Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

I’m 43 is this dress too short for me?

205 replies

NarniaBanarnia · 16/04/2020 21:35

www.warehouse.co.uk/gb/clothing/dresses/pintuck-puff-sleeve-mini-dress/037263.html?dwvar_037263_color=77&cgid=dresses

It’s just to wear about the house on warm days, maybe school run if we ever get back to school Smile on a hot day if I’m feeling brace enough.

I would wear it with trainers or flat Grecian sandals.

I’m size 10, good legs (well good thighs, my calves are skinny and shapeless)

I have no boobs or waist so this (shapeless) smock type of dress is usually the best style for me.

I would be buying from John Lewis not warehouse itself in case the upcoming administration scuppers orders! Poor warehouse staff Sad

But at 43: is this just too short?! I’m braver than I used to be at eg 33. I give far fewer fucks (just the occasional one) Grin

OP posts:
AnnUumellemahaye · 17/04/2020 11:15

Thank you orangeblossom Grin

VenusTiger · 17/04/2020 11:19

Don't think age should matter, but, I've got a dress like this (late 30s) and the wind likes to fill it up and send it over my arse regularly, so be mindful of that OP - nice knickers required!

RuffleCrow · 17/04/2020 11:26

If it looks like something you'd feel comfortable and happy in then buy it!

Ask yourself whether a man would ever ask whether an outfit was "too young for him" then stop being sexist/ ageist towards yourself.

Men tend to wear the same kind of clothes they've always worn or just what they feel happy in. Why should we be any different?

LaurieSchafferIsAllBitterNow · 17/04/2020 11:38

Always wear big safety pants and never wear that dress in a breeze

And only wear it if you KNOW you can get out of any car with your knees together.

YesThatIsMyRealName · 17/04/2020 11:41

@AnnUumellemahaye You're really bafflingly interested in other women's crotches. I'm imagining you with a tape measure out making sure other women's clothing choices meet with your approval.

There are loads of things I don't like - tattoos, cold shoulder tops, mum jeans, those chunky white trainers, loafers with little tassels on - but you know, if other people want to wear them, they are welcome to, it's none of my business and I certainly don't extrapolate anything about the wearer's personality based on their outfit choice.

Do you get this wound up about men wearing shorts or sleeveless tshirts or is it only women you go this bananas about?

YesThatIsMyRealName · 17/04/2020 11:42

@LaurieSchafferIsAllBitterNow Yes imagine if her knees weren't together, my God, how awful, the world would simply end.

Mysterian · 17/04/2020 11:42

The model in the pictures just can't be arsed. She looks really fed up with life.

Chickychickydodah · 17/04/2020 11:45

If you have the figure and confidence go for it, I would wear leggings with it personally, lovely dress though 👍🏻

ANoiseAnnoys · 17/04/2020 11:45

AnnUumellemahay

Is that you Barbara (Cartland)??

I LOVE the man with two brains btw!

NC29 · 17/04/2020 11:46

yes it is.
I have one, wear it, and it is too short for me too.
on the other hand: can i be bothered? :) Anybody who doesn't like how I look in it has the free will to turn their head.

NarniaBanarnia · 17/04/2020 11:49

Eeek, didn't mean to start a bunfight!! Mind you, it's a nice change from worrying about Covid... Grin

Lordy, no, I'm not an attention-seeker! As perhaps I should have made clear, this really would be a dress for sitting around working at home (I have no clients so never see people, creative job) or in the garden (or homeschooling grr) and knowing me I'd chicken out of wearing it on the school run or even popping to the corner shop anyway.

Beach, too, absolutely, if I ever see one again...

But my issue with dresses is a bit of a tricky one, which might be worth explaining.

I'm not remotely a tradiitonal feminine shape, I WISH TO GOD I looked nice/felt comfortable in a standard pretty floaty knee-length-ish patterned or flowery summer dress, but I so do not. I am athletic build, shoulders like a rugby player, flat chest but very wide back and ribs, no hips, no waist.

Usual 'pretty' frocks look utterly absurd on me imo and I feel very uncomfortable in them.

I can't do shirt dresses as they more often than not have tie-waist-belts which don't nip in a lovely waist but sort of sit on my non-waist and make me look bulkier than I am at a size 10. I can't do wrap dresses as they pull across my wide back while simultaneously gaping at my non-existent boobage. I can't do shift dresses as I have no 'shape' for them and again they make me look wider and larger than I am (I may only be a size 10 but a tall and athletic size 10 which makes me almost hefty in a way if that makes sense. Certainly quite a masculine build).

I avoid shoulder straps of any kind, especially spaghetti straps, because my shoudlers are big and broad and again I look like a rugby player. (Also aforementioned moles on shoulders/upper arms/chest that I am VERY self-conscious about, way more so than flashing even my entire pantage to the world) . Grin

Smock/swing dresses work therefore because they disguise my lack of curves (something I long for) and highlight my slimness (tight clothes also make me look hefty). Also I tend to be able to find them with sleeves which a lot of trad pretty sundresses don't have. Or if they DO have sleeves they're of the tea-dress variety (make me look like a rugby player) or they're shirt dresses with tricksy belts I can't pull off.

Smock dresses that are too LONG look, to me, and feel more importantly, like shrouds - just too covered-up and Amish-like (nothing wrong with that but you do get funny looks if everyone else is rocking a flippy littel sundress and you're in a knee-length, high-necked shroud)

I have a couple of lovely smock dresses that are admittedly a couple of inches longer than this one that I lived in last summer.

I had eating disorders throughout my 20s and never wore a dress as I was too self-conscious and miserable. By the time I hit my 30s I had worked out my shape and decided dresses were awful on me. Plus I couldn't afford laser treatment I need for legs (and I have awful skin that can't handle shaving or waxing) so I just lived in bloody horrible chino trousers all summer long, sweltering and sweating.

Had laser a couple of years back and it changed my life.

At 43 I care less, finally, about looking a certain way I was never able to, and have embraced my assets (legs) while still very much wanting to disguise my bad points (most of the rest of me!)

I'm slightly going off the dress (having ordered it) as I've clocked the puff sleeves and sometimes those are awful on me (sometimes not) - sorry everyone!!

Aaaanyway, this is a massively long-winded post!

Just to say the whole smock/too short thing has reasons behind it.

And I would have ZERO intention of going out and about in this dress to actually, y'know, see people and stuff.

Mind you when it hits 35 degrees plus as it did in London last July, I don't think anyone notices or cares a bit too much thigh any more, do they?!

OP posts:
AnnUumellemahaye · 17/04/2020 11:50

Anoise Finally! I've been waiting for someone to recognise me. Grin

(Ann, not Barbara)

moomoomummy · 17/04/2020 11:51

Thank you for kind leg comments! Don't let any comments hold you back from strutting you stuff in your lovely dress!

Staypositivepeople · 17/04/2020 11:52

No ..it’s aimed at teens and women in early twenties..

Embracelife · 17/04/2020 11:53

Just wear it!
Pull on some shorts or cropped leggings under heath to go out in public if you need to -if it s windy

AnnUumellemahaye · 17/04/2020 11:59

I certainly don't extrapolate anything about the wearer's personality based on their outfit choice.

Oh but you do....you totally do. It's human nature. We all subliminally (or sometimes blatantly) advertise who we are by how we dress. And we judge. We all silently judge and pigeonhole people.

*There are loads of things I don't like - but you know, if other people want to wear them, they are welcome to, it's none of my business.

I agree completely. Except where someone starts a thread asking for my opinion, then it becomes my business. They don't have to agree with me, or take my advice, but if they don't want to give fair consideration to my opinion then they shouldn't have asked for it!

ZaraW · 17/04/2020 11:59

What is the obsession with leggings. The dress is fine by itself leggings will just make it look dated.

AnnUumellemahaye · 17/04/2020 12:13

At 43 I care less, finally, about looking a certain way I was never able to, and have embraced my assets (legs) while still very much wanting to disguise my bad points (most of the rest of me!)
I totally understand and identify with all your body angst and the battle that is finding clothes I can feel confident in. It's so bloody hard finding things that don't make your bad bits look worse - I get it! Being eternally self conscious about aspects of your appearance is a curse.

I had to smile at your long winded post because although we are virtual opposites in body shape, it's the sort of thing I would write about myself, probably completely overthinking things in other people's eyes.

I get that the dress will suit your body type completely and I bet you'll look great in it, but I still think it could do with being a couple of inches longer. Anything above the knee is NOT going to look frumpy if you are tall and slim.

tontie · 17/04/2020 12:15

it’s aimed at teens and women in early twenties..

That's not Warehouse's demographic hence why the latest celeb to "curate" is mid 30s

beachbreeze · 17/04/2020 12:47

Don't believe in age affecting what I wear. I'm 40 this year and wear very short dresses whenever I feel like it. So yes, go for it.

StarlightLady · 17/04/2020 12:49

To think l got to my 40s without knowing that anyone over the years who got the slightest glimpse of my knickers needed counselling.

Don’t worry though, l’ve just ordered some asbestos ones! They will go nicely with my thick ankle length skirts.

YesThatIsMyRealName · 17/04/2020 12:55

"Oh but you do....you totally do. It's human nature. We all subliminally (or sometimes blatantly) advertise who we are by how we dress. And we judge. We all silently judge and pigeonhole people."

Subconsciously I may do, but I make sure that I treat people as far as I can as equals. Like a decent person does.

" agree completely. Except where someone starts a thread asking for my opinion, then it becomes my business. They don't have to agree with me, or take my advice, but if they don't want to give fair consideration to my opinion then they shouldn't have asked for it!"

You're the one who was going on about people being flashy and showy and showing their crotch.

Just because someone asks doesn't mean you have to be a wank about. You can just say "imo it's too short". not banging on about what people will think and how they will see her crotch and what kind of person she will come across as.

That is why everyone is having a go at you, not because you think it's too short but because you're coming across as a judgemental oaf.

AnnUumellemahaye · 17/04/2020 13:27

Just because someone asks doesn't mean you have to be a wank about. You can just say "imo it's too short". not banging on about what people will think and how they will see her crotch and what kind of person she will come across as.

Oh I see. I was under the impression it was okay to answer people who addressed me directly and to debate with those who challenged my opinions on here. That’s how I thought it worked. 🤦🏻‍♀️

I wasn’t aware I was supposed to slope off with my tail between my legs once more than one person had disagreed with me and tried to make me feel foolish.

Thanks for the advice.

givemeacall · 17/04/2020 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pictish · 17/04/2020 13:29

We may silently judge and pigeonhole...but we are also capable of consciously overriding our preconceptions and taking no heed of them for they are often, if not usually, wrong.
People never fail to surprise, dismay and delight me, despite what they’re wearing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread