I seem to have a habit of having old irons reconnecting with me. I'd like to think it was because I'm so good, lol. Has anyone else had this and what do you think/what do you do?
Third it's more than likely because they're wondering if they can get some no-strings sex. I don't mean just in your case, but in general when people come sniffing around again, that's their motivation. I don't get this because I'm very clear that if something isn't right for me then it's over and I don't engage with them any further.
Mr Wow doesn't sound particularly lovely tbh - still using POF 'for the laughs' - yeah right! If he really wanted exclusivity with you, you'd be exclusive. Words are easy, look at his actions.
Be careful that you're not seeing what you want him to be/think he could be rather than what he actually is. Everyone has met men who 'could be' perfect if only they did or didn't do x, y and z, but if they're not actually doing x, y and z or don't want to do it then they're not perfect at all, it's projection and fantasy.
I posted on your other thread last week and honestly, you need to raise your bar for acceptable behaviour and set some firmer boundaries or you're just going to keep repeating this same pattern with non-committal chancers.