Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Why do men who “don’t want kids” end up having one with the next woman they meet

153 replies

lalalapancakes · 13/03/2024 05:20

Any ideas? Known of several who are adamant they never want children only to get into a relationship with someone else and have them… I’m sure sometimes unplanned pregnancies but often planned too.

OP posts:
MaxTalk · 13/03/2024 19:37

WhatDoesThisMeanForUs · 13/03/2024 19:20

Really? My experience is men want kids as much, if not more than, women.

No idea what sort of men you are meeting...!!

YetAnotherSpottyDress · 13/03/2024 19:56

MaxTalk · 13/03/2024 18:22

How many men really want kids? 5% if that?

I've met a lot of men who wanted kids; who have kids because they wanted them; who love them very much and who have great relationships with them.

I also know some who didn't and don't.

My son is 25 and he would love to get married and have children one day. He has since primary school!

oldtiles · 13/03/2024 22:15

Its easier for men to want children because in the end its not them who are ultimately responsible in 99% of cases. Its women who are beset with the pressure to have kids from all sides, its women's lives and bodies who are most effected while a man's life is often unchanged unless he chooses to actively engage more as a parent, many do not.

Pacificisolated · 13/03/2024 22:20

Lots of men do want children. My other half said he always wanted to be a dad and his actions supported this. We should not be telling young women that ALL men are reluctant to had kids. This just encourages them to stay with men who will be at best reluctant fathers, and at worse string them along until their fertility is over.

All the men I have known who left their long term partner and quickly had children with someone else re-partnered with a younger woman. From an outsider looking in, it seems like it was a compromise on their behalf to keep a younger and more attractive woman interested.

kkloo · 14/03/2024 01:59

MaxTalk · 13/03/2024 18:22

How many men really want kids? 5% if that?

Lots of liars out there then saying they want kids if they don't 🤔

Pinkbonbon · 14/03/2024 02:49

I think lots of men don't have any particular desire for kids. But they'll go with the flow if she does. I mean, it's not like it's their bodies that'll get ruined. Or even that they have to stick around if the going gets tough.

As someone who doesn't want them myself I'd like to think that those who say they don't are genuine. But I recon many men who don't want them are on a flimsy fence tbh.

WandaWonder · 14/03/2024 03:56

kkloo · 14/03/2024 01:59

Lots of liars out there then saying they want kids if they don't 🤔

If a survey was done with people who are actively TTC, trying IVF etc. and it was done 100% honestly on a scale of 1-100 of how invested they are in having children where do you think women would be compared to men?

Josette77 · 14/03/2024 05:14

32degrees · 13/03/2024 10:10

I think men want to spend their 20s and 30s having fun and being free. They enjoy their youth, unencumbered by children.

Then in their 40s and 50s they want to see what else life has to offer, they've slowed down. They think they might as well experience having children.

Basically what George Clooney did.

I saw a Seth Rogan quote recently where he says he and his wife and psyched to be childfree, lying in bed smoking weed and watching movies etc. when I read it I thought, I bet he'll have children with his next wife.

Seth and his wife are incredibly happy and will never have kids.

How deeply patronizing.

They are lovely people who have been happily in love for 20 years.

They are also known for their work with Alzheimer's advocacy in BC. They have very full meaningful lives.

And yes I can speak from experience. They are amazing people.

heartbroken22 · 14/03/2024 05:19

Because they don't want to lose another woman like they did the last, the grief makes them dwell and question their choices. It's not about not wanting a kid with the one before. It's the mental process of going through a break up and not feeling like that again.

Josette77 · 14/03/2024 05:22

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 13/03/2024 07:00

I agree with BumpityBumper

My DH was a bit like that. I told him that I wanted kids and it could be with him or someone else.
I also told him that since he was in his 30's, the next woman he found was likely to feel the same as me. So if we split up he would only be kicking the problem down the road and would end up in the same dilemma with someone else. He saw sense.

A friend of mine got her DH to agree to keep D's with the same speech

That seems so sad though.

You basically told him if he didn't have kids with you he'd end up alone because all women want kids?

How is that "seeing sense"?

That's just trying to manipulate someone.

Bansheed · 14/03/2024 05:39

My Dh's first wife had severe fertility issues. He said he was ambivalent, neither for or against, but she wanted to try, so they had a few failed IVF attempts. They divorced shortly after for many reasons, mostly that he wanted to relocate overseas and she didn't.

Fast forward 20 years, ( now in his 50s)he is a step dad to my three, since 2021. He says that living with the kids has been ultimately, one of the most surprising and fulfilling parts of his life. He is involved, knows/ makes them a priority and takes the relationships seriously. There have been bumps with the integration, of course, but there has always been an honest dialogue that is solution driven.

He left his last long term GF as she wanted kids and he thought that he didn't want to change his lifestyle. I know that she finds his new step dad persona hard. And I understand why. The options were that he lied to her about not wanting kids and/or didn't love her enough. It is a hard pill to swallow and I would feel the same as her.

Men self prioritise, if they don't want to do something, they won't do it for someone else. Only if they want to, for themselves.

Ggttl · 14/03/2024 06:10

@MaxTalk Of course men want kids. It is societies that have more equality for women that have the lower birth rates, not the other way round. I am struggling to think of any men I know who doesn’t/didn’t want kids.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/03/2024 06:25

mrandmrsrobinson · 13/03/2024 09:14

Or women trap men with "unwanted pregnancies"

You need to read this if men want to prevent pregnancy they need to take responsibility:

We have been brainwashed:

https://designmom.com/twitter-thread-abortion/

Twitter Thread on Abortion | Parenting | Design Mom

Popular lifestyle blogger, Design Mom, shares her raw thoughts on Abortion in her first Twitter Thread. Click here now to read it and share your thoughts too!

https://designmom.com/twitter-thread-abortion

Autienotnaughtie · 14/03/2024 06:28

The relationship isn't the one for them

They are not ready yet

They do not have the financial set up they want

Trulyme · 14/03/2024 07:07

MississippiAF · 13/03/2024 05:21

They just didn’t want to settle down/have kids with the previous person.

Exactly this!

Same reason as why some men say they don’t want to get married but then quickly marry the new woman.

They never saw a future with the previous partner and was only with her until they found someone better.

It must be so hurtful if you thought he genuinely didn’t want kids/to get married and so you chose not to either and then he goes off with someone else and does it straight away.

Starseeking · 14/03/2024 07:24

They just don't want DC with the partner that they said that to.

Clearly they did want DC if they had them with someone else.

Arewethebadguys · 14/03/2024 07:50

honeylulu · 13/03/2024 07:15

I agree with @Bumpitybumper
I've seen it happen a few times with good looking Jack the Lad types. They like having girlfriends but swear they'll never get married or have kids.

Then eventually they aren't so good looking and get a bit podgy but still want a young good looking partner, and find they can't attract or keep one without offering more. So it's a kind of compromise.

Omg all of this! Seen it happen multiple times

Rewis · 14/03/2024 07:56

Their mates start having kids and less friends to spend time and do the bachelor thing with. or they start thinkng that going to football with your son might be fun.

Biological clock. giving your family name and plant your seeds and all that crap.

Meeting then right person. Wanting to keep the right person

realising women around you have kids and just agree to it.

Assuming it doenst change their lives.

Pressure from people around you. The benefits for your career

Moonlitwalk · 14/03/2024 07:58

Then eventually they aren't so good looking and get a bit podgy but still want a young good looking partner, and find they can't attract or keep one without offering more. So it's a kind of compromise

Yep- I have seen this many times before too. It's easier to have all these deal breakers when you are young, hot and fit. Not quite so easy when you are ageing, have let yourself go a bit but still want to attract the kind of woman you got in your 20s when you were young hot and fit. Its funny how the deal breakers seem to fall away then 😆

Pinscher · 14/03/2024 08:17

Halloweenrainbow · 13/03/2024 06:45

They don't have the time pressure women have so they can afford to weigh up their options.

A counter question could be...how many women have babies with the wrong man for fear of not having time to meet anyone else?

They actually have the same time pressure if not worse, men on average become ill and die earlier. They also produce worse quality sperm after the age of 30 which leads to many birth defects. Older fathers is one of the reasons many people are born with issues these days. It just isn't.talked about, easier to blame eomen for everything.

gannett · 14/03/2024 08:31

Moonlitwalk · 14/03/2024 07:58

Then eventually they aren't so good looking and get a bit podgy but still want a young good looking partner, and find they can't attract or keep one without offering more. So it's a kind of compromise

Yep- I have seen this many times before too. It's easier to have all these deal breakers when you are young, hot and fit. Not quite so easy when you are ageing, have let yourself go a bit but still want to attract the kind of woman you got in your 20s when you were young hot and fit. Its funny how the deal breakers seem to fall away then 😆

I find this quite sad as a child-free woman - that anyone who doesn't want a child is pressured into having them.

Though having said that, all the child-free people I know, men as well as women, are not especially relationship-focused either - they're happy being solo and a partner is an optional extra. The kind of man who needs to be in a relationship will inevitably have to compromise, I suppose.

Last year I was out drinking with a few friends, including a child-free gay couple and a straight guy who was the only parent there. He asked one of the gay men whether they'd have had children if they could have done so as easily as a straight couple (yes, I thought this was an odd question too, he was a bit drunk and didn't seem in a great place) and seemed surprised when the answer was "absolutely not". It seemed like it had only just occurred to him that not having children might have been an option for him too.

It's quite strange that not having children - which basically involves doing nothing except making your contraception as iron-clad as possible, if you're hetero - is the life path that involves a conscious, active choice. Whereas a lot of people have children without even being aware that a different choice is possible. Maybe that sense of inevitability strikes men on the dating scene in their 30s but I find it sad.

Runnerduck34 · 14/03/2024 08:44

I find this interesting, I've noticed bit before too.
An uncle insisted he didn't want DC him and his first wife divorced over it.
He remarried and had his first DC in his late 40s.
He is a good Dad.
Feel sorry for his first wife who desperately wanted DC and never had them- was in her early forties when they divorced.
Uncle told my Dad " he wasn't ready" until his late 40s.

HeraSyndulla · 14/03/2024 08:58

Bumpitybumper · 13/03/2024 06:43

I actually know a few men like this who genuinely never did want children and they told all their partners this who seemingly accepted it. They then got into a relationship with a woman who this is a non-negotiable for and who they are desperate not to lose so they make the compromise for them. I don't think their desire for children actually changed.

Some appear decent fathers and others still seem reluctant even when the child is here. I think it's a big gamble for a woman to have a child with a man that has no Intrinsic desire for a child.

Agree with this totally. I worked with a guy who reluctantly agreed to have a child and he regretted it, almost from day one.

Moonlitwalk · 14/03/2024 09:14

I find this quite sad as a child-free woman - that anyone who doesn't want a child is pressured into having them

But it's all about choices isnt it?- if you meet someone you fancy who wants kids and you don't want kids then don't date them- not really hard. Sure, it might take longer to find someone compatible because as you get older your pool of dating becomes smaller but if you really don't want kids then that should be your dealbreaker. I wouldnt call it "pressure" at all- I met many guys when I was younger that I really liked but their visions for the future did not align with mine so I didnt date them because I could forsee trouble ahead down the line. Even though I liked them, we werent compatible. Thats really not pressure if you know upfront that someone wants a life that you don't want for yourself. I think pressure is not the right word here as that implies you cant do anything about it or are some kind of victim when thats really not true at all.

gannett · 14/03/2024 09:23

Moonlitwalk · 14/03/2024 09:14

I find this quite sad as a child-free woman - that anyone who doesn't want a child is pressured into having them

But it's all about choices isnt it?- if you meet someone you fancy who wants kids and you don't want kids then don't date them- not really hard. Sure, it might take longer to find someone compatible because as you get older your pool of dating becomes smaller but if you really don't want kids then that should be your dealbreaker. I wouldnt call it "pressure" at all- I met many guys when I was younger that I really liked but their visions for the future did not align with mine so I didnt date them because I could forsee trouble ahead down the line. Even though I liked them, we werent compatible. Thats really not pressure if you know upfront that someone wants a life that you don't want for yourself. I think pressure is not the right word here as that implies you cant do anything about it or are some kind of victim when thats really not true at all.

Oh yeah I do agree with this - I meant more that it's sad that some people give ground on their dealbreakers so easily, and don't wait to find someone they're truly compatible with, and let themselves be pressured.

Swipe left for the next trending thread