Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

34, pregnant, always wanted a baby... but the father can't choose between me and his ex

114 replies

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 10:57

I'm 34 years old, 6 weeks pregnant, and feeling completely lost.

I've always wanted to be a mum. I don't have any children and had a termination 4 years ago, which was a very difficult and traumatic experience for me. This pregnancy wasn't planned, but it is very much wanted and until recently I was excited about becoming a mother.

I've known the father for around 4.5 years and we've been together for the last 18 months. He has a young son with his ex-partner and they separated before we got together.

Throughout our relationship I've struggled with what I felt were blurred boundaries between him and his ex. He has been regularly staying overnight at her house when visiting his son once a week (she lives 3 hours from him and because of his job it's difficult to have his son at his house outside of his very limited holidays) and he has often spoken about missing his family unit. Over the last few months I became increasingly suspicious that there was more going on than I was being told.

A few days ago he finally told me the truth.

He admitted that throughout our relationship he has been in love with both me and his ex. He also admitted that he has slept with both of us at different points over the last 18 months and that he hasn't been honest with me about the nature of their relationship.

She knew he was with me but basically said to him when he had a conversation with her the other day and told her I was pregnant that she thought it wouldn't last between us and he would always come back to her anyway.

What has completely broken me is that even after finally being honest, he still doesn't know what he wants.

He says he loves us both deeply. He says we're very different women and that he gets different things from each of us. He says he can picture a future with either of us and doesn't feel either choice is necessarily wrong. He's currently in therapy and says he's hoping to make a decision over the next week or so about what he wants his future to look like.

If he had sat down and told me he'd made a mistake, that he wanted to be with me, and that he wanted to build a family with me and our baby, I honestly think I'd be willing to try and work through what has happened.

But that's not where we are.

Instead, I'm 6 weeks pregnant and waiting for the father of my baby to decide whether he wants a future with me or with another woman.

Financially I would be okay. I know he would support the child, he has money and I have a good support network around me. My concerns aren't financial, they're emotional.

I also want to be fair and balanced. Despite everything that's happened, he is an incredible father to his son. One thing I've never doubted is how much he loves him or how committed he is as a parent. I genuinely believe he would be a wonderful father to our baby too.

That's part of what makes this so difficult. If I thought he was a bad person or would be a bad father, this decision would probably be easier. But I don't. The issue isn't whether he'd be a good dad, it's whether I can cope with the uncertainty, dishonesty and heartbreak that has surrounded our relationship.

I keep going round in circles. On one hand, I've always wanted a child and if I take him out of the equation, I absolutely want this baby. On the other hand, I can't help but wonder if I'm setting myself up for a lifetime of heartbreak

Part of me thinks I should focus on becoming a mother regardless of what happens with him.

Another part of me wonders whether it's fair to bring a child into a situation where the father is in love with two women and still can't decide what he wants. Or if he does choose to be with his ex and whether I can deal with that heartbreak while having his child.

I know nobody can make this decision for me, but I'd really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been in a similar situation or who can offer an outside perspective.

Please be kind. I'm heartbroken and trying to process a lot of information very quickly.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 22/06/2026 13:14

duplicate erased

user1492757084 · 22/06/2026 13:14

How many others is he seeing?
He is a cheat and a liar.

I would consider only your own capacity and plans.
Sever all contact with him and be free to choose an honest relationship or none. You will fine as a lone mother.

WaltzingWaters · 22/06/2026 13:15

Why on earth are you giving him the “option”. Have some self respect and take that choice away from him. He’s been and continues to be an absolute dickhead. Even if he does “pick” you, I really doubt you’d ever be able to trust him, so just have that power now to end things with him.

Whether or not you keep the baby and solo parent/co-parent should be the only decision here.

Missey85 · 22/06/2026 13:16

Lose the guy and keep the baby 😊 his ex can have the idiot you'll be ok as a single mum do you have family to help you if that's what your worried about?

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 22/06/2026 13:20

@Georgia3092

Did you post last week about this?

Instead, I'm 6 weeks pregnant and waiting for the father of my baby to decide whether he wants a future with me or with another woman.

Either way my advice is the same.

  • If you want a child and are happy to be a single mother (knowing what babies require i wouldn't raise a baby solo) crack on.
  • If you dont want to raise a child alone or think you couldnt raise the child alone I'd have a abortion.

"Hope" is not a strategy or a plan.

GotTheBluePeterBadge · 22/06/2026 13:23

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 11:30

His job isn't a typical 9-5 where he can simply decide to work somewhere closer. I'm not going to give specific details of is job but his career involves relocating depending on where opportunities are, and that's been the case for years.

His ex hasn't moved 3 hours away with their son. She still lives in the same hometown she's always lived in, and he's the one whose work has requires him to live elsewhere and move around. Obviously when they were together she lived with him and moved with him. Now she's staying put in her hometown.

I completely understand people having different views on whether they would make different career choices in that situation, but I don't think it's as simple as saying he should just get another job. That's not really how his profession works.

You're worth far more than waiting to be chosen.

Have the baby, make sure he meets his responsibilities, and find someone who chooses you wholeheartedly and would never put you through this sort of agony.

I wish you well, OP!

orangegato · 22/06/2026 13:24

Omfg how are you even contemplating being with him? He will never choose. If he picks you then still has cosy sleepovers with his ex what will you do?

Do you want a baby with that disgrace of a man for a father?

Stop doing the pick me dance. Let her have him.

Sashya · 22/06/2026 13:26

@Georgia3092

Let's put emotions aside and think. You are 34. You already had one abortion and it was not easy. You want to have a child. You are ok financially and can make it - and father will be contributing (regardless of relationship).

I think in your situation it'd be crazy to terminate. The impact on you will be even more devastating than the previous termination. AND it is very likely that you will miss your chance for having a child at all.

Try to not mix up the romantic fantasy of The One; that perfect partner to have a child with; that perfect family unit - and having an actual baby.
This is where you thinking of "it won't be fair to bring a child into this situation" comes from.
Your situation is not one where you are having a child with some sort of horrible abuser; or doing it to save a failing relationship - where one would appropriately question why would anybody decide to have a child.
Yours is a relationship where things became complicated - but it was not a known to you. And pregnancy already happened.

And, additionally - plenty of people start of in that "perfect family unit" to have a child with that perfect person they were sure about - and have a child with them - only to realise later in life that there are no guarantees, and relationships can break down at any time.

Have your child. They will be loved by you, and clearly the man in question will also be in their lives. There are many different family setups, and no one has a crystal ball to predict the future. The love you'll have for your child will enrich your life. And as to the guy - you may or may not end up with him. But you are young, and you will also have plenty of time to meet and fall in love again.
But if you miss your window for having a child - that you will not be able to change.

Congratulations on your pregnancy! Take care of your health and hopefully it'll all go well.

Onetimeusername1 · 22/06/2026 13:27

I really wouldn't assume he's a good dad based on the current setup, maybe if he's wasn't shagging the mother the three hour journey to see his kid would dry up. So quite possibly, if you aren't shagging him he won't bother to come see your joint kid.

You see it all the time, men put way more into their step-kids or second family than their first.

Lacksplease · 22/06/2026 13:28

Youve already posted.
He's not a good partner or a good father or not even a good person. He's selfish and manipulative.
I would be tempted to do a disappearing act and keep him off the birth certificate.
You clearly want this baby. If he does. He can go through the courts to get it once he finds you. (Tip, he probably won't cos he ain't such a good father, then you can get on with your life with your lovely baby).

sesquipedalian · 22/06/2026 13:28

OP, you will never be able to trust this man, no matter which of the two of you he “chooses”. Don’t give him the option - you’re worth so much more than the crumbs of another relationship. Tell him to sling his hook, then decide how you’re going to make the best life possible for you and your baby.

StarPyjamas · 22/06/2026 13:29

The OP's thread from 4 days ago has just disappeared.

DearDenimEagle · 22/06/2026 13:40

And , let’s just say he says he picks you…but he’s still going to be going to see his ex and son, isn’t he? And she wants him back. So you’ll never know what’s happening there..well you will, even if he denies it. You can’t trust him. So that’s not going to change, whatever he says.

You need to stop with waiting for him to decide. He won’t change.
You need to decide to be a person in your own right . Grow some self esteem.
Tell him to get lost.

19lottie82 · 22/06/2026 13:40

As others have pointed out…..

if he turns round and said he wants to be with you and your baby, would you be relaxed, happy and trusting, in him going off to visit his child (and the ex he cheated on you with) every other weekend?

Tillow4ever · 22/06/2026 13:40

Sashya · 22/06/2026 13:26

@Georgia3092

Let's put emotions aside and think. You are 34. You already had one abortion and it was not easy. You want to have a child. You are ok financially and can make it - and father will be contributing (regardless of relationship).

I think in your situation it'd be crazy to terminate. The impact on you will be even more devastating than the previous termination. AND it is very likely that you will miss your chance for having a child at all.

Try to not mix up the romantic fantasy of The One; that perfect partner to have a child with; that perfect family unit - and having an actual baby.
This is where you thinking of "it won't be fair to bring a child into this situation" comes from.
Your situation is not one where you are having a child with some sort of horrible abuser; or doing it to save a failing relationship - where one would appropriately question why would anybody decide to have a child.
Yours is a relationship where things became complicated - but it was not a known to you. And pregnancy already happened.

And, additionally - plenty of people start of in that "perfect family unit" to have a child with that perfect person they were sure about - and have a child with them - only to realise later in life that there are no guarantees, and relationships can break down at any time.

Have your child. They will be loved by you, and clearly the man in question will also be in their lives. There are many different family setups, and no one has a crystal ball to predict the future. The love you'll have for your child will enrich your life. And as to the guy - you may or may not end up with him. But you are young, and you will also have plenty of time to meet and fall in love again.
But if you miss your window for having a child - that you will not be able to change.

Congratulations on your pregnancy! Take care of your health and hopefully it'll all go well.

According to her post from early April, she’s had 2 previous abortions and was pregnant that day of posting.

I hope that it’s case of changing some details for anonymity…

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 22/06/2026 13:41

StarPyjamas · 22/06/2026 13:29

The OP's thread from 4 days ago has just disappeared.

She asked for it to be withdrawn.

StarPyjamas · 22/06/2026 13:45

He admitted that throughout our relationship he has been in love with both me and his ex. He also admitted that he has slept with both of us at different points over the last 18 months and that he hasn't been honest with me about the nature of their relationship.

There's something you need to remember about this OP.

During April you two had been trying for a baby for 6 months.

And all during that time, he knew how he felt about you both, yet was perfectly happy to continue TTC.

Is that really a 'fantastic' father?

Quitelikeit · 22/06/2026 13:47

He has cheated on you already - not his ex.

If he wanted you he would be there now - I think he’s trying to let you down gently and also he might think he can sway you into an abortion

Why did they break up in the first place?

Stepmum900 · 22/06/2026 13:52

This baby will be very much loved by you and financially supported so keep the baby but ditch your bloke.
you’ll always be paranoid he’ll go back to her and leave you in the lurch. Just the fact he says he loves her (as well as you) would be enough for me to drop him. I wouldn’t want to be in competition with another woman all my life. X

LoveItaly · 22/06/2026 13:52

Jk987 · 22/06/2026 11:43

You sound completely passive in all of this? You’re sat waiting for him to pick you or not? Why does he get a choice? Let’s say he chooses you, he’ll still sleep with won’t he? He’s not going to suddenly keep it in his trousers.

You need to take the decision out of his hands and soon.

Chances are if the OP stays with him he will add another woman into the mix at some point. Why wouldn’t he, if the two he’s currently with put up with it?

Pyjamatimenow · 22/06/2026 13:56

News flash- he isn’t in love with either of you. have the baby if you want it but shut down any possibility of a romantic relationship. You need clear boundaries now for the sake of the baby

Scout2016 · 22/06/2026 14:00

How fantastic is his job that it's worth only seeing his son once a week for? That's a choice he made OP, come on.

Even if he were the greatest father ever to live, he is a truly terrible partner and you can do better. He lies and cheats and messes you around.
Why on earth are you giving him the option to be with you? End it for him OP.
You can't trust him. You will still have his ex and son in your life, but this time you're left at home with baby while he scuttles off seeing his ex / son. Just don't entertain it.
Don't take any emotional blackmail either because this is all his fault. Don't fall for any "I'm in such a bad place" type crap, even if he is in therapy.
He has deceived you and lied to to over and over. You don't need his baggage and dishonesty.

fireandlightening · 22/06/2026 14:04

Don't do this to yourself. You can't possibly wait around for a man to decide in therapy if he is going to pick you! Especially this man who sounds like a self-indulgent twat.

DoodIeBug · 22/06/2026 14:10

Ive been there, begging pleading him to make up his mind. I WILL NEVER DO THAT AGAIN.

LTB. He will then decide

waterrat · 22/06/2026 14:32

Please take one thing from the ladies of mumsnet

He is not a good man in any way shape or form. He has lied...let himself have both of you and behaved selfishly and with total self interest. In life we make choices in order to be respectful and kind ..instead he has just kept sleeping with you both.

He is also not a good dad to treat his ex the mother of the child like this. And he is also treating you like absolute shit

Walk away and have the baby if you want but this man is a selfish user.

You will realise one day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread