I’ve read this whole thread now. I’m not sure why you posted OP, you seem to believe in your relationship and that’s all that matters. However you have asked if people find this age gap odd, and yes the majority will.
I don’t agree with many posters who speak about males being older being just as odd, as biologically and practically, since the dawn of time it’s not as odd at all. Men have always tended to settle down historically at a later age, being historically the provider, they have established themselves somewhat so they can provide for a family. Men are able to have children well into old age, whereas for women there is a cut off point from about mid 40s onwards. Sex drive is generally good for men at a much older age, where many women because of hormones no longer feel that drive. So if you have a 25 year old woman with a 40 year old man, they are both often at the same stage of their lives in terms of maturity, desire to have children, and then she will hit menopause and he will have a slightly lowered sex drive (maybe ED) when she’s 50 and he’s 65. It just biologically speaking makes a lot more sense. Someone was outraged by the comment about trade ins earlier, but it’s a fact many men because of their continued drive end up leaving marriages where their needs are not being fulfilled by a same age wife, and seek out younger women. Morally wrong to do so, but if we are speaking biologically, it’s because they are no longer at the same life stage, even being the same age. So in a lot of cases an older man and a younger woman makes a lot of sense, and men are naturally drawn to younger women, it’s a fact.
I am 40. To me a 23 year old is a child, the same age as some of my friends children. I physically and mentally could not engage on that level with a 23 year old. As well as just not even going there in my mind, I wouldn’t see a 23 year old sexually, or step in to their young life and turn it on its head. They have their whole lives ahead of them, and will be biologically drawn to women that are still 18, and much more likely to have a good future with an 18 year old than a 40 year old. By the time the 23 year old is 40, they will still be fancying and drawn to 25 year olds, but a mid 50s wife will be going through menopause and ageing to the point where it will be obvious. It may work out, but in most cases I would say it doesn’t.
If my son was 23 and was with a 36 year old single mother I would be really sad about it.