Thank-you all so much for your responses. They have been really helpful.
@StealthNinjaMum She said at the time that I had made her judge herself and that if she hadn't been "a slag" in the past, she wouldn't have to worry about this because I admitted I wouldn't have been too worried if she had less partners.
Unfortunately, she specifically had dtd with 10 different bikers (from a biker bar) in the space of as many months back in her youth. This was brand new information that triggered my concern. I am not saying she didn't use protection, but I can imagine (and yes I am stereotyping that bikers might not be too picky about safe-sex and possible drug-taking/needle use). It was specifically the biker aspect that freaked me out. I did wonder if she had gotten the feels and then caught herself when that conversation came up. When we were discussing it on Sunday and she was saying she thought I was getting too invested and I said "I was never going to fall in love with her and that she wasn't going to fall in love with me, was she?"... she paused for several seconds before reply "no".
@Neverexpected2 I think she is burying her head, she said that she would get extremely anxious waiting for results. I get it, first time I was testing, I felt the same. This is my third time and its water off a duck's back to me. I didn't ask her if she was scared and she said not, but I think she was in self-preservation mode by then.
@Sunshineandflipflops This was the strange thing. We were seeing each other more often than I used to see my LTRs. Only difference was that dtd was expected when I went round.
@DaffoDeffo Obviously, I made a mistake by accepting her at her word but I think in my head the risk exposure had increased a lot based on the new information. As is stated on the thread later, as far as I knew, exposure wasn't guaranteed based on any time frame. I can see why and how she would be upset. I did try and explain that it was all about risk and nothing about moral judgement. Unfortanately, I think the moral stigma for STI and an inference that she had something was what was upsetting her. Regarding your herpes comments, I agree, I am starting to think the whole thing is pot luck, and even doing all the right things you are just reducing it, not eradicating it.
@Ant330 Given the advice I had received from the tester guy, I regret not going with this option.
@Easha I think she has her head buried in the sand and just doesn't want to deal with it.
@Crustaceans Yes, I think I am going to wait a lot longer before ditching the condoms. Unfortunately, I really struggle with them. I won't say why, but they seriously curtail the enjoyment.
@JeSuisPrest I think by the point I realised I had to say something, it was a shit-show. I was really hoping she would just say she would get tested, but I think she was adamant she wasn't going to be pushed into something she felt she didn't have to do.
@LilyRose88 Unfortunately, I think she thought us getting tested "together" was too much of a couply thing to do, IDK.
@midcenturylegs We have known each other for about a year and a half already. I did say that it's been playing on my mind that we shouldn't have ditched them so soon. I obviously hadn't dtd with someone else because I would have just had the test on my own. I know she felt judged and that definitely hurt her.
@HIVpos Very special thank-you for sharing. I read the thread you linked too. Extremely brave to detail your story and I can't imagine the stress it must have put you under. Clearly from the thread, the stigma is worse than the virus with current medical treatment. What is very frustrating was that your advice contradicts the advice the health professional gave. I believe you, over him. He seemed pretty laid-back about the whole thing and I got the impression he didn't really care much about HIV because we were talking heterosexual sex involving UK citizens. I opted for everything anyway, because... well... why not? I think your comment about "type" is so true. This was the mistake I made in that she is in a respected profession but it was only once the back-story came out that I got concerned.
Thank-you all again. I think it has helped me put it all into perspective and I have less of the wtf feeling in my head. I think if we are to start again, then I think I will go back to condoms but be okay with oral. It was when I suggested we would have to cut out oral that shit really hit the fan.