Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

34, pregnant, always wanted a baby... but the father can't choose between me and his ex

114 replies

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 10:57

I'm 34 years old, 6 weeks pregnant, and feeling completely lost.

I've always wanted to be a mum. I don't have any children and had a termination 4 years ago, which was a very difficult and traumatic experience for me. This pregnancy wasn't planned, but it is very much wanted and until recently I was excited about becoming a mother.

I've known the father for around 4.5 years and we've been together for the last 18 months. He has a young son with his ex-partner and they separated before we got together.

Throughout our relationship I've struggled with what I felt were blurred boundaries between him and his ex. He has been regularly staying overnight at her house when visiting his son once a week (she lives 3 hours from him and because of his job it's difficult to have his son at his house outside of his very limited holidays) and he has often spoken about missing his family unit. Over the last few months I became increasingly suspicious that there was more going on than I was being told.

A few days ago he finally told me the truth.

He admitted that throughout our relationship he has been in love with both me and his ex. He also admitted that he has slept with both of us at different points over the last 18 months and that he hasn't been honest with me about the nature of their relationship.

She knew he was with me but basically said to him when he had a conversation with her the other day and told her I was pregnant that she thought it wouldn't last between us and he would always come back to her anyway.

What has completely broken me is that even after finally being honest, he still doesn't know what he wants.

He says he loves us both deeply. He says we're very different women and that he gets different things from each of us. He says he can picture a future with either of us and doesn't feel either choice is necessarily wrong. He's currently in therapy and says he's hoping to make a decision over the next week or so about what he wants his future to look like.

If he had sat down and told me he'd made a mistake, that he wanted to be with me, and that he wanted to build a family with me and our baby, I honestly think I'd be willing to try and work through what has happened.

But that's not where we are.

Instead, I'm 6 weeks pregnant and waiting for the father of my baby to decide whether he wants a future with me or with another woman.

Financially I would be okay. I know he would support the child, he has money and I have a good support network around me. My concerns aren't financial, they're emotional.

I also want to be fair and balanced. Despite everything that's happened, he is an incredible father to his son. One thing I've never doubted is how much he loves him or how committed he is as a parent. I genuinely believe he would be a wonderful father to our baby too.

That's part of what makes this so difficult. If I thought he was a bad person or would be a bad father, this decision would probably be easier. But I don't. The issue isn't whether he'd be a good dad, it's whether I can cope with the uncertainty, dishonesty and heartbreak that has surrounded our relationship.

I keep going round in circles. On one hand, I've always wanted a child and if I take him out of the equation, I absolutely want this baby. On the other hand, I can't help but wonder if I'm setting myself up for a lifetime of heartbreak

Part of me thinks I should focus on becoming a mother regardless of what happens with him.

Another part of me wonders whether it's fair to bring a child into a situation where the father is in love with two women and still can't decide what he wants. Or if he does choose to be with his ex and whether I can deal with that heartbreak while having his child.

I know nobody can make this decision for me, but I'd really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been in a similar situation or who can offer an outside perspective.

Please be kind. I'm heartbroken and trying to process a lot of information very quickly.

OP posts:
toottoot3 · 22/06/2026 12:35

Your very vulnerable and desperate for him to choose you, doesn't matter who he chooses he's still going to fuck around, he didn't tell you, you knew.
How is he going to chose which child to visit on Christmas? Holiday with, put to bed, school assembly?

SweatySpider321 · 22/06/2026 12:37

Why are you feeding into all this nonsense?! Pick for him, end the relationship and contacts CMS once the baby is born

Dweetfidilove · 22/06/2026 12:38

My darling, this man has told you he's in love with his ex, has slept with her (everyone surmised this on your previous thread), and not being with her leaves a big gaping hole in his heart.

Why oh why do you want to be 'chosen' by him?
So you can worry every time he goes to stay overnight with his son?
So you can worry every time he looks sad and forlorn?
So you can worry that you and your baby are always second best and just not enough?

Think of all the emotional energy you are wasting right now, when you should be celebrating the news of your much wanted pregnancy.

Think of all the energy you'll be wasting in early motherhood, worrying about him when you're tired and adjusting to newborn, and life is generally a struggle.

Think of all the energy you'll be diverting from raising your child, working overtime to 'keep' a man who has told you you're not enough.

I could probably carry this on...
I believe the first kindness you need, is the one you'll give yourself. Set the cheat free - for your amd your baby's stability and peace.

likimagee · 22/06/2026 12:39

Ucch he’s military isn’t he OP. Chances are it’s not just you and the ex. He’s not a good dad, he’s not a good partner. Walk away.

albalass · 22/06/2026 12:40

What a mess. A great dad doesn't create the situation that this man has created - two young children to two different women in quick succession, faithful to neither woman. That's the 'family' environment he has created for his children. That is not a great dad. He has not in any way put his son first and is now having another. There is so much more to being a parent than paying money and visiting occasionally. And it's tough. I think most couples will agree babies and young children can place a massive strain on relationships.If he's not sure if he wants to be with you without a baby then when times get tough, which they will, I can't see him sticking around. You can do so much better.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 22/06/2026 12:44

Be a single parent. Do it yourself. I wouldn't have an abortion in your situation.

outerspacepotato · 22/06/2026 12:46

He's lied to you your entire relationship and you chose to believe some pretty obvious lies. He's untrustworthy and unreliable and unfaithful.

If you want to have the baby, have it but understand he is a shitty partner and parent and he really wants to be somewhere else and with his ex. Prepare to be a single mother from birth on and file for maintenamce when the baby arrives.

Naurrr · 22/06/2026 12:46

Would he not parent your future child 50/50?

Summervibes83 · 22/06/2026 12:47

Regardless of how he is as a father, someone who lies to you for 18 months while cheating on you is not a good guy OP, good men don't do that. Even if he does choose you, you will never be able to trust him or be certain that you are what he wants. Don't do that to yourself.

TracyBeakerSoYeah · 22/06/2026 12:51

I remember you saying on your previous thread that you'd known him 4.5 yrs (I think that's right)
So he's not been a very good friend to you let alone a boyfriend.

It seems that you have been the rebound girlfriend all along & you do deserve better much better.
You need a man who is 100% loyal to you and it's not him.

If you feel that you can cope being a single parent tied to this idiot man for the next 18 years plus then have the baby.
If not then don't

Cannybeme · 22/06/2026 12:54

OP, this man has lied to you for the duration of your relationship. Why would you want a baby with this person?

You are waiting on his feelings or for him to make his mind up.. are your feelings not valid?

He can see a future with you and his ‘ex’. He loves you both.. blah blah blah.. are you and the ex both happy being someone’s 50%

He either wants a polyamorous relationship and hasn’t got the bollocks to say so or he’s a complete manchild who needs someone to make
his mind up for him.

OP - RUN!!!

Allisnotlost1 · 22/06/2026 12:55

This is a messy situation but there’s only one possible outcome for you and him. It’s done, he’s let you down and disrespected you and you have to move on from him for your own self-respect and mental health.

If you’re prepared to be a single mother and can maintain emotional boundaries with him as the father then continue the pregnancy. However the ex knows about you and will possibly be more wary if you are the ‘other mother’ rather than the other woman. It doesn’t sound ideal, but it’s doable if he will financially support you.

You’re young, you can meet someone else and have a baby, don’t think of this as your only chance.

StarPyjamas · 22/06/2026 13:00

This is a messy situation but there’s only one possible outcome for you and him.

Not true.

The other possible outcome is that the OP will continue to allow him to treat her like shit for many more years.

And keep starting threads about him.

Starlight7080 · 22/06/2026 13:00

No matter what he will always have one foot out of the door. He is not worth wasting time on.
Just plan to be a single parent and enjoy it. You will be a lot less stressed then you are now.
He obviously has no respect for you or love .

Backtoday · 22/06/2026 13:02

I wouldn’t be waiting around waiting to be picked OP, I can tell you that.
Where is your self-respect?
You will never be able to trust him anyway…he’s already shown himself to be a cheat and a liar.

Have the baby if you want to.
I’m sorry OP.
It’s a horrible situation to be in 💐

Tweedledeedledum · 22/06/2026 13:02

If you decide to keep your baby then you need to prioritise them and by extension yourself. If he's going to be so indecisive, or, more likely, determined to have two women fawning over him, make sure you're not one of them. You and your baby deserve so much more.

GreenOpalFruits · 22/06/2026 13:03

Haven't you posted this already?

hididdlyho · 22/06/2026 13:03

Can you be referred for counselling by the abortion clinic? Personally I wouldn't want to have a baby with someone who I know is so flaky as it seems unfair on the child, who will presumably have a father and a half brother in and out of their life. If you know he wouldn't want to be in the child's life, that could be different. However, watching your kid be disappointed when he doesn't show up to visit etc as he got a better offer or is busy playing happy families with the other mother and their son, I imagine would be heart breaking.

I would cut contact with this man, it's very bold of him to let you know he'll be hopefully making his decision decision this week. No doubt his ego will be loving having two woman fight over him, so I wouldn't count on him making a decision and sticking to it any time soon.

CaptainMyCaptain · 22/06/2026 13:03

OhBotherSaidPoo · 22/06/2026 11:02

Never ever wait around for someone to make a decision on whether they love you enough. If they even doubt it, then that's the only answer you need.
Be brave and take control.
Right now he's got two women fighting for him. Unless his dick is made of solid gold no man is worth that level of stress and angst.
Put yourself and your pregnancy first. Dump the man and let him go back to his broken relationship because you're no longer an option to him.

Exactly this. Enjoy your baby and live your own life

Error404FucksNotFound · 22/06/2026 13:05

I honestly wouldn't hang around waiting to see if he's going to pick me.

Have the baby. You want to be a mum. He can be involved or not, you cant make him step up and be a father but you sure as shit should not stand round begging him to be your partner.

Choose for him and tell him to sling his hook.

Because you know what? Even if you are the lucky lucky winner of this top prize - he'll still be banging second place on the side

BreatheAndFocus · 22/06/2026 13:06

Don’t wait for this cheating drip to make his decision! It sounds like he thinks he’s god’s gift to women and is deciding which woman he will grace with his presence 🙄

Dump him! Even if he chooses you, you have no idea whether he won’t go off with his ex again. Get rid of the conceited twat, keep the baby and live your own life free of this unnecessary drama.

I know it’s upsetting now. In the past I’ve cried so much over people - but, years on, I’ve realised they weren’t worth a single teardrop.

Jellybunny98 · 22/06/2026 13:09

My mum always told us that if a partner ever has to choose between you and another person, that should be your sign to remove yourself from the equation entirely. The right person doesn’t need to have an affair and therapy to decide to be with you.

Life doesn’t have to be this hard.

Ladybyrd · 22/06/2026 13:10

He wants to have his cake and eat it and you’re letting him.

Tillow4ever · 22/06/2026 13:10

What happened with the April pregnancy @Georgia3092?

Hayley1256 · 22/06/2026 13:12

I really don't understand how your considering being in a relationship with him? For the last 18 months he's lied and cheated. There could be other women for all you know.

If you want the baby then have the baby but I would be clear that you won't be in a relationship with him as you will never be able to trust him again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread