@anxiiousone thanks
I agree as an ex nurse myself who mainly worked in elderly care I came across a lot of hcps with similar views regarding patients with limited quality of life being kept alive and even at points felt that way myself.
There were patients I cared for who were suffering and in great pain but being kept alive mainly to assuage the guilt of the deciding relatives - unpalatable maybe, true definitely! It was more about relatives not being "ready" to let the person go regardless of how the patient was suffering.
That's a whole other thread really though as it feeds into medical ethics, who decides, and our cultural DEEP discomfort and verging on clinical denial that death and dying is part of life. It's unavoidable and some unfortunately will die before reaching close to a "normal" lifespan.
I have relatives with life limiting conditions, they're far more realistic and very clear about their wishes to the point of making detailed "living wills" and having DNR notifications and have had detailed discussion with their gps and assigning the least emotive relatives who are most likely to adhere to their wishes as their advocates.
I'm in relatively good health physically at the moment in these terms (I have a physical disability due to a car accident that affects my nerves and is mainly a pain issue, plus serious mh issues) but I have made clear to dd my wishes regarding if anything were to happen to me that left me in a vegetative state, unable to communicate but in lots of pain etc what my wishes are, also my wishes regarding organ donation, funeral style etc we shouldn't shy away from these things.
I think he might be better suited to a research role, frankly.
a colleague suggested that to him only a week ago!
I agree, the thought of this guy dealing with patients and families on possibly the worst day of their lives is seriously concerning!
It's unfortunately VERY difficult to get rid of bad clinicians
@Gcgjiut You have a very poor grasp on how it works! and a frankly disgusting and combative attitude to the op which I HAVE reported!
I'd argue if every clinician with a dx mh condition was prevented from working AS a clinician the nhs and patients would be FUCKED! Healthcare workers are at significantly higher risk of mh conditions BECAUSE of the nature of their jobs!
People with mental illness absolutely can and do make good hcps - I was a nurse for 7 years with active ocd. It made me a bloody good nurse, my patients were well cared for - not just my assessment - and had the lowest acquired infection rates! There are many hcps working and being excellent hcps while suffering from depression, anxiety, ocd, health anxiety, eating disorders and even conditions like bipolar. Doesn't make them any less capable, and often makes them MORE empathic as they can relate to patients own stresses and anxieties.
Indeed a level of arrogance/narcissism is even necessary for some roles! Or they'd not be able to eg cut open the heart of patient, amputate a limb, inject the heart, deliver the worst news (we had a whole day of specific training on that one!)
The surgeon I had who removed my ectopic pregnancy had a dreadful "bedside manner" which my then husband balked at but I actually found it much easier to be able to ask straight questions and get straight answers as to what I was facing, she actually managed to remove the embryo and other tissue while leaving the tube intact - that takes an immense amount of skill and was the best possible outcome. I'd have her 10 times over and twice on Sunday's rather than one with a better bedside manner but who didn't have the skill to leave the tube in place and still functioning! Even one of the nurses apologised for her manner and I said no need, she clearly knows her job and my case well and that's more important.
Don't doctors have any psychological screening before they are let loose on unsuspecting patients??
😂😂😂😂
Er...no basically!
During my nurse training we had modules on mh/psychology, excepting the one trainer/lecturer who had been a mh nurse the others made no disguise of the fact that they thought that even doing the modules was a huge waste of their time! That should give you some idea of how most hcps feel about mental illness in patients let alone colleagues!
@TheDaydreamBelievers exactly!
@Eckhart excellent posts as usual
@Lovemusic33 you REALLY need to rtft!
@MrDarcysMa you also, many hcps have similar views and I agree with pp who said many lay people do too they just don't admit it. I've even got friends and family who HAVE disabled children with similar views, it's not callous to consider that quality of life (particularly when high levels of pain may be a factor) is important in such discussions and decisions. I've been with parents when they have made such heartbreaking but ultimately correct decisions.
Again our cultural attitude towards this is appalling, rather than discuss it we ignore it and leave such families lacking the ability or forums to get much needed advice and support
How can one trust him to put 100% into saving a life of such a child as a doctor in A&E? I couldn't. actually I'd trust a dr like that more than a more empathic dr, more likely to be honest about the effects of treatment ON THE PATIENT than tiptoeing around the FEELINGS of the parents, also hcps like this tend to be stringent rule followers and wouldn't give any but the most ethical, excellent quality care. I suspect he's very good at the skills side of things.
Some posters have very odd and unrealistic ideas of what it takes to make a good hcp.
Op glad you've made the right decision for you. Good luck to you, you sound lovely and I'm sure when the time is right you'll meet the person for you