Ali was just going to respond to your previous post but now I'm ignoring you for suggesting I have another baby! I can't cope with one!!
No, interesting that you should ask about Sharon's opinion, because this came up. I told the group that I decided he was only feeding at night out of habit. Now, remember that Sharon is as baby-led feeding as is humanly possible, and puts the baby totally in charge of bfing (this is a caveat, really!), but she sort of rolled her eyes and didn't seem hugely impressed! I managed to stop flagellating myself to think it through. From her BLbf view, Iestyn is in charge. And if Iestyn wants to feed at night, he wants to feed at night. But in reality he's not feeding because he's hungry, and it really must have been just a habit because it was broken! If it was comfort, he manages without it, and he's not losing weight. So go for it.
(Mind you, that's easy for me to say because I think I was just lucky, and Iestyn wasn't a good sleeper but he was a good settler, in that once he was fed he settled (but it could be up to 5 times a night though!) and so CC wasn't too hard because it's the settling that's the problem. This isn't smugness, it's me saying that I can't really claim success on this one because the problem wasn't as bad as what others have been going through.)
Feeding during the day - I've discussed this with Sharon and my brilliant HV (am I the only one with a fabulous HV?!). Sharon said Iestyn will indicate the number of feeds he needs. True, but he's not always accurate! However, he feeds morning, after lunch or afternoon if I'm with him, sometimes another afternoon one, and bedtime. When he's at nursery/with Mum, he gets morning, afternoon c. 4.30, and bedtime. However, Mum says he's usually arching his back and unsettled i.e. needs a bf at 4.30 if I'm not there on time. Whether that's hunger or comfort, I don't know. Do you have 'signs' with Peter or do you have set times? My personal non-expert opinion is since you're with him all the time, feed when he demands during the day, simply because you can? And if it's set times, perhaps drop one? What do I know anyway!
Oh, if you're dropping night feeds, then I found it helpful to make sure Iestyn actually eats loads in the day. For my peace of mind, so that he's really not hungry! He now demands more breakfast!
I'm typing a long one in the hope Sponge makes contact whilst I'm doing it!