Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Dad disowned me over one comment- how do I fix it?

272 replies

erasemybrain · 10/08/2025 12:45

Hi, this is long.
I have previously had a brilliant relationship with my parents. I'm married and have 2 children. We have always been very close. My DH has no parents and they have treated him like a son. They have looked after our children - we have never paid childcare. We recently had a week off work to renovate a room in their house. We do a lot for each other. I speak to my mom every day and my dad every couple of days if we haven't seen them.
We usually holiday together and have done for years. Dad used to pay for the holiday and now we do (power shift?). We do all the work, cooking etc. We also do all the driving once we have arrived. We often do the same things on holiday - throw backs to when we were kids, but it's a very democratic and organic process deciding what we want to do and we don't have to do things all together.
Anyway- this year may half term we were on holiday- dad was celebrating a big birthday while we were there. Other family has come along to stay nearby. Everything was going well, we had had a nice day. It was his birthday the next day. We sorted dinner and my teen was being a bit rude/cheeky to me (as is often the case, testing boundaries!). He has been at the accommodation all day with my husband and the rest of us had been a couple of places (ie I hadn't been nagging him all day!) I told him he had been rude and he took that on the chin because he knew he had. My dad said "oh will you give it a rest" I said "if you don't like it go somewhere else" - there were numerous other places to be other than sat at the table with us. He had already finished his food.
Well this lot the touch paper and he got his car keys and drove off. He had left his phone behind and we all sort of carried on as normal. My mom did ask him not to go but he left anyway. He was gone a couple of hours and by the time he came back we were all in bed- small accommodation you could hear everything. He came in and seemed even more angry than when he left. He went into his bedroom and demanded that my mom pack his case. She was begging him to stay. My DS who had been cheeky was sobbing and begging him to stay. My mom said she had chest pain and he ignored her. He was packing his things and I slipped out of the chaos and sat in his car. I hoped that then I could talk to him and apologise (even though I didn't feel what I had said had warranted that reaction- we are normally people who say what we think!) He locked me in the car and I couldn't get out. I could hear my son sobbing and begging.
I have never seen him behave like this before he was so so angry. I saw my husband standing in his was asking him to stay and talk. My Dad said he didn't want to hit him but he would if he didn't move. Again this couldn't be more out of character. I was very very worried. Someone let me out of the car and I went in to try and get him to talk but he was fighting us to get out. All I could think of what if he crashes and dies my son will be affected forever.
The neighbours started shouting for us to keep the noise down and my dad started shouting for help. The look in his eyes was wild and I really felt like I didn't know him at all. My mom was still begging him to stay.
We let him leave. He drove 200 miles home.
There was an aftermath of trying to contact him and make sure he was ok. Mainly other family members. He would only really speak to my son. My other younger son was in bed and terrified of the whole thing.
I text him the next day but he was accusing me of assaulting him and was still clearly angry.
He hasn't spoken to me or my husband since. This shows no sign of improvement. He thinks we did a terrible thing trying to stop him from leaving. I did send him and email explaining how worried for him we were (this seems to make him angry that we were worried) that we only tried to stop him from leaving because we love him etc, etc. That resulted in him blocking me.
For clarity my husband stood in his way and held his hands up to his shoulders and stood his ground. I hugged him to stop him leaving. Arms round his waist.
Please help me fix this. I miss him so much. It feels like a dream that I'm going to wake up from. It was so out of character. I have thought some kind of medical issue but then why would he be carrying it on! I have told a few friends who know him (who have been on holiday with us and them) who can't believe it either!
Thank you so much for reading.

OP posts:
soupyspoon · 10/08/2025 15:10

Account734 · 10/08/2025 14:58

If someone upset me and I tried to leave and then was physically restrained by a "hug" and a younger man blocking my path refusing to move until I threatened violence I would be absolutely furious. It's not ok to physically try to force someone to do what you want and that's what you and your husband were doing. You literally told your father to leave, he did and then you caused absolute chaos. Own it and apologise.

Exactly this.

He may well, or may not have other issues with his character at other times, but OP is posting about this one incident where he has got upset quite rightly about something someone said and then been trapped essentially from making his own decision about where he wants to go

I'd love to see this the other way around, my son upset me at dinner, told me I could go somewhere else if I didnt like it, I left for a while, came back to pack my bags and wanted my husband to support me to leave and during this, my son and his wife blocked my way, my son sat in my car and prevented me from leaving, physically 'hugged' me to restrain me

Yeah, reads well doesnt it.

Challenger2A7 · 10/08/2025 15:11

Sorry, but it sounds like dementia, either just starting or just beginning to show. I'm not a medical expert but I have a lot of sad experience of this in my own family. I would bet it's dementia.

SomethingInnocuousForNow · 10/08/2025 15:12

thisistoofunny · 10/08/2025 15:07

Nope. He could have quietly returned after he stormed off over nothing, packed a bag and left with no fuss at all, and he should certainly not have come back angrily making demands that his servant, oh sorry wife, pack his bag after everyone was in bed.

He did his level best to ensure maximum disruption and cause distress, and got precisely what he wanted.

Oh, don't get me wrong, he acted like an unpleasant man baby, but to physically restrain him / block him in several ways?

BrentfordForever · 10/08/2025 15:15

Shitmonger · 10/08/2025 14:53

Ah, you’re a man. So it’s acceptable for him to disrespect her but when she responds she’s crazy and hysterical.

His crazy hysterics are fine though and definitely not abusive at all. 😂

And it’s acceptable for her to physically restrain him, calling it a “hug”?

i am the man after this ^ comment?

Account734 · 10/08/2025 15:17

usedtobeaylis · 10/08/2025 15:09

She's already apologised. Leave her alone.

Get a grip. She is on MN asking for people's views so I'm giving mine. It's the point in case you weren't aware.

She says she apologised but she also says her father disowned her over one comment which is not true so I'm wondering what her apology was for, the restraining a person, or the comment. Two very different things.

SomethingInnocuousForNow · 10/08/2025 15:18

soupyspoon · 10/08/2025 15:10

Exactly this.

He may well, or may not have other issues with his character at other times, but OP is posting about this one incident where he has got upset quite rightly about something someone said and then been trapped essentially from making his own decision about where he wants to go

I'd love to see this the other way around, my son upset me at dinner, told me I could go somewhere else if I didnt like it, I left for a while, came back to pack my bags and wanted my husband to support me to leave and during this, my son and his wife blocked my way, my son sat in my car and prevented me from leaving, physically 'hugged' me to restrain me

Yeah, reads well doesnt it.

Exactly, you can't restrain people or restrict their liberty for being unpleasant.

Then to turn round and insinuate he's got dementia or mental illness or other instability is a bit gaslighty in my opinion. I mean, what is the evidence? Man overreacts and is visibly angry? There would be a hell of a lot of men with dementia or mental illness so severe it reduces capacity!

soupyspoon · 10/08/2025 15:19

According to most posters on this site, you can disown and become estranged from anyone at any time in any case, its your boundaries.

So thats what he has chosen.

Idontknowhatnametochoose · 10/08/2025 15:21

Op has already apologised. Continuous apologies will probably just make her dad feel more justified in his stance and more inclined to feed off the drama of the situation.

One genuine apology is enough. It's up to him now.

BrentfordForever · 10/08/2025 15:23

I’d work on that apology, given her Op I can imagine what that apology looked like .. 🤔

Missanimosity · 10/08/2025 15:24

JMSA · 10/08/2025 13:22

What a strange situation and response from him. I totally get that you must be devastated OP, but I think it’s important to back off for now and give it time and space.
In future, when things get back to normal - which fingers crossed they will - I would think twice before having your lives so enmeshed. It’s too much.
Cut the apron strings a bit and focus on your own family, whilst still maintaining a good relationship.
Best of luck.

I mean, a grown adult man wanted to leave but was stopped and restrained by a bunch of other adults. Why? What could have happened if he left? For me the overreaction is from your side, and lots of drama. You should have let him go, with what right you stop a grown adult man from leaving? It is also illegal.

OvernightBloats · 10/08/2025 15:24

Did he feel infantalized by the comment? As though you were telling him off like he was a child. This comment could have been the last straw for him,

Llamasarellovely · 10/08/2025 15:26

My utterly beloved father did the same to me a couple of weeks after starting statins for HBP 20+ years ago. Out of the blue over a fairly innocuous comment of mine, v similar. We didn't speak for about 4, 5 months. My mother was distraught. It was a random Google moment when she read something about someone online doing similar, yada yada.
Anyway, the med effect settled down. We started speaking. Neither ever apologised.
He is still a great father and grand father, it was just a blip in over half a century.
I hope it's something similar for you.

lemonraspberry · 10/08/2025 15:26

The issue is not with the comment to your DS. He was struggling beforehand hence the 'give it a rest' response. OP your response gave him the excuse to get out of there.

Maybe it was anxiety with his birthday, maybe he was tired and needed a break but it all got out of hand with people telling him what to do. By stopping him from leaving and making a scene it just escalated the situation. Endless apologies will not sort this out.

Back off and let him cool down and in a couple of weeks revisit. Let your mother try and sort it out in the meantime.

justanotherdrama · 10/08/2025 15:27

My friend had a similar incident at a family bbq a family member just lost it, someone phoned an ambulance as it was out of character and sadly it transpired there was underlying issues they weren’t aware of.

I’d getting in to contact with the GP asap to see if they can assist, it sounds so sad all round 😢 I hope you can work it out.

speakball · 10/08/2025 15:27

If it’s a new thing with him isn’t your mum concerned about dementia? If it isn’t a new thing then general aging makes it harder for people with personality issues and especially harder for those around them.

TiggyTomCat · 10/08/2025 15:28

The only time I've seen or heard of a really unexpected overreaction in an older parent like this it was the first signs of dementia. Obviously I really hope it's not that but I do feel it warrants further thought and possible investigation if he will allow that. All best wishes.

hazelowens · 10/08/2025 15:28

I would be thinking definitely a medical problem. My dad is one of the nicest sweetest men ever, would do anything for his family. In 2014 he got very unwell with blood clots in his lungs. He recovered but he wasn't the same. He would help you out but you could tell he wasn't happy about doing it, then my mum died and he was very indifferent about it. He adored my mum would have walked on hot coals for her and when she died he never cried, never really showed any emotion. We then discovered that my mum had clearly been hiding how bad it actually was so we started looking after him and one day I went up and I can't remember what happened but my dad was screaming at me and I genuinely thought he might hit me as he looked like he was losing control. My dad was against hitting any women as he had been brought up with his dad battering his mum every day. After that day we decided that he was very unwell and then we noticed he was forgetting small things. He was diagnosed with vascular dementia and is now in a good nursing home as none of us were coping well with him and it wasn't fair on him as he wanted us to be there all the time and my sister and I had young kids, jobs and houses to run. He is much happier now cause he is getting the company he wanted which is making his symptoms easier to manage.

So after that big waffle I think maybe you should see if you can get him to a doctor for a check up just incase. X

MaggieBsBoat · 10/08/2025 15:30

Strangely in the whole post I could see myself in your dad’s position and what you said sounded awful and saying “we are a family who say what we think” is normally just code for brutal and rude statements.

Of course he could’ve calmed down and it could’ve washed over him but in the end after so much h socialising I may have acted out in the same way.

IkeaJesusChrist · 10/08/2025 15:30

You told him to fuck off, he then attempted to and you and the rest of your family behaved like utter idiots.

Honestly what the fuck were you thinking?

SomethingInnocuousForNow · 10/08/2025 15:31

justanotherdrama · 10/08/2025 15:27

My friend had a similar incident at a family bbq a family member just lost it, someone phoned an ambulance as it was out of character and sadly it transpired there was underlying issues they weren’t aware of.

I’d getting in to contact with the GP asap to see if they can assist, it sounds so sad all round 😢 I hope you can work it out.

I mean, he might well have new onset health issues that are affecting his mood, cognition or impulse control. However, nothing like it has happened again, he's still working, he has form for silent sulking. Can you imagine ringing up an adult man's GP and saying 'this man overreacted to a comment telling him to leave, he tried to leave and looked really angry so we restrained him to the point that he shouted for the neighbours to help him. We'd like it on his medical notes that we think he is hysterical.'

SpinnyDinos456 · 10/08/2025 15:34

He's lost control of you and it pisses him off. You talk about him like some sort of god. Begging him to forgive you for months wtf? Still letting the kids over there? His good little girl told him off (rightly so, he was undermining your parenting), and he massively escalated it.

Frankly, I don't understand why you aren't more angry.

Movedafter4years · 10/08/2025 15:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fluffyholeysocks · 10/08/2025 15:35

IkeaJesusChrist · 10/08/2025 15:30

You told him to fuck off, he then attempted to and you and the rest of your family behaved like utter idiots.

Honestly what the fuck were you thinking?

Did she?? I missed that in the OP?

ChickenChow · 10/08/2025 15:36

OP I would 'let him' keep doing what he is doing.

Focus on fun times with your family and Mum.

It's in his hands, so try to put it to the back your mind.

IkeaJesusChrist · 10/08/2025 15:37

Fluffyholeysocks · 10/08/2025 15:35

Did she?? I missed that in the OP?

If you don't like it go somewhere else aka fuck off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread