@oggdog why are you dead-set on the Mansfield / Ashfield and into Derbyshire area? This is nowhere near the peak district, so I'm wondering what is drawing you to the area?
This whole area is ex-mining towns, areas that thr BNP used to be very vocal in and now we have the modern day equivalent with Reform UK strong in the area. These are deprived areas.
There will be many nice, decent people living in the area. But when the whole of Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire is your options - these are not the areas anyone local would choose.
Which brings me back to - what is drawing you to this area?
If you want to be on the edge of the Peak District, you want Carsington, Darley Dale, Cromford areas. Pixton, Ripley, Class Cross, these aren't near thr Peak District. There are much nicer villages in the countryside on the Nottinghamshire Lincolnshire or Leicestershire side of the County. Look for Bottesford, Belvoir, Langer and that side of Nottinghamshire.