresting in the previous series that I couldn't even remember how many children had implausibly failed to turn up to their sister's wedding. To be honest, it took me a while to recall that Rose was not Nicola Walkers eldest daughter, but her sister.

However it plodded along for three series in an undemanding fashion. I played 'Guess how much the kitchen cost' and the cast is of a calibre that even tosh like this is, to some extent, watchable, though it always felt like a missed opportunity and I found myself wondering why they never renewed Silk. To say this jumped the shark with this Christmas special would be to entirely overstate the level of action. It subsided like a soggy Creme Catalan into an unappetising sugary syrup.

The faults were innumerable, from the MIA siblings to the doe eyed ex who is strangely callous towards his wife and two little children in London. There was the implausible meet cute of two lawyers who absolutely must have already known each other professionally. Not only because the London legal world is a small pond but because Hannah would have known the identity of the London law firm who drew up her daughter's pre nup. A contract dealing with property of that size would hardly have been a last minute negotiation, so she would have spent months going back and forth. There was the arrival of the Mistress, then the weird handling of the mistress, the FIL's and then the MIL's and then all the guests the next day meekly accepting the mistress showing up at the son's wedding. And then staying for breakfast after making a scene and nobody says nuffin.

There was the groom who runs away from his fiancée, sits on a rock all night and is then welcomed back by his fiancée and her entire family in spite of the fact he's been a total dick. Not to mention the English lawyer who draws up a Spanish divorce with a vast property, a family business and a multi million pound fortune to dispose of, in a single morning in the middle of a cancelled wedding with a manhunt for a missing person going on.

I mean, what the hell was all that?

...no sitting on the fence there! Grin

But yes, I broadly agree. The quality of writing has never matched the calibre of the cast and there were many missed opportunities in the series. A good concept, but I felt each series got weaker. And then this 'Barcelona' two partner plumbed new depths.