Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Has anyone's partner hit them just the once?

196 replies

sn21 · 20/05/2020 10:15

Me and my partner have been together 6 years, we've always had a rocky relationship, however last night we had an argument and he hit me. The argument sort of stopped after that, and I took myself in the bathroom. While he stayed in the bedroom. Long story short he had a panic attack, over what he did and said he couldn't believe what he'd just done and he was really sorry. I've read so many domestic abuse stories, that the physical abuse can come much later, but after 6 years of being with him he has never put a finger on me. I'm not scared of him, I just don't know whether to believe him or not 😔

OP posts:
nowornever1 · 20/05/2020 21:04

I went crazy when I was in the pill and had horrible PMT and I had left my parents home and moved in with my boyfriend and I would be crazy, irrational and would scream and shout and sometimes hit my OH.

He did hit me during a couple of times during those arguments and I'm ashamed I also hit him.

But that a was a very bad period of our relationship. I came off the pill, reconciled with my parents and we got married and have an amazing strong marriage. We have been together for 20 plus yrs and have 3 kids and I know we were both wrong but we were too young and couldn't cope. Now aged 40 we wouldn't dream of hitting so I do believe depending on the circumstances you can move past violence. We bicker a bit nowadays but generally we don't argue anymore

PrincessButtercuppp · 20/05/2020 21:11

He did that to you one time too many. Only ever hitting someone once is not a thing, and I'm guessing you already know it. Sorry it worked out like this but better you know now. I genuinely feel for you x

Dery · 20/05/2020 21:51

There is probably the occasional exception but he will almost certainly hit you again. But really this:

"A rocky relationship?
One where there is anger and arguing?
Why would you stay? Even before he hit you."

A rocky relationship is by definition no foundation for the future. No-one could recommend that you bring children into a rocky relationship. What are you hoping for long-term and why do you think your partner is the person to supply it? (And don't base your decisions on having been together for 6 years - google sunk costs fallacy and you'll get the point). Sounds like it may be time to start afresh.

crispysausagerolls · 20/05/2020 21:54

@SomeoneElseEntirelyNow

Never read a truer post. Eerily familiar and true.

Babyg1995 · 20/05/2020 21:56

Yes my ex partner hit me only the once because I left his sorry ass there and then they NEVER change .

Tootletum · 20/05/2020 21:58

No experience but I think the theory is that domestic violence is the same as dogs who worry sheep. If they've done it once, they get a taste for it. Stick around to find out, or get heavy duty counselling, or cut your losses.

Dragongirl10 · 20/05/2020 22:02

Sorry but that is a huge boundary he's crossed. How DARE he hit you? Who the hell does he think he is? I was always taught the first time a man raises his hand, you walk away. You are worth more than being someone's punch bag. Hope you're ok.

THIS ^^

Sugartitss · 20/05/2020 22:08

Bollocks to the panic attack.

Bet it was worthy of an Oscar.

buckfastattiffanys · 21/05/2020 00:23

Yes.
Once and that was over. He also tried to say he couldn't beleive i'd "driven him to it" and that i'd brought out a side of him he didn't know existed.

I reported it to the police and they were so supportive. I explained that he thought id driven him to it and described the lead up. Basically I'd gone round to his when he'd forgotten he'd invited me. He was angry I'd then caught him smoking weed. (I didn't know this about him). I asked him what was going on and he told me to leave. I said you invited me round? Cue some threatening stances and some punches.

I exaplained that he told me to leave, if I'd left he wouldn't have hit me.

Their response was that, whatever the situation, everyone has a choice and it was his choice to respond with violence.

So simple, yet so powerful.

viccytwiffy · 21/05/2020 01:12

but it wasnt your first argument was it... and he has been fantasising (dont judge him for this, he is human) about hitting you - because after each argument he thinks about how hitting you might have improved how he felt, not necessarily coherently though... just a visual fantasy - (i had them for years about my sister actually, and i eventually one day slapped her very hard, and felt terrible) - his mind has connected to his body in regard to this fantasy - it is now a connection, an algorhythm, a response, a practiced reaction (once is enough to train the mind body) - you are in for it.... but it's only a hit aint it.. i mean he didnt chop your head off.... depends what you think you can take... but in my opinion - its too late - you have to leave him and that would be fair to him - he needs real justice, not just a wishy washy forgiveing wife - you owe it to the relationship to leave...you owe it to eachother to leave... being hit is the 'full stop' 'the end' of this relationship... he knew that, you knew that... make it a loving end.

GrumpyHoonMain · 21/05/2020 01:21

Hitting just the once is rare and usually only happens when the abuser goes straight to counselling and actively works on his / her anger issues. I was hit by a man on one occasion but I think the embarrassment of me absolutely thrashing him (grew up around brothers so I know how to defend myself) and throwing him bodily out of the house in his underwear in the middle of the day made him realise he needed help. If I had been smaller or weaker he could have battered me and would have had no incentive to change. Anyway he’s genuinely a changed man now and manages his temper and MH issues in a far better way.

InterestingIris · 21/05/2020 01:32

Not hit...but dh did push me violently once, a couple of years into our relationship.

We were late teens/early twenties, both drunk and shouting at each other - he shoved me away, really hard, and I careered back into a bookcase and ended up on the floor. It bloody hurt too.

He was mortified and apologised profusely and swore he didn’t know what came over him and he would never do it again...I very nearly left him but didn’t. 16 years later, there’s never been a repeat and we have a very happy marriage.

This incident was very much a one off in many ways though - our relationship wasn’t/isn’t generally volatile and we’re not usually the ‘drunk and shouting’ type...it was our first ever big argument after two years and massively fuelled by alcohol on both sides.

There’s no excuse for it ever but only you can judge the ‘validity’ of his panic attack and other circumstances. However if your relationship is generally volatile this sounds more like an escalation to me rather than a one off and I would certainly think carefully about continuing the relationship.

RaingodsWithZippos · 21/05/2020 01:35

Can a man hit a woman once and then never again? Sure. DH slapped me once, because I was attacking him and the only way to stop me was to shock me into stopping by thumping me. Situation completely contained - I was so gobsmacked that he raised his hand to me that i stopped hitting him on his head where he had a huge scar from a childhood injury. However, the fight only arose because I was struggling with my mental health and completely screwed up as a result of a previous abusive relationship. He was very patient with me until that point and put up with me treating him dreadfully - I was pushing against normal boundaries because my ex had abused me in every way possible and for some screwed up reason I thought if I pushed DH he would turn out the same. He didn't - he was a thoroughly decent man who was so upset that he had slapped me even though it was self defence. We were together for 20 years, this incident occurred about 2 years into our relationship when I was very unwell and had PND. Neither of us raised a hand to the other after that one incident, I never had to walk on eggshells or appease him, we were ourselves completely around each other but it did spur me on to seek treatment for my depression.

My ex, however, different kettle of fish. Started hitting me just after we got engaged, when we moved in together he would beat me black and blue, rape me, controlled who I spoke to and where I went, forced me to have an abortion, stopped me.going to uni, cheated on me constantly - he was always sorry after he hit me but sorry that he had reacted to me pushing his buttons when he had told himself not to rise to it. I was too scared to push buttons, I once got beaten and punished for suggesting we ate chips from the paper instead of on a plate, that was the pettiness of what drove him to hit me. Or once I was reading Cosmo magazine and there was a poster of a man with no shirt on - I was kicked down the stairs for that with just a t shirt on, no underwear or shoes, and made to cross the main road to put the magazine in the litter bin because he wouldn't have 'that porno' in the flat. He then got us locked out and the fire brigade had to come to let us back in - he broke my collarbone for that and made me take a crate of beer down to the fire station to apologise for my stupidity in getting us locked out.

Totally different situations but I bet my ex is still violent towards his current wife, whereas my lovely DH never even lost his temper with me again after that one episode where I had started it and he was trying to stop it. Our marriage was never rocky.

Only you know which of those two situations is more comparable to your own, but if it's more similar to the one with my ex, do yourself a favour and get rid.

sn21 · 22/05/2020 13:43

Thank you for all of your replies, I am so grateful. I am okay, I’m not quite sure how I feel about what happened the other day, I’ve felt quite emotionless since. I have taken pictures of what I can in case I do decide to take it further. I only have a scratch on my neck and a faint bruise by my collar bone and on the back of my shoulder.

By rocky relationship I mean we’ve been on and off in the past we’ve had a lot of people make it difficult for us to be together, my dad kicked me out when I was 15 because I refused to break up with him because he was very strict over the whole “boyfriend” thing. I’m 21 and he’s 22 we have 3 children together (3,2&6 months) we’ve been together since we were 15. It’s always been that we’ve been good together and things will go really well for ages and then something happens and things will just blow up. We both have our own mental health struggles so that does play a part in it as well, which causes the arguments to sometimes escalate, but we’ve been good for 2 years now and things have been going extremely well. We’ve put in so much effort to make our relationship work for the kids. We still have a way to go, but things have been really looking up.

The other day we were just having a normal argument about something stupid, it turned into bringing other things into it and it just kept going. I started to feel really overwhelmed and I went to leave the bedroom. He shut the door and stood in front of it and told me we needed to talk about it. I was in too much of a state to talk it out at that point in time and I told him I needed to go to the bathroom and calm myself down first. He refused and said he didn’t trust me because he thought I was going to self harm. I promised him I wouldn’t and I said he can even stand at the bedroom door and watch me make sure I go in the bathroom or i told him I’d sit in the kids room (they were at nursery at the time). I just needed a few minutes to myself to calm down. I even suggested he go in the kitchen and leave me to calm down in the bedroom. He still refused, so I kept trying to go round him and grab the door handle and he pushed me on the bed and strangled me. I didn’t back down once he got off me I said to him, that him keeping me in the room was stressing me out and the longer he kept me in there the more I was going to think about self harming. He still refused so I tried to go to the door again and he repeated what he did again. I still got back up and I don’t remember much of what was said but I believe he pushed me again so I spat on him (I don’t know why I did it🤦🏼‍♀️ this is completely out of character for me but I know it’s a big hate of his and in the moment I thought it would’ve helped me get him out of my way somehow) he then slapped me across my face and knocked me off my feet. He grabbed me as I fell to the floor and shouted in my face. It then stopped shortly after this and I went to the bathroom. Then I came out and he had his panic attack.

I feel like I have no right to be upset over what he did because we’ve had bad arguments in the past where I’ve tried to hit/push him because he’s refused to let me leave a room or refused to get out of the house. Every time I’ve lashed out at him he’s just accepted it because he said it doesn’t hurt and I feel like he’s now finally hit me back, even though I could never have the strength to actually hurt him, but this time I didn’t do anything.

He grew up watching his dad beat up his mum regularly and I’ve always assumed from what he’s told me and how he speaks about it that it’s really affected him and made him want to be completely different. He’s always told me that he’s proud he never grew up to become “that man”. When he had his panic attack all he kept saying was “I’m so sorry, I’m just like my dad. I’m nothing but a scumbag” and that he had flashbacks of when it used to happen to his mum straight after. I’d like to genuinely believe he isn’t that person as he’s always supported me through everything like my dad being emotionally abusive and I’ve been raped in the past. He’s reacted to those things as you’d find any man would. However when it comes to my mental health struggles I always feel like he always shuts me down. He doesn’t understand how I can want to cause harm to myself when I have children to think about etc. And always makes me feel bad if I self harm by telling me things like “well if you didn’t do that you wouldn’t be in pain a few days later”.

Its taken until this morning for him to finally tell me that it won’t happen again. It’s been 3 days. I don’t know if I believe him or not. I was having doubts about the relationship before this happened as I’m just finding it hard to keep this relationship going. I’m always stressed, I feel like I’m doing 80% but he thinks he’s doing his fair share. I’m in debt with a few bills and I’m never going to be able to pay them off if I leave him as my money just doesn’t cover it. Our relationship seems to have gone back to normal since if anything better than how it’s been the past few weeks building up to the incident. I don’t know if he’s trying to prove his love for me and earn my trust back or if he’s just trying to play with my mind. He’s been really affectionate, he’s been checking in. Everytime I mention the incident or when I showed him what he’d done to me now the bruises have come up he will just apologise again and again. He’s instigated sex twice since and I stupidly went along with it. We haven’t had sex in about 2 weeks and before that it was more once every month his choice not mine (this is also a new thing in the relationship that’s started in the past year). He’s a great dad and it would break the children’s hearts if we weren’t together😔

OP posts:
fourquenelles · 22/05/2020 14:01

Strangled you twice? He will KILL YOU.

AwrightDoreenTakeAFuckinDayOff · 22/05/2020 14:03

He isn’t a great dad to his children if he strangles their mother and hits her.

Your children’s hearts will be more broken if he seriously injures you or kills you.

AwrightDoreenTakeAFuckinDayOff · 22/05/2020 14:03

Leave. Before he does.

LovingLola · 22/05/2020 14:05

You need to separate
For all your sakes

AwrightDoreenTakeAFuckinDayOff · 22/05/2020 14:06

And please read @SomeoneElseEntirelyNow ‘s post.

Please.

Again and again and again until it sinks in.

MarieQueenofScots · 22/05/2020 14:07

As soon as someone is violent once it proves they’re capable of it. However much they profess to it will never happen again, you will never be sure.

Leave before he does it again.

SueEllenMishke · 22/05/2020 14:13

He strangled you?
He will kill you. You need to leave.

WiryTail · 22/05/2020 14:13

No, not in 23 years.

Former partner did and carried on doing it and other shit controlling stuff until I saw sense and left.

NiteFlights · 22/05/2020 14:16

He strangled you? He will kill you. You need to leave.

Please listen, OP. Please leave.

MsPavlichenko · 22/05/2020 14:18

He's not a great dad. You being killed will break your DC's hearts. His father being violent sadly makes it more likely he will be abusive not less. And your DC too if you don't get away from this toxic environment.

Please call WA.

Saltystraw · 22/05/2020 14:21

Unlike others I think it’s good he felt remorse straight away. Would you rather he felt none.
I think people can be pushed to extremes, most cases it’s not a one off but sometimes they find that act so horrific that they wouldn’t do it again.