It's not as simple as an old lady being attacked by a stranger - I think (and I may be wrong) that what Kibbutz is trying to get across is that she found her child's behaviour improved massively when she started behaving differently herself.
Also that this child is not a stranger - she is the child of the oP and obviously reacting to the situation she finds herself in, whether or not the OP can help it.
I agree Rowingboat that RHK cannot currently do any more than she is doing - she is in a very bad state and nobody can change their behaviour just like that - it needs an epiphany of some sort.
But I do not think this is aided by enabling a victim mentality. That's not good for anyone.
Support, yes, but the gently, gently, stroling approach can go on and on and remove all personal responsibility from the unfortunate party - who in the end IS the only one who can make things different for herself and for her daughter.
Does any of that make sense? I've been reading this thread and the other one for months and the OP continues to blame everything and everyone for what's going on - she cannot seem to see herself as anything but a victim, and although her situation is horrifying, she isn't just a victim - and it's damaging to concur with this.
She has the power to do things to help, once she finds a way to do this - but putting it all at the feet of mental health professionals isn't going to get her anywhere, because basically they won't save her. They nevr do - they will do so much and then you're on your own.
The sooner people realise this, the quicker their recovery will be. Though as I said, it can't be forced. And it's unpleasant to realise.
I am very, very sorry for the OP but I won't sit here telling her that yes, everything is conspiring against her, because that's not true and it's not helpful.
I'm not singling you out in any respect Rowingboat, just the general tone of the thread has been like this and it's frustrating to watch.
I'm really sorry if this offends anyone, that's not the intention. But 'support' is not always straightforward.
Thankyou if you have read this, it's not meant as an attack on anyone - that would be pointless. just a viewpoint about helping people...I just want to help.