Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Dad disowned me over one comment- how do I fix it?

272 replies

erasemybrain · 10/08/2025 12:45

Hi, this is long.
I have previously had a brilliant relationship with my parents. I'm married and have 2 children. We have always been very close. My DH has no parents and they have treated him like a son. They have looked after our children - we have never paid childcare. We recently had a week off work to renovate a room in their house. We do a lot for each other. I speak to my mom every day and my dad every couple of days if we haven't seen them.
We usually holiday together and have done for years. Dad used to pay for the holiday and now we do (power shift?). We do all the work, cooking etc. We also do all the driving once we have arrived. We often do the same things on holiday - throw backs to when we were kids, but it's a very democratic and organic process deciding what we want to do and we don't have to do things all together.
Anyway- this year may half term we were on holiday- dad was celebrating a big birthday while we were there. Other family has come along to stay nearby. Everything was going well, we had had a nice day. It was his birthday the next day. We sorted dinner and my teen was being a bit rude/cheeky to me (as is often the case, testing boundaries!). He has been at the accommodation all day with my husband and the rest of us had been a couple of places (ie I hadn't been nagging him all day!) I told him he had been rude and he took that on the chin because he knew he had. My dad said "oh will you give it a rest" I said "if you don't like it go somewhere else" - there were numerous other places to be other than sat at the table with us. He had already finished his food.
Well this lot the touch paper and he got his car keys and drove off. He had left his phone behind and we all sort of carried on as normal. My mom did ask him not to go but he left anyway. He was gone a couple of hours and by the time he came back we were all in bed- small accommodation you could hear everything. He came in and seemed even more angry than when he left. He went into his bedroom and demanded that my mom pack his case. She was begging him to stay. My DS who had been cheeky was sobbing and begging him to stay. My mom said she had chest pain and he ignored her. He was packing his things and I slipped out of the chaos and sat in his car. I hoped that then I could talk to him and apologise (even though I didn't feel what I had said had warranted that reaction- we are normally people who say what we think!) He locked me in the car and I couldn't get out. I could hear my son sobbing and begging.
I have never seen him behave like this before he was so so angry. I saw my husband standing in his was asking him to stay and talk. My Dad said he didn't want to hit him but he would if he didn't move. Again this couldn't be more out of character. I was very very worried. Someone let me out of the car and I went in to try and get him to talk but he was fighting us to get out. All I could think of what if he crashes and dies my son will be affected forever.
The neighbours started shouting for us to keep the noise down and my dad started shouting for help. The look in his eyes was wild and I really felt like I didn't know him at all. My mom was still begging him to stay.
We let him leave. He drove 200 miles home.
There was an aftermath of trying to contact him and make sure he was ok. Mainly other family members. He would only really speak to my son. My other younger son was in bed and terrified of the whole thing.
I text him the next day but he was accusing me of assaulting him and was still clearly angry.
He hasn't spoken to me or my husband since. This shows no sign of improvement. He thinks we did a terrible thing trying to stop him from leaving. I did send him and email explaining how worried for him we were (this seems to make him angry that we were worried) that we only tried to stop him from leaving because we love him etc, etc. That resulted in him blocking me.
For clarity my husband stood in his way and held his hands up to his shoulders and stood his ground. I hugged him to stop him leaving. Arms round his waist.
Please help me fix this. I miss him so much. It feels like a dream that I'm going to wake up from. It was so out of character. I have thought some kind of medical issue but then why would he be carrying it on! I have told a few friends who know him (who have been on holiday with us and them) who can't believe it either!
Thank you so much for reading.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/08/2025 13:32

So he was

Fed up
Irritated by his GS being snapped at
Snappy
Got snapped at and told pretty much to fuck off if he didn't like it. So he did. And decided that actually, yes, he has had enough and would therefore do exactly what his daughter had instructed him to do.
Had his wife screaming and crying and claiming that she was having symptoms that could have been a heart attack
A teenager wailing and crying
HIs daughter blocking his escape route (the car)
His daughter wailing and crying
His daughter's husband grabbing him and blocking his escape route
His daughter smothering/grabbing at him whilst wailing and crying
Everybody around him that he sees almost all of the time everyday shouting and wailing and crying and grabbing at him because he's not allowed to get away from what's clearly become far too much for him

If you want to trigger anybody's fight response, you certainly went about it the right way as you all obstructed his actual first instinct, which was flight.

RattyMcBatty · 10/08/2025 13:32

I do think that you telling a grown man that if he doesn't like it, he can go somewhere else is a really incredibly rude. I'm not surprised he did just that - I know my dh and/or father would have done. To then physically restrain him (you say it was a hug, but was it really?) would have made it all very much worse.

Can you go round and profusely apologise, say you know you were out of order and are so, so sorry? I think that's all you can do.

ThejoyofNC · 10/08/2025 13:33

As usual Mumsnet have a diagnosis to excuse it all away. He acted a fool and is probably ashamed of himself so now he's acting like a petulant child to top it off.

Ally886 · 10/08/2025 13:35

JLou08 · 10/08/2025 13:21

This is so dramatic I wonder if it is true. He was dramatic wanting to leave over one comment. Your mum was dramatic begging him to stay and saying she had chest pain. You and your DH were very dramatic trying to stop him from leaving and causing such a commotion that your child was crying and neighbours were complaining. It's all utterly ridiculous. You should have just let him go.

Totally agree, either let him go and calm down or a swift punch to the chops. Don't need all the drama.

My FIL behaved like this once and we let him go and calm down, 14 years later and he still hasn't spoken to us 👌

ConsultMe · 10/08/2025 13:36

Honestly? You sound like you are seeing him as the wronged party when you are the wronged party. You’re pandering to his bad behaviour. He seems very controlling, and scary. I think you need to distance yourself from
him and await an apology. The fact you think
you need to make him feel better, is a bit odd tbh. If what you have said is completely true, I cannot see why you feel you have done something bad to him that warranted his reaction. It’s very confusing.

Untailored · 10/08/2025 13:37

No one comes out of this well. You were rude, he overreacted. Then everyone else overreacted even more. Everyone was being very dramatic.

Ally886 · 10/08/2025 13:41

RattyMcBatty · 10/08/2025 13:32

I do think that you telling a grown man that if he doesn't like it, he can go somewhere else is a really incredibly rude. I'm not surprised he did just that - I know my dh and/or father would have done. To then physically restrain him (you say it was a hug, but was it really?) would have made it all very much worse.

Can you go round and profusely apologise, say you know you were out of order and are so, so sorry? I think that's all you can do.

You sound like one of those families that never airs their grievances and one day it will boil over and someone will end up having a coronary.

If someone annoys you, tell them, be rude. That way they know their behavior is getting on your nerves. If OPs dad doesn't like the atmosphere, go sit elsewhere and he was told just that. I think I use that phrase 10 times plus a week. "If you don't like it, lump it"

ConsultMe · 10/08/2025 13:47

Ally886 · 10/08/2025 13:41

You sound like one of those families that never airs their grievances and one day it will boil over and someone will end up having a coronary.

If someone annoys you, tell them, be rude. That way they know their behavior is getting on your nerves. If OPs dad doesn't like the atmosphere, go sit elsewhere and he was told just that. I think I use that phrase 10 times plus a week. "If you don't like it, lump it"

I agree to a certain extent. I think family members should be able to navigate the situation posed by the OP without all the drama that ensued and a relationship deteriorating to the point of being disowned. Part of how you get your relationship to that stage, is being able to healthily communicate with each other - instead of avoiding any possible confrontational discussion.

ThatsNotMyTeen · 10/08/2025 13:51

Sounds horrible - but is it really out of character or does he have form for expecting to be the big man and no one standing up to him ?

godmum56 · 10/08/2025 13:53

good grief, it only needs the doof doofs.......
My adivice would be to stop spending holidays together.

WallaceinAnderland · 10/08/2025 13:55

I expect your mum's seen this multiple times. He's just been good at hiding it from you.

erasemybrain · 10/08/2025 13:56

I know I should have let him go. With hindsight I would have done that. He was just being so irrational I was genuinely scared for him. We were over 200 miles from home and it was late. (I also didn't want him to miss out on the rest of the holiday or his birthday when we had lots of special plans.)
Normally that comment wouldn't have upset him. Or if it did he would have just told me.
For what it's worth only one of us was blocking him at any one time. I wasn't shouting and screaming. I was apologising profusely and calmly and he could still have easily overpowered me. I asked him if there was anything I could do for him to stay etc. it took a lot to appear calm.
I have tried to keep things as normal as possible. Still visited my mom with the children. Still taken treats for them with me. He sits in another room. Doesn't say hello or goodbye. Mom says he's angry when she talks about me. He is fine with the kids though and sits and watches movies with them.
Do you still think it could be illness even though he still feels the same way? It's a couple of months later so UTI etc wouldn't still be an issue.
There is absolutely no way he would go to the doctors. The bit that makes him angry now is that we were worried about his state of mind.
He came home and was visited by my sibling on his birthday and he acted like nothing had happened. Even though he knew sibling knew.
He works for himself and had managed to continue working successfully. In times of trouble he has asked me to step in and help with the business but it's going ok I think.
We are going on holiday again in a couple weeks and they were supposed to be coming. Obviously that won't happen.

My mom on the day after was distraught. She doesn't know how to fix it either. She says when he falls out with her and gives her the silent treatment he will just suddenly act like nothing has happened. I've been hoping for that for so long! He had to come back to pick mom and the rest of his stuff up I so hoped he would do that then.

I don't know if that answers everything.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 10/08/2025 13:57

As I suspected. Your mum is used to this man baby.

SanctusInDistress · 10/08/2025 13:58

Does he have a UTI infection? Sounds something medical is going on. My father became increasingly angry over a couple of years and it turns out for years hes had a cancer thst is now terminal.

Beachtastic · 10/08/2025 13:59

She says when he falls out with her and gives her the silent treatment he will just suddenly act like nothing has happened.

Oh dear, I'm afraid she is stuck in an abusive relationship and you just witnessed what she may have coped with silently for years.

BallerinaRadio · 10/08/2025 14:02

Everything about this is so over the top it sounds like an episode of EastEnders

AMurderofMurderingCrows · 10/08/2025 14:02

WallaceinAnderland · 10/08/2025 13:57

As I suspected. Your mum is used to this man baby.

She says when he falls out with her and gives her the silent treatment he will just suddenly act like nothing has happened

Looks like you've just never been on the receiving end of your dad's behaviour. Have you ever witnessed him give your mum the silent treatment?

I will hold a grudge until my last breath so if he were my dad, he could fuck right off unless he apologised to me. Even then it would definitely make me see him in a different light and I'd be quizzing my mum to see if she needed help leaving him.

Screamingabdabz · 10/08/2025 14:03

I would do exactly what your dad did if someone spoke to me like that. You were rude and you upset him. Stop trying to weasel out of it with hand wringing apologies. Too late. At this point just acknowledge his anger and own what you did.

BrentfordForever · 10/08/2025 14:04

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/08/2025 13:32

So he was

Fed up
Irritated by his GS being snapped at
Snappy
Got snapped at and told pretty much to fuck off if he didn't like it. So he did. And decided that actually, yes, he has had enough and would therefore do exactly what his daughter had instructed him to do.
Had his wife screaming and crying and claiming that she was having symptoms that could have been a heart attack
A teenager wailing and crying
HIs daughter blocking his escape route (the car)
His daughter wailing and crying
His daughter's husband grabbing him and blocking his escape route
His daughter smothering/grabbing at him whilst wailing and crying
Everybody around him that he sees almost all of the time everyday shouting and wailing and crying and grabbing at him because he's not allowed to get away from what's clearly become far too much for him

If you want to trigger anybody's fight response, you certainly went about it the right way as you all obstructed his actual first instinct, which was flight.

This 1000%

in some cultures the way you spoke to him would be very insulting (I’d be insulted too)

rest of reactions too much even for me reading

if you want him to forget start by apologising

SpaceRaccoon · 10/08/2025 14:06

if you want him to forget start by apologising

Why? He snapped at her first, and then he overreacted first (I don't disagree that there was a mass overreaction though btw).

ParvuliThankYouDebbie · 10/08/2025 14:07

She says when he falls out with her and gives her the silent treatment he will just suddenly act like nothing has happened

Ohhhh, so it's not out of character for him them. It's just that he's not done it to you specifically before.

Viviennemary · 10/08/2025 14:09

You told him to get out. So he did. Too much time spent with everyone together isn't working. Take a step back. Sounds like he hasn't been enjoying these get together but put up with them. He now has had enough. That's my take.

LadeOde · 10/08/2025 14:11

This is too complex to judge without being a witness to it. I'll bet your bottom dollar that OP's dad & everyone present at this incident will have a very different version.

PigletSanders · 10/08/2025 14:12

He’s abusive and relishing you all pandering to him.

Tell him to fuck off and grow up. Call his bluff. Awful, awful man.

RightOnTheEdge · 10/08/2025 14:13

Well I got bad vibes about him when you said he came back and demanded your mum pack for him.
She says when he falls out with her and gives her the silent treatment he will just suddenly act like nothing has happened.
This just emphasises the fact that he's not a very nice man and your mum has probably had to put up with his shit for years.

I agree with @NeverDropYourMooncup though that you all sound like massive drama llamas! Everybody's reaction sounds so over the top and dramatic!

Honestly I'd leave him to sulk. I really couldn't be bothered with his tantrum.