Some women could forgive, others couldn't. Does one crime in the past doom you to never being happy again? If it does, is it any wonder why men hide things like this?
He had no right to deny OP the chance to make that decision for herself and also it was something he did on multiple occasions according to his own account , but he has probably downplayed the frequency tbh.
He could always, you know, go be “happy” with a woman who is ok with it, instead of making another person unhappy just to get what he wants?
I’m sure there are many “cool girls” who would be okay with it. He knew OP may
not be one of them which is why he withheld that information. That is deceptive.
For some men, women who have had a threesome, an abortion, had sex at all... women who have more than a few sexual partners (most men and women lie for this reason!), had OF... these are dealbreakers. How honest have most women been about their past to their partners? What is the forgiveness buffer?
If a woman told a man about an abortion or an OF the day after the wedding I’d take a very dim view of that too. There’s a reason why any man or woman withholds that kind of potentially contentious information and chooses to disclose it only on the wedding night.
He clearly knew it was going to be a big deal for OP but wanted to disclose it - at a time that suited him with no regard for her feelings.