Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

34, pregnant, always wanted a baby... but the father can't choose between me and his ex

114 replies

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 10:57

I'm 34 years old, 6 weeks pregnant, and feeling completely lost.

I've always wanted to be a mum. I don't have any children and had a termination 4 years ago, which was a very difficult and traumatic experience for me. This pregnancy wasn't planned, but it is very much wanted and until recently I was excited about becoming a mother.

I've known the father for around 4.5 years and we've been together for the last 18 months. He has a young son with his ex-partner and they separated before we got together.

Throughout our relationship I've struggled with what I felt were blurred boundaries between him and his ex. He has been regularly staying overnight at her house when visiting his son once a week (she lives 3 hours from him and because of his job it's difficult to have his son at his house outside of his very limited holidays) and he has often spoken about missing his family unit. Over the last few months I became increasingly suspicious that there was more going on than I was being told.

A few days ago he finally told me the truth.

He admitted that throughout our relationship he has been in love with both me and his ex. He also admitted that he has slept with both of us at different points over the last 18 months and that he hasn't been honest with me about the nature of their relationship.

She knew he was with me but basically said to him when he had a conversation with her the other day and told her I was pregnant that she thought it wouldn't last between us and he would always come back to her anyway.

What has completely broken me is that even after finally being honest, he still doesn't know what he wants.

He says he loves us both deeply. He says we're very different women and that he gets different things from each of us. He says he can picture a future with either of us and doesn't feel either choice is necessarily wrong. He's currently in therapy and says he's hoping to make a decision over the next week or so about what he wants his future to look like.

If he had sat down and told me he'd made a mistake, that he wanted to be with me, and that he wanted to build a family with me and our baby, I honestly think I'd be willing to try and work through what has happened.

But that's not where we are.

Instead, I'm 6 weeks pregnant and waiting for the father of my baby to decide whether he wants a future with me or with another woman.

Financially I would be okay. I know he would support the child, he has money and I have a good support network around me. My concerns aren't financial, they're emotional.

I also want to be fair and balanced. Despite everything that's happened, he is an incredible father to his son. One thing I've never doubted is how much he loves him or how committed he is as a parent. I genuinely believe he would be a wonderful father to our baby too.

That's part of what makes this so difficult. If I thought he was a bad person or would be a bad father, this decision would probably be easier. But I don't. The issue isn't whether he'd be a good dad, it's whether I can cope with the uncertainty, dishonesty and heartbreak that has surrounded our relationship.

I keep going round in circles. On one hand, I've always wanted a child and if I take him out of the equation, I absolutely want this baby. On the other hand, I can't help but wonder if I'm setting myself up for a lifetime of heartbreak

Part of me thinks I should focus on becoming a mother regardless of what happens with him.

Another part of me wonders whether it's fair to bring a child into a situation where the father is in love with two women and still can't decide what he wants. Or if he does choose to be with his ex and whether I can deal with that heartbreak while having his child.

I know nobody can make this decision for me, but I'd really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been in a similar situation or who can offer an outside perspective.

Please be kind. I'm heartbroken and trying to process a lot of information very quickly.

OP posts:
GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 22/06/2026 11:40

Have the baby but don’t put the father on the birth certificate?

Ghht · 22/06/2026 11:42

So the man has cheated on both of you and yet he’s deciding “which one” he wants. You’re both wet flannels. You should both be ditching him after his behaviour. Man wants to have his cake and eat it, and you both bought the sob story.

Have the baby because it seems like you want to be a mum and another abortion may cause you further trauma. It seems like he would still support you financially.

Ditch the man, seriously.

AmberSpy · 22/06/2026 11:43

You will never be able to trust him. He will never be able to repair this (even if he tries, and I'm not convinced he will). I'm sorry OP but he will never be the partner you deserve or need.

Keep the baby if you want to but don't ever allow yourself to think that he will be a consistent father or that you need to stay with him for the baby's sake. Prepare to be a single parent (but go after him for maintenance).

AltitudeCheck · 22/06/2026 11:43

Being the one who is 'chosen' by this man isn't the prize you think it is! Who wants to be chosen by an unfaithful, weak willed, irresponsible man? Let his ex have him, you'll be the winner in the long run.

Jk987 · 22/06/2026 11:43

You sound completely passive in all of this? You’re sat waiting for him to pick you or not? Why does he get a choice? Let’s say he chooses you, he’ll still sleep with won’t he? He’s not going to suddenly keep it in his trousers.

You need to take the decision out of his hands and soon.

Stade197 · 22/06/2026 11:47

If I was in your situation I'd keep the baby but not the man

I wouldn't want to wait around for someone to pick me over someone else, I'd want him to want me and no one else.

If he wasn't attached to this other person for life it may not be as mad if he chose you, but he will be attached to her forever as they have a son so even if he picked you then every time he goes to visit/stay over you are going to torture yourself with thoughts of what is he up to, does he love her, are they sleeping together etc

DaisyChain505 · 22/06/2026 11:47

You’ve already posted about this and you were told by dozens of people that you’ve been stupid to be/stay in a relationship with someone who in a very short period of time has left his young baby, got with you and now knocked you up all whilst playing the two women at the same time.

His behaviour hasn’t come out of the blue and he has been this way your whole relationship. You need to work on your self esteem and self respect so it is never an option for someone to get away with treating you so poorly in future.

If you want this baby get on with it but end the relationship and be prepared to raise this baby alone. But for the sake of this baby do not continue this relationship, you have a child to put first now and this teenage drama filled relationship is toxic and unhealthy.

StarPyjamas · 22/06/2026 11:47

Were the 238 replies on the exact same thread you started 4 days ago no enough for you OP?

NotSure222 · 22/06/2026 11:47

You have two issues

  • your relationship with him
  • your baby

You say he is a good man but he lied to you for months and cheated on you and slept with you without your knowledge while sleeping with someone else. That's a big character flaw. Stay together and you will never know if he does it again - and he will need to see the mother of his child for the rest of that child's childhood at least so how are you going to feel about that on a regular basis. Even if he picks you, he has basically told you you are not enough for him - he needs another woman to balance out what he wants in a life partner. Believe him - he has told you to your face you are not enough for him. Find someone who loves and adores you. Why would you want to stay with someone who has told you you are not enough for him? You were happy together while he was seeing someone else ... take that off the table and he might not be as happy.

Babyputyourpantson · 22/06/2026 11:47

Why are you letting HIM make the decision? Have you heard of the phrase

"Don't make someone else a priority when all you are is an option?"

Send him back to the ex, he has clearly been having his cake and eating it, are you sure they were even split up? Tbh I would probably reach out to the ex and confirm what he's telling you both!

Ilovemyshed · 22/06/2026 11:52

OP, concentrate on you and your child. Let him support you financially and be a dad, but turn off the emotion and cut him loose as a partner, it is clear he is not.

You don’t need him or his flip flapping. Please don’t stay with him.

You will have a better, happier life finding your own path with your own strength.

best wishes.

Squidward2026 · 22/06/2026 11:59

He's not a good dad, he's a shit dad, because he's been cheating on the mother of his child, which is totally disrespectful, happy to risk the stability amd happiness of his sons home life for a shag. If he's ok with treating a woman like that, he's a misogynist too, so that means he'll raise his kid with those values. A shit dad.

He also could've been with his boy all this time, his son must miss him, but he's happy to live his own life, be far away from him, have a new relationship with you, while also coming and going to the family house as he pleases, having sex with his sons mother for fun. Thats vile and the opposite of a family man.

Forget him OP, he's vile, he doesn't love or respect either of you. But clearly he's a charmer who knows how to keep you hooked and you're totally at your most vulnerable time while pregnant. Hes using you for sex and enjoys the headgames, thats all.

If you want your baby have your baby, you'll be a great mum, but don't factor him in to the picture.

Lurkingandlearning · 22/06/2026 12:01

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 11:30

His job isn't a typical 9-5 where he can simply decide to work somewhere closer. I'm not going to give specific details of is job but his career involves relocating depending on where opportunities are, and that's been the case for years.

His ex hasn't moved 3 hours away with their son. She still lives in the same hometown she's always lived in, and he's the one whose work has requires him to live elsewhere and move around. Obviously when they were together she lived with him and moved with him. Now she's staying put in her hometown.

I completely understand people having different views on whether they would make different career choices in that situation, but I don't think it's as simple as saying he should just get another job. That's not really how his profession works.

He is going to be spread very thin when he has two children to be a great dad to, especially as they will live so far apart. And by the sounds of it, he could be relocated even further away

Channellingsophistication · 22/06/2026 12:07

You have to let him go. He doesn't love both of you deeply in fact he doesn't really love either of you. He's probably just enjoying being with you both and keeping his options open.

I think you should just make plans to go it alone with your baby.

isthatstillthesame · 22/06/2026 12:10

It seems as if you want to wait to be picked, know deep down that’s a shit option, but want that choice to be validated on here. It won’t be. Not a single person of the hundreds who have replied or will reply on either of your threads will advise that. And no, his job taking him to different places isn’t a good enough excuse. Does the mother of his child have that option? Whoever primarily looks after a child has to stay where the child is, where their school is etc. That enables the less committed parent to follow their career. He could change career if he really wanted to go 50/50. I’m not saying he should but his career is not the reasonable excuse you think it is. And when you are an exhausted single parent, watching him swan in and out of your child’s life, you will realise that.

HauntedRavioli · 22/06/2026 12:11

Even if he picks you, you will never be happy and secure with this man. If he cheats with you, he will cheat on you. How long do you suppose it will be before he has a third pregnant partner doing the pick me dance?

If your baby is a daughter, would you want her to take this kind of treatment from a man? If its a son, would you want him to treat women the way his dad does?

topcat2014 · 22/06/2026 12:15

Keep the baby dump the useless oaf

NeelyOHara · 22/06/2026 12:21

I bet she doesn’t even know about you, you’re the side piece.

noshade · 22/06/2026 12:23

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 11:30

His job isn't a typical 9-5 where he can simply decide to work somewhere closer. I'm not going to give specific details of is job but his career involves relocating depending on where opportunities are, and that's been the case for years.

His ex hasn't moved 3 hours away with their son. She still lives in the same hometown she's always lived in, and he's the one whose work has requires him to live elsewhere and move around. Obviously when they were together she lived with him and moved with him. Now she's staying put in her hometown.

I completely understand people having different views on whether they would make different career choices in that situation, but I don't think it's as simple as saying he should just get another job. That's not really how his profession works.

Realistically then he's going to move again, and have two children, both potentially hours away from him and each other.

I think you need to make plans for you and the baby, assuming he will be an absent father. I'm really sorry for what he's putting you through.

OutOfApricots · 22/06/2026 12:23

Seems to me that she never really was the ex. You have unknowingly ended up as the OW. Don't do the 'pick me' dance. Don't wait for him to choose.

Keep the baby and ditch him.

whippersnapper55 · 22/06/2026 12:24

Do you really want to wait around to see if he 'picks you'? He will always have contact with the ex because they have a child together and you will never be able to trust him. You would be setting yourself up for a lifetime of misery.

If I were you, I'd leave him to his ex and starting planning a life for you and your baby. You don't need him, you can raise your child on your own and have a happy life.

And btw, he's not an amazing father. An amazing father doesn't treat the mothers of his children the way he has. He's a liar and a cheat.

FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 22/06/2026 12:28

Absolutely do not wait and see if he picks you.

Even if he does, the other woman is always going to be there. You’re always going to worry about what’s going on between them. Is that really the life you want to live?

Take back some control of the situation.

Thundertoast · 22/06/2026 12:29

Georgia3092 · 22/06/2026 11:30

His job isn't a typical 9-5 where he can simply decide to work somewhere closer. I'm not going to give specific details of is job but his career involves relocating depending on where opportunities are, and that's been the case for years.

His ex hasn't moved 3 hours away with their son. She still lives in the same hometown she's always lived in, and he's the one whose work has requires him to live elsewhere and move around. Obviously when they were together she lived with him and moved with him. Now she's staying put in her hometown.

I completely understand people having different views on whether they would make different career choices in that situation, but I don't think it's as simple as saying he should just get another job. That's not really how his profession works.

He could move careers. He might not be able to do his exact current job in a stationary way, but the option to change careers is open. A 'good' father isnt one who misses out on most of his child's life but provides financially. A good father would be doing everything they could to not miss out on their child's life, and a good man wouldnt think it was fair to leave it all to his ex. I know that society has indoctrinated us to believe that a nice man who has a job that means he works away and doesnt see his children very much is a great dad, they are making a sacrifice for their family, but they arent. These men always have a choice and they choose to not actually spend time with their children.

oliviaAustin · 22/06/2026 12:30

So he’s going to leave you and your baby every weekend to go see his other child and continue to stay with his ex who he has admitted to sleeping with? Yeah that’s going to go well…

99bottlesofkombucha · 22/06/2026 12:34

Tell him to fuck off, and all communication should be about the baby, which you are going to make some big decisions on now you know what a cheating liar the baby’s dad is, and that you are going to block him for a week because you need the space. Him: why but what about me I love you TOO. You: the key point here is you’re a cheating fucking liar, and you’re not listening.
Block him and think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread