Please or to access all these features

Brexit

What shall we call the return?

158 replies

SevenYellowHammers · 30/09/2026 18:17

Briturn? Britsin? Britback?

or just a big dose of humble pie?

OP posts:
NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:22

DarkForces · 30/09/2026 20:04

I'm sure you are more eloquent than me, but I am a European citizen. I like being part of something bigger. I like freedom and opportunity and peace. The eu represents that to me.

Even if the 'bigger thing' is failing, will cost us a fortune and take us back years?

GentleSheep · Yesterday 09:31

BeMoreBear · Yesterday 08:26

He'll need a mandate first, if he's going to try to push rejoining without a referendum (at least that's the democratic thing to do). So that means calling and winning the next election. Given where Labour and Reform are in the polls, if Burnham takes Labour into an election based even partly on rejoining the EU, there is a real chance that we would end up with a Reform minority government.

And if Burnham tries to do this without a mandate... well the 2011 riots come to mind. There are a lot of very unhappy, unsettled people out there who would relish the opportunity.

Yes true, he'd need to win an election.

InMySpareTime · Yesterday 09:33

If it takes ten years to rejoin, it would be 20 years since the original referendum which would still respect the “once in a generation vote” rhetoric.

TemporarilyCantDoMyself · Yesterday 09:41

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:22

Even if the 'bigger thing' is failing, will cost us a fortune and take us back years?

Are you a Russian bot? 😂

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:53

No. Just a UK citizen who can spot the bleedin obvious.

Why join a failing economy that's trillions in debt?
Why open our borders to anyone when most people want to 'stop the boats'

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 09:55

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:53

No. Just a UK citizen who can spot the bleedin obvious.

Why join a failing economy that's trillions in debt?
Why open our borders to anyone when most people want to 'stop the boats'

Some people seem to believe it's some sort of socialist paradise.

Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 10:01

I think because it’s a union people think it’s all happy clappy. It was set up to stop the different countries kicking the shit out of each other right enough and it has been successful in that to date but it doesn’t seem to be stopping individual countries moving rightward.

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:07

Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 10:01

I think because it’s a union people think it’s all happy clappy. It was set up to stop the different countries kicking the shit out of each other right enough and it has been successful in that to date but it doesn’t seem to be stopping individual countries moving rightward.

Also for the post war domination of France and Germany in Europe. Adenauer also feared the rise of the trade unions, so free movement of workers would undercut wages and lower the chances of strike action. You could bring in cheap labour from weaker economies and cut costs.

PollyBell · Yesterday 10:09

Brexinandoutshakeitalllabout

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:29

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:53

No. Just a UK citizen who can spot the bleedin obvious.

Why join a failing economy that's trillions in debt?
Why open our borders to anyone when most people want to 'stop the boats'

The borders wouldn’t be “open to everyone” there would be movement for people with European Passports but, as it was before, it would be monitored. The small boats problem has got worse since Brexit. I was disappointed by the EU’s response to the refugee crisis when we were part of it. It will get much worse with climate changes and I do believe within the EU UK could work well for a better and more coordinated approach.

OP posts:
SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:30

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 09:22

Even if the 'bigger thing' is failing, will cost us a fortune and take us back years?

Brexit cost a fortune and took us back years.

OP posts:
Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 10:31

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:07

Also for the post war domination of France and Germany in Europe. Adenauer also feared the rise of the trade unions, so free movement of workers would undercut wages and lower the chances of strike action. You could bring in cheap labour from weaker economies and cut costs.

Was this why Tony Benn wasn’t a fan?

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:32

Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 10:31

Was this why Tony Benn wasn’t a fan?

Exactly. Also Jeremy Corbyn, a critic all his political life until he became Labour Party leader.

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:33

Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 10:31

Was this why Tony Benn wasn’t a fan?

It’s a market liberalist organisation not a “socialist paradise”

OP posts:
CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:34

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:33

It’s a market liberalist organisation not a “socialist paradise”

No indeed. Very much not about the workers.

notanothernamesurely · Yesterday 10:34

Brenter?

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:40

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:32

Exactly. Also Jeremy Corbyn, a critic all his political life until he became Labour Party leader.

Corbyn’s approach was halfhearted to the extreme.

I was swayed by Leftxit (sp?) myself but in the end couldn’t come to terms with aligning myself with Farage et al.

I had to vote because women fought for the right but I voted Remain with a heavy heart and wished it was a question I hadn’t been asked.

I had no concept of how it would tear this country up economically and socially.

Life long Labour supporter and always will be but they did us a great disservice by not getting behind remain campaign.

OP posts:
TemporarilyCantDoMyself · Yesterday 10:43

Europe definitely isn't perfect.
But; Russia wanted Brexit.
Russia helped engineer Brexit.
Russia spread propaganda in favour of Brexit.
Russia benefits from Brexit.
Russia benefits from a divided Europe.
And Russia, Russia, Russia- Trump.
So if you like democracy, if you don't much like Putin on the one hand and Trump on the other, we're better in.

CatrionaBalfour · Yesterday 10:45

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:40

Corbyn’s approach was halfhearted to the extreme.

I was swayed by Leftxit (sp?) myself but in the end couldn’t come to terms with aligning myself with Farage et al.

I had to vote because women fought for the right but I voted Remain with a heavy heart and wished it was a question I hadn’t been asked.

I had no concept of how it would tear this country up economically and socially.

Life long Labour supporter and always will be but they did us a great disservice by not getting behind remain campaign.

I think Margaret Thatcher's approach was interesting, she was a huge supporter of the EU for obvious reasons (trade union power, cheap labour etc) but didn't want full economic union, and of course, famously reduced UK contributions. Her reflections on it are interesting.
Yes, it's a right wing project, but Labour, officially always thought it was in the UK's interests. Not those on the Left such as Tony Benn of course.
Many European nations have moved to the Right. We'll see what happens.

Badbadbunny · Yesterday 11:08

BeMoreBear · Yesterday 08:26

He'll need a mandate first, if he's going to try to push rejoining without a referendum (at least that's the democratic thing to do). So that means calling and winning the next election. Given where Labour and Reform are in the polls, if Burnham takes Labour into an election based even partly on rejoining the EU, there is a real chance that we would end up with a Reform minority government.

And if Burnham tries to do this without a mandate... well the 2011 riots come to mind. There are a lot of very unhappy, unsettled people out there who would relish the opportunity.

Brexit was the culmination of decades of politicians taking us into the EU without a referendum. What the public voted for in the 70s was the EEC - a trading community. We never voted for closer links in terms of justice, defence, immigration, single currency, etc etc. Teresa May was trying to get agreement to get back to something like the EEC but MPs of both parties voted against her, and we ended up with a "Hard" Brexit.

It would be a VERY foolish politician to try to do anything beyond a return to a kind of EEC ie limited to a customs union. They and their party would be out for potentially decades and it would leave a virtual open door for Reform.

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 11:08

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:29

The borders wouldn’t be “open to everyone” there would be movement for people with European Passports but, as it was before, it would be monitored. The small boats problem has got worse since Brexit. I was disappointed by the EU’s response to the refugee crisis when we were part of it. It will get much worse with climate changes and I do believe within the EU UK could work well for a better and more coordinated approach.

France will give all the people waiting at the Calais camps travel documents ( virtually a passport or temporary passport) which will allow them to travel to the UK in the normal ways. Once in the UK, they will 'disappear' into society as they do now - but the volume of people coming over will be huge

France solve their problem overnight!

No wonder they want us back in

You'll also have the Polish gangs moving back in and taking over the drug lines from the Albanians. It will be utter carnage!

Badbadbunny · Yesterday 11:11

EEexpat · Yesterday 08:57

Watch the BBC QT episode 24 September 2026. Andrew Neil provided a good list of reasons why the UK would not benefit from rejoin the EU.

Jonathan Reynolds, Labour, also spoke well. Being in the EU didn’t solve UK
problems. So, rejoin wouldn’t solve them either.

For those who get excited about a rejoin, remember the following:

To trigger article 49 requires a vote by MPs. Do all Labour MPs have proof that a rejoin will make the UK better off than now?

UK has outgrown, Germany, France and Italy since leaving the EU.

UK has lower immigration than, Germany, France , Spain and Italy.

UK has lower US tariffs than the EU.

The EU would be forced to offer a deal that is less favourable than before.

The Remoaners don't want to listen to facts.

NoisyBrickDog · Yesterday 11:14

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:30

Brexit cost a fortune and took us back years.

How has it cost us a fortune when they are 15 trillion in debt and our economy is better then any of their member countries - including France, Germany, Italy?

And we have far better trade deals with the US - and virtually the same trade deals with Japan, Australia, New Zealand, India

Meandthegherkin · Yesterday 11:22

There was some analysis that said trade friction had hit GDP. I sceptical about forecasts as I used to work in finance and I’ve never seen an accurate forecast, if the general direction of travel was as forecast that was perceived as a win. I was a remainer and would be again for selfish reasons as it rejoining the EU would probably directly benefit me and mine but the fact that our economic growth has outperformed France and Germany since 2016 is more relevant to me than analysts hypothesising an alternative.

NetballHoop · Yesterday 11:24

Tixerb

I'd rejoin in a heartbeat.