Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Teenage daughter going away with her boyfriend. Would you be OK with it?

207 replies

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 07:14

My daughter has been seeing her boyfriend for a year. They are both 16.

He has asked her to go away overnight with him in the summer holidays. They will both be 17, will have been together for 18 months by then and will be going alone.

I don't have a problem with it. She's reluctant to tell her dad because of the way he has overreacted to, well, pretty much everything! I've said she can't go without telling him in advance, which she has agreed to do, but I know he will be bouncing off the walls about it.

Would you be OK with this?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 28/02/2023 12:49

I wouldn't tell him.

Either they're already having sex, in which case presumably you haven't told him of you know or you're ignoring knowing, or they're going away to have sex. I don't think a 17yo who's with someone she loves and you trust, who's the same age, who's somewhere you know, should have to tell him.

I'd actually be worried that it would make it harder to tell you if she needs you to come and get her /help leaving etc because she'll have to basically tell him he's right and she wasn't ready. If it's just you, and she trusts you not to judge, she's more likely to be honest

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 13:02

OK. I've read all the replies. Thank you - I knew I could count on you all to be the voices of reason!

They are both very sensible. I trust them together to look after each other. They've had no arguments are very kind and loving towards each other so I have no concerns about him, her or the relationship.

As far as sex goes, they haven't. I know that and I know the reasons for it. They're fine and it's nothing to worry about but also their business. That might change by the summer - who knows. But, by then, they'll have been together for 18 months and will be 17 anyway.

I'll mention YHA to them. In case they can't book somewhere as 2 under 18s.

Until now, she's rarely asked to go and do anything. I've said no to 3 things and she's admitted since that she wasn't comfortable about them anyway so wanted ro gauge my opinion. None were to do with her boyfriend..

I don't 'encourage' sex. She has asked if he can stop the night. I've said no because we don't have a spare room. His mum has said yes because they do. Of course, I'm not stupid but at least the respect is there. She hasn't stopped over though.

As far as her dad goes, you're right. His relationship with her is his to manage. We had a similar issue when my eldest got to this age and he wanted to control what he did too. He says it's because he loves and cares about them. He does... but he also seeks to demonstrate this through control.

I spoke to her before she went to school this morning. I've already told her she doesn't need my permission as such but courtsey dictates that we all tell each other where we are going to he and what we are doing and when we are coming home.

I went away for a couple of nights last week and left her home alone. Her brother knew and he boyfriend's parents knew - in case she needed an adult (I was only an hour away anyway). So she is given freedom, responsibility and independence. Her dad would go ballistic if he knew she'd been home alone. So we didn't tell him.

She and her boyfriend have taken the train on day trips and he's been angry about that too - what if something happened, what if they needed picking up, what if, what if, what if...

They want to go to London. He is worried about knife crime, gun crime, bombs, rape, murder, her going missing, her running out of money, them losing each other. The list goes on! But any of those things could happen in our he town/city too. And him knowing where she is won't prevent them from happening. I refuse to keep her locked up. He wants to protect her and sees my attitude as reckless and uncaring. He would hold me entirely responsible if anything happened.

I suppose lovkdown has muddied the waters somewhat. She didn't go anywhere really between being 13 and 15 so there hasn't been a gradual exposure to things and he keeps talking about her not having had the chance to mature or experience things in a normal timeline. But I am confident she can look after herself.

My boyfriend has already said that we'll be on standby when they go and, if necessary, wil drive down ourselves to help them out.

He is her dad. She is under 18 and he does have PR. But he isn't her keeper or her captor and he doesn't understand that if she doesn't get to experience things when she is still living at home, she won't have the experience to enable her to make decisions when she is older.

She has done things that he doesn't know about but it does make me quite anxious in case he finds out. So, yes, I have considered that, but its also right that he doesn't have that control over me now either. I ignore the streams of messages he sends me. I don't engage or even respond once they start entering the realms of nonsense.

So, assuming they can find somewhere to stay, she will he going and she won't he telling him. I will be knowing where she is going and she'll be in contact with me.

Thanks for all the responses and advice.

OP posts:
Catonahottin · 28/02/2023 13:10

Your ex sounds like a nutter.

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 13:11

He tried similar with me when we were younger. He tried forbidding me from going into the city on my own despite the fact I'd lived away from home for 7 years and had a child by that point! I ignored him obviously. Amongst other rhings. But I knew nothing of controlling/abusive relationships or red flags when I was younger soni just rolled my eyes and got on with it.

He's just a bit of a dick.

My daughter and her boyfriend are great - just lovely kids As far as teenage relationships and boys go, she's already told me her bar is set very high now. And I can see that.

Her dad should be bursting with pride at how bloody amazing she is.

OP posts:
FrenchandSaunders · 28/02/2023 13:21

Just wondering if this age group seem so much younger and more reliant on parent's permission/involvement due to having to stay in education for longer.

I'm mid 50s, so by 17/18 I had been working for nearly two years. Obv some went to uni, but not many. Not sure it's a good thing to be honest.

GoodChat · 28/02/2023 13:25

FrenchandSaunders · 28/02/2023 13:21

Just wondering if this age group seem so much younger and more reliant on parent's permission/involvement due to having to stay in education for longer.

I'm mid 50s, so by 17/18 I had been working for nearly two years. Obv some went to uni, but not many. Not sure it's a good thing to be honest.

I think OP made a good point with covid. They didn't have the freedom in the years where we would have to enable us to mature.

FrenchandSaunders · 28/02/2023 13:25

Just read your update, your ex sounds unhinged, I'd be telling him as little as possible. Keep your distance.

Riapia · 28/02/2023 13:47

Totally fine at 17 in a stable relationship.
How stable is a relationship between two seventeen year olds.

Doesn’t need to be stable it’s just sex. She’s no longer daddy’s little girl. Remind him of this.
😁😁

GoodChat · 28/02/2023 13:50

Riapia · 28/02/2023 13:47

Totally fine at 17 in a stable relationship.
How stable is a relationship between two seventeen year olds.

Doesn’t need to be stable it’s just sex. She’s no longer daddy’s little girl. Remind him of this.
😁😁

They haven't had sex.

Hartlebury · 28/02/2023 14:02

I wouldn't be telling him, it's not really got anything to do with him, she doesn't need his permission and you know where they are.

He's reaping the benefits of his shitty misogynistic attitude 🤷🏼‍♀️

Englishash · 28/02/2023 14:08

You should tell him. Tell. Not ask.

cestlavielife · 28/02/2023 14:10

She is 16 not 6
She is gillick competent
She can choose to see her dad or not
Tell him her life or not
Most child arrangement orders for contact end at 16

No reason to tell him anything

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2023 14:16

Riapia · 28/02/2023 13:47

Totally fine at 17 in a stable relationship.
How stable is a relationship between two seventeen year olds.

Doesn’t need to be stable it’s just sex. She’s no longer daddy’s little girl. Remind him of this.
😁😁

My dd is 17, and I would say that her relationship is pretty stable tbh. They have been together for about a year, had a solid friendship for years before that. Never any arguments or drama. They're very comfortable in each other's company, they communicate really openly and honestly with each other, are both comfortable with the other having time to do their own thing.

Of course, they know that they're very young and that they probably won't be together forever, but they make each other happy right now and they'll stay together for as long as that continues to be case. They're both mature enough to realise that going off to uni in separate directions will inevitably put a lot pressure on their relationship. They know that they may grow apart, meet other people or end up wanting different things. But that could happen in any relationship, I guess.

I guess it all depends on what you mean by "stable", doesn't it?

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 16:19

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2023 14:16

My dd is 17, and I would say that her relationship is pretty stable tbh. They have been together for about a year, had a solid friendship for years before that. Never any arguments or drama. They're very comfortable in each other's company, they communicate really openly and honestly with each other, are both comfortable with the other having time to do their own thing.

Of course, they know that they're very young and that they probably won't be together forever, but they make each other happy right now and they'll stay together for as long as that continues to be case. They're both mature enough to realise that going off to uni in separate directions will inevitably put a lot pressure on their relationship. They know that they may grow apart, meet other people or end up wanting different things. But that could happen in any relationship, I guess.

I guess it all depends on what you mean by "stable", doesn't it?

This sounds exactly like my daughter and her boyfriend.

I couldn't have explained it better myself.

It's not 'just sex' 🙄 She and I speak quite openly. Neither of them are ready yet for different reasons (both of which i understand) but it suits them both.

However long it lasts (afterall university is on the horizon for both of them), it'll have been a lovely and positive experience for both of them.

It's a far better relationship than I ever had with anyone at her age and for a fair while after tbh 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 28/02/2023 16:33

Riapia · 28/02/2023 13:47

Totally fine at 17 in a stable relationship.
How stable is a relationship between two seventeen year olds.

Doesn’t need to be stable it’s just sex. She’s no longer daddy’s little girl. Remind him of this.
😁😁

I got married at 17 but she was older. I think it is only now that the age thing is beginning to cause a problem
Or it could be that Dh just acts like a very old man whilst I still feel very young

SleepingStandingUp · 28/02/2023 16:42

FrenchandSaunders · 28/02/2023 13:21

Just wondering if this age group seem so much younger and more reliant on parent's permission/involvement due to having to stay in education for longer.

I'm mid 50s, so by 17/18 I had been working for nearly two years. Obv some went to uni, but not many. Not sure it's a good thing to be honest.

In 41, I stayed in school til 18 as did all my friends. There's no way I'd have just disappeared off at 17 for a weekend without my Dad's permission. And I had a curfew, as did my friends. Perhaps that did make me pathetic but I don't think boundaries lasting a few more years than you had affected my ability to live as a adult 🙄

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2023 16:45

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 16:19

This sounds exactly like my daughter and her boyfriend.

I couldn't have explained it better myself.

It's not 'just sex' 🙄 She and I speak quite openly. Neither of them are ready yet for different reasons (both of which i understand) but it suits them both.

However long it lasts (afterall university is on the horizon for both of them), it'll have been a lovely and positive experience for both of them.

It's a far better relationship than I ever had with anyone at her age and for a fair while after tbh 🤷🏻‍♀️

Yep! Far better than any relationships that I had at that age either!

I actually feel very happy for dd that her first proper boyfriend has effectively set the bar so high for her. I think it will go a very long way towards ensuring that she won't tolerate any substandard relationships in the future, because she has a very clear idea of what "good" looks like. I didn't have that when I was younger, and I think it caused me to put up with a lot more than I should have done.

Her bf's whole extended family have been absolutely lovely as well - so incredibly kind and welcoming. I think she likes his mum almost as much as she likes him!Wink

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 17:42

SleepingStandingUp · 28/02/2023 16:42

In 41, I stayed in school til 18 as did all my friends. There's no way I'd have just disappeared off at 17 for a weekend without my Dad's permission. And I had a curfew, as did my friends. Perhaps that did make me pathetic but I don't think boundaries lasting a few more years than you had affected my ability to live as a adult 🙄

The problem is that her dad won't actually let her do anything. She was invited to a party a couple of years ago and he made the whole thing so unpleasant and stressful that she ended up not going and he then turned that eound on her and accused her of being flakey and ungrateful when, actually, he'd just taken the shine off it all.

He says no to everything just so that, if anything does go wrong, he can be the one who says it was nothing to do with him because he didn’t want her to do it in the first place and it'll be my fault for allowing it.

She doesn't have a curfew because she rarely goes out. It's just never been necessary. She doesn't drink, she's never tried a cigarette, never skived off school, never lied about where she was going. She's always been honest with me.

She pierced her nose a couple of years ago. Well her friend did it. She asked le to tell him be ause she was scared of his reaction. Her dad went off his rocker. He was talking about getting the police involved for assault, coercion and criminal activity. It was two teenage girls who'd pierced each other's noses. Probably ill advised but deserving of no more than an eye roll in reality. And then he told her he was disappointed that she didn't trust him enough to tell him and said that if she wasn't mature/old enough to tell him herself, then she wasn't old orature enough to have done it.

He got it into her head a couple of years ago that she'd been sending abusive messages to a friend of hers. I got reams of messages about that too talking about the sort of person she was, how he was concerned about bad infuences in her life, what he felt itight lead to in the future- criminal records, incarceration, never being able to get a job with vulnerable people. He might as well have been describing the downfall of humanity. She had fallen out with the friend a couple of years earlier but they'd recently got back in touch. She showed me her messages. Here was nothing to suggest unkindness and she went to that girls house for a sleepoever the following weekend. He'd just fabricated the whole thing.

This isn't about curfews or good behaviour. It's him being an absolutely prick.

OP posts:
autocarrot · 28/02/2023 17:51

So, assuming they can find somewhere to stay, she will he going and she won't he telling him. I will be knowing where she is going and she'll be in contact with me

Perfect solution @HowWouldYouRespondToThis.

My ex husband also sends reams of emails, endless diatribes etc, etc, etc regarding the (adult) children.

I now reply with "thanks", so he can't say I'm ignoring him (which would produce a further diatribe), and delete the emails. I don't even read beyond the first sentence or so, because life is too short.

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 17:51

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 28/02/2023 16:45

Yep! Far better than any relationships that I had at that age either!

I actually feel very happy for dd that her first proper boyfriend has effectively set the bar so high for her. I think it will go a very long way towards ensuring that she won't tolerate any substandard relationships in the future, because she has a very clear idea of what "good" looks like. I didn't have that when I was younger, and I think it caused me to put up with a lot more than I should have done.

Her bf's whole extended family have been absolutely lovely as well - so incredibly kind and welcoming. I think she likes his mum almost as much as she likes him!Wink

Ha, same!

He has a younger sister who she gets on well with too.

It's such a lovely first relationship experience. Especially when you read of the awful experiences some girls have 😥

Totally agree with everything you've said. It's nice to know that some teenagers are having a lovely experience!

OP posts:
icouldbutno · 28/02/2023 17:57

Op, I mean this kindly again, but it seems like during covid you've missed out a bit on how your relationship with your ex could reasonably be expected to change as your children become adults.

Why does he need to be directly in touch with you at this age or in coming months? I wouldn't expect parents of a 17 Yr old to have to do much direct communication at all on a daily or weekly basis. Yes post-18 decions maybe, arrangements for uni or suchlike but not so he thinks it's OK to send you streams of angry messages.

Have you considered telling him to arrange things directly with DD? What do you haveto contact each other about or, after all these years, are you still doing it because he'll get angry if you don't or if you block him?

I know these things aren't easy in real life but in black and white on the page, many posters have asked the same question.

So many of us are programmed to placate because it's easier but at this point, maybe it's time to rip the plaster off?

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 17:57

autocarrot · 28/02/2023 17:51

So, assuming they can find somewhere to stay, she will he going and she won't he telling him. I will be knowing where she is going and she'll be in contact with me

Perfect solution @HowWouldYouRespondToThis.

My ex husband also sends reams of emails, endless diatribes etc, etc, etc regarding the (adult) children.

I now reply with "thanks", so he can't say I'm ignoring him (which would produce a further diatribe), and delete the emails. I don't even read beyond the first sentence or so, because life is too short.

Yes I had a load about my adult son the other week. I just totally ignored him. In the end I said that I felt it was something the three of us should discuss together if he was that concerned. He ignored that suggestion. I suggested it 3 times in total. No other reply and he ignored it all.

He didn't want to resolve anything. He wanted to rant. He takes a tiny grain of truth and extrapolates the most ludicrous nonsense from it which just makes speaking to him about anything pointless.

I have no idea why he wants to think or speak so badly of his children who, in all honesty, have rarely given us any bother at all.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 28/02/2023 18:00

No I wouldn't be OK with this. Not surprised it looks like her Dad won't be either. Absolutely not on.

HowWouldYouRespondToThis · 28/02/2023 18:01

icouldbutno · 28/02/2023 17:57

Op, I mean this kindly again, but it seems like during covid you've missed out a bit on how your relationship with your ex could reasonably be expected to change as your children become adults.

Why does he need to be directly in touch with you at this age or in coming months? I wouldn't expect parents of a 17 Yr old to have to do much direct communication at all on a daily or weekly basis. Yes post-18 decions maybe, arrangements for uni or suchlike but not so he thinks it's OK to send you streams of angry messages.

Have you considered telling him to arrange things directly with DD? What do you haveto contact each other about or, after all these years, are you still doing it because he'll get angry if you don't or if you block him?

I know these things aren't easy in real life but in black and white on the page, many posters have asked the same question.

So many of us are programmed to placate because it's easier but at this point, maybe it's time to rip the plaster off?

I think you're probably right about the relationship not transitioning and I do think lockdown probably had a lot to do with that.

I'm not sure whether he was always quite so anxious and risk averse but it's become very apparent since lockdown.

Tbh, we rarely speak. I haven't contacted him since before Christmas when we just clarified Christmas and because he was a bit inconsistent and I just wanted to clarify for my own plans as the children were really sure.

She does make her own plans with him.

He only gets in touch when he wants to send these lengthy rants. I'm not even sure he actually expects a response to them. He doesn't say anything about the fact I don't respond.

He's upset them both many times though.

OP posts:
CantStopWontStop0 · 28/02/2023 18:02

Absolutely not. But that's my view.