Nice one Spence - glad you were able to relax and have a good time a bit.
Walk - Nora is right, when I look at profiles I see a dozen that look pretty much the same - 'love to travel, curl up with wine/dvd, walks on the beach, work hard/play hard', all that rubbish. To get someone interesting interested, it's about your profile and standing out from the same old, same old.
Write something witty & humorous, interesting but not overly philosophical (you can get to that later if it's you) Don't mention how much you love salsa, zumba, yoga, travel, even if it's true. Give someone something to ask questions about. Movies, tv programs, poetry, whatever floats your boat. People want that 'me-too' moment to begin when they read the profile, same as on a good first date.
And so many profiles are just bland, almost copy and pasted from others. Boring.
You'll stand out from all the same old rubbish - at least to someone who's not likely to just send cockshots to the first 50 pretty faces he sees that day.
I like Match, personally, compared to the others. Haven't tried GSM simply because I prefer to stick to one site, and I know how that one works. However now I'm in a different place I thought I'd try OKC which is also kind of okay. POF still sucks.