Mmmm, I think that's maybe the problem? Facially attractive, so photographs well for profile shots, sort of "fluffs over" the physical build, then doesn't get much follow up from first meets? 
I mean I think people are attracted to different builds, so if you put an inaccurate representation online then not only are you gonna meet people who aren't attracted to you in person BUT you'll also prevent yourself meeting those who WILL be attracted to you and your physique in person
I have met a few chaps who seem to have taken some good "arty at an angle photos" but in person are about 75% less attractive (I'd say its not just facial structure, but posture, dress sense, voice, etc)! So now I try and go for men with a few "natuarl unposed in daylight" shots.
I'm no oil painting myself but try and get the most accurate representation of myself, don't really struggle for follow up after meets. Actually am quite sad and take recent pics of myself in front of a mirror haha!