Mamma Mia: I Have a Dream — Anybody else watching?

[PolkadotsAndMoonbeams]

I'm not sure it'll reach the heights of the BBC ALW shows (I loved those!), but I'm going to give it a go.

Some Greek sunshine will also be nice now the evenings are getting darker!

Finally a better song. I think she's got the best voice

Desmonda can definitely sing!

The choreography was so much easier in that one.!

She definitely can - the only thing is she’s clearly not a natural dancer. I think it was a good pairing with Zachiel being the weaker singer and Desmonda being the weaker dancer

Desmonda’s voice was beautiful.

I thought that was a lovely performance from both Zak and Desmonda, even though Zak hasn’t the strongest voice. I think Zak could be at risk, which is a shame because I quite like him.

I agree that Desmonda can sing and act, just that dancing is not her forte.

Zackiel was OK.

I know we haven’t seen them yet but I reckon it might be Zach and Leah to go tonight

I think this song will be difficult for anyone

Least we can understand the words in this version

This is terrible.

Really not feeling this. Seems a bit flat to me, but can't put my finger on why 🤔

This is the weakest so far I think. The only thing that might save Marcellus is he does seem to be a bit of a natural mover

Another naff song, I don't think his voice is very strong

Wonder how the songs are picked, I'd rather they were doing ones like Abba's

Changed my mind. I think Marcella could be at risk. He was a bit one dimensional. Leah isn’t a Sophie but she was the better of the two.

Time for Leah to go I think

Leah was better than Marcellus but I think she’s the weakest of the women tonight. Is there anyone else still to come?

All the songs have been awful. Not doing them any favours at all.

Yes I think Marcellus is the weakest guy so far. Not sure about the girls, as Leah was OK.

The judges don't seem to want Esme to do well. Keep putting her down when talking about her.

Yes. Esme and (man-bun) Craig.

They really do seem to have favourites. It’s weird.

I only liked the third song, all the others are dull af and previous weeks they've generally been more naff than good

Why aren't they doing songs similar to ABBA, as that's the musical they're auditioning for? There's so many good musicals, how about songs from Cats, Phantom, lion king etc?

I can't remember the Joseph one, what songs did they used to do for that?

Hope Esme gets a fair critique tonight!

I would prefer musicals songs like others have suggested

I know SNF is a musical

The Joseph ones were more of a reasonable mix of songs for what they’d actually be doing IIRC. Still some pop, but not a million miles away from the score.

Stevie and Tobias’s song was from Chicago. Agree that they should all have songs from musicals.