Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Has anyone's partner hit them just the once?

196 replies

sn21 · 20/05/2020 10:15

Me and my partner have been together 6 years, we've always had a rocky relationship, however last night we had an argument and he hit me. The argument sort of stopped after that, and I took myself in the bathroom. While he stayed in the bedroom. Long story short he had a panic attack, over what he did and said he couldn't believe what he'd just done and he was really sorry. I've read so many domestic abuse stories, that the physical abuse can come much later, but after 6 years of being with him he has never put a finger on me. I'm not scared of him, I just don't know whether to believe him or not 😔

OP posts:
pointythings · 20/05/2020 11:37

Well, my late husband 'only' threatened to kill me on one occasion. But that was because I called the police, had him removed and refused to let him come back.

I don't think much of your chances here, OP.

suggestionsplease1 · 20/05/2020 11:44

A female partner slapped me once when we were both very young and I had said something provocative (no I know that is no excuse, but that was the scenario.) She was immediately apologetic although I wasn't in the mood to accept any apologies right at that point in time.

I knew her well enough to know that that wasn't going to be typical for her and that our relationship wasn't characterised by any other emotional abuse, controlling behaviour etc, so I let it go. We were in the relationship a further 4 years without any repeat of that and then separated after growing apart. We were never ones for major arguments and there wasn't an unhealthy dynamic. We are still very good friends now.

So to answer your question, I think it's possible but you have to look at the broader context of your relationship and interactions; if the relationship is already characterised by problems, arguments and is volatile I would say there is a very good chance it will happen again.

newtb · 20/05/2020 11:44

Yes, less than 3 months after we were married. It was with enough force to smash their knuckle.

Apparently it was my fault as they were trying to get me to talk to them.

After 40 years I finally managed to get the courage to leave. Nearly 3 years ago and not yet divorced.

No medical attention for me, but dh went to hospital. Police would prosecute, but no longer in the UK.

JudyCoolibar · 20/05/2020 11:47

The problem is that if he gets away with it once, consciously or subconsciously he will think that he can get away with it again; for him, a mental barrier would have fallen.

I second taking a photograph of any injuries, and consider calling Women's Aid.

Raidblunner · 20/05/2020 11:51

No one should be hitting each other in relationships. When they do they've lost control of themselves and are putting your safety at risk. You could have slipped hit your head and potentially received a serious injury. That's what makes it a step to far, I would say unless he seeks professional help with this it's the end of the road.
My ex was often 'loose' with her hands over our time together, I'm not a small bloke and mostly could shield myself but it's still didn't make it right. Please be careful and make sure he sees the impact of it, promises of not doing it again don't tackle the underlying issue of it. I'd say get help or get out.

LexMitior · 20/05/2020 11:54

No.

His panic attack was designed to manipulate you and your emotions. He will certainly do it again because it will get easier to blame you for everything after this.

That’s why you have to leave. My ex punched walls. He then progressed to making an attack. The psychology was pretty clear - he thought I would accept he was allowed to do this.

Don’t be fooled. One hit sets the tone for years.

AgentJohnson · 20/05/2020 11:56

There was a year between the first hit (grabbing me by the throat and pinning me to the ground) and me regaining consciousness in an ambulance. A line was crossed and he could never accept that an therefore was blind to the new reality that crossing that line had created.

OP the odds aren’t great but him playing the victim to his poor treatment of you, doesn’t bode well.

NoMoreDickheads · 20/05/2020 11:59

I hit my partner recently. It was during the exposure of his affair

@MizMoonshine To me that's a bit different- you were in shock etc. He's a cheating arsehole and you can do better than him.

OP- It sounds like the relationship is frequently unpleasant, anyway, and his hitting you comes on top of that. Not good at all.

WhatwouldLangdo · 20/05/2020 12:01

@MizMoonshine

No, there's no excuse for violence ever. He cheated on you and you were violent towards him. Both are disgusting.

category12 · 20/05/2020 12:04

I think whatever the circumstances of hitting a partner, it means something is irrevocably broken between you. So while I think most people could understand hitting someone who cheated on you, it still means it's done, broke, fubar. And time to get out.

Zhuleva · 20/05/2020 12:05

It's (of course) horrible what he did, and completely unacceptable. The only thing I'd offer in mitigation is that my dad once hit my mum in the 60s, and was similar to your partner in that he was horrified and vowed never to do it again. And he didn't - and didn't do anything even coming close. They're still together now and in their 80s

YouJustDoYou · 20/05/2020 12:14

You can bet your bottom dollar he would not have hit a 6'5 body builder. Why? Because he would know the towering body builder would retaliate and your bf would be beaten to a pulp.

So - why did he hit you? Because he knew, self consciously or not, HE WAS SAFE. He was safe from being physically hurt back. He was safe to hurt someone weaker than him.

Would he hit his boss? No. Because firing and no income. Would he...punch a policeman out of anger?? No, of course not. Because arrest and prison. And so on.

Even women who hit men often do it because they know that, typically, a man won't hit her back.

Abusers do it because they can. Because it's easy. Because it's safe for them to do it.

begoniapot · 20/05/2020 12:19

Fuck the panic attack and the remorse. He will do it again. A little switch goes off in the mind of a violent person once they have hit you, and you stay. The switch tells them you've tolerated it once so you will again.

AnnaNimmity · 20/05/2020 12:21

My ex only hit me once - I left him after that though. When I looked back over the relationship, there was another incidence of violence that I had normalised, and lots of controlling behaviour.

However I did speak to his ex after the violence to warn her (and he corroborated what she said), and she told me that he had been violent to her, and that the behaviour had escalated his behaviour with her - getting increasingly violent, right up to pushing her down the stairs, and putting his hands around her neck. My view is that once it's happened once, and you've let it go, there's a boundary that's been broken. And they know that. It becomes easier to justify extreme behaviour.

(interestingly when he hit me, he was shouting out her name - it was terrifying. The hate . I still have flashbacks to that night).

But more terrifying was that she chose to go back to him, with a child, and risk her life and that of the child. There is clear evidence that domestic violence escalates, and putting hands round neck is a massive risk factor. I do not know why anyone would go back if there is even a tiny risk of violence, but with a child? It's selfish to the extreme I think.

I don't know if you've got children OP. But it was that fear that stopped me going back to him. He pushed me onto a concrete step, and I fell hard. I was very bruised. But it could have been worse.

I have also read the Gift of Fear and picked up on that quote (quoted by a PP) - if you are hit once you are a victim, twice and you are a volunteer.

Good luck Op. My experience was that he just worried about himself. Begging, and pleading, but ultimately just worrying about his own reputation. He went on to accuse me of lying. I wish I was.

Friendsofmine · 20/05/2020 12:25

I slapped my ex partner once after he told me how he'd cheated on me and screamed at me. I have never hit anyone before or since. It was 20 years ago. I certainly didn't want him to comfort me as I freaked out.

I think this is different. I think you are alluding to a bad relationship already with other things going on. I am worried this is the start of something.

LexMitior · 20/05/2020 12:26

@Zhuleva

Maybe for your parents this was okay. Still, have you ever reflected on why you know this story? In its way, it’s odd that you do.

I don’t think this man is regretful except for himself. He realises he is in the shit if she reports it. Better to claim he is on verge of having mental episode than take responsibility for his actions. That tells you just how selfish he is.

CoronaMoaner · 20/05/2020 12:29

No this was not my experience.
My ExH didn’t hit me for the first time until after we were married. We’d been together 5 years by that point.
At the time it felt bizarre that it had never happened before but now I realise it was probably because he had married me and I was a strong believer in marriage is forever (which he knew).
In my case it wasn’t a punch to the face. It started off pushing me around (physically) escalating to a shove down the stairs and the final attack strangling me against a wall.
That progression happened over 7 years. The last time it happened I had this realisation that if I didn’t leave he would kill me (intentionally or not).

My advice would be to leave the relationship but I appreciate that is easier said then done.

Oh and finally, whatever you decide don’t keep the incident last night a secret. He will want you to.

NamesNamesSoManyNames · 20/05/2020 12:32

Look, I am sure there are people who have only hit someone once.
But I wouldn't take the chance.
He's shown a lack of control. What's to say he won't be "pushed" into it again? (pushed in brackets and it's never pushed, it's always their behaviour that's to blame)
Would he have hit a man who matched him in strength? Would he have hit his boss if they had a disagreement?

HollowTalk · 20/05/2020 12:33

You've had some good advice here, OP - apart from the quote from a man who said a woman who's hit more than once is a volunteer. Absolutely disgusting thing to say.

madcatladyforever · 20/05/2020 12:37

I doubt it. My husband started about 5years in and it escalated from there and then always the pathetic crying. But at the end there was no crying just hate.
It sounds to me that your relationship should be over anyway. It's not OK to be screaming and arguing with each other all the time anyway.

SoleBizzz · 20/05/2020 12:39

It WILL happen again. Take responsibility and dump.

SoleBizzz · 20/05/2020 12:39

For your wellbeing *

chickpeachicky · 20/05/2020 12:39

No, it's never once.

AnotherElle · 20/05/2020 12:41

Do you have children OP?

If children's services were to become aware of this and the fact you were still in a relationship they would have concerns.

Maybe you don't have children I don't know but isn't this reality enough for you to see this is not a healthy relationship and if you don't already have dc then he's not the right "man" to have them with? And if you already do then don't take a chance as they need you to make the right decision for them.

PlanDeRaccordement · 20/05/2020 12:42

I agree with PP, any man that consciously hits you has crossed the line and you should not stay with him. You say your relationship is rocky anyway so there is no point putting off the inevitable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread